search

tronprotocol / tips

TRON Improvement Proposals
229 stars 203 forks source link

Why the tips is ordered by tip number, not by created time? #666

Closed abn2357 closed 3 months ago

abn2357 commented 3 months ago

It seems more reasonable to order tips by created time. Developers can track the latest tips.

hitlxy commented 3 months ago

@abn2357 In my opinion, TIP file should be name with its unique identifier, that is TIP number. When we talk about a TIP, or search a TIP, it is very convenient to use the TIP number directly.

The files in all repository are sorted alphabetically based on the file name.

I always find the latest tips through TIP/proposals page or the tip issues page, because they are usually the most popular and discussed recently, or the tips that have just been launched on TRON mainnet.

abn2357 commented 3 months ago

@abn2357 In my opinion, TIP file should be name with its unique identifier, that is TIP number. When we talk about a TIP, or search a TIP, it is very convenient to use the TIP number directly.

The files in all repository are sorted alphabetically based on the file name.

I always find the latest tips through TIP/proposals page or the tip issues page, because they are usually the most popular and discussed recently, or the tips that have just been launched on TRON mainnet.

@hitlxy

截屏2024-07-08 16 52 02

As the above image show, important tips(Proposals) are not ordered by tip number(column of TIP LINK), it looks good. I think it maybe good to order tips of Tips Guide(image below) by creating time or maintain a list of latest tips ordered by creating time like Proposals. It will be friendly to users and developers.

截屏2024-07-08 16 47 54
abn2357 commented 3 months ago

@hitlxy All tips are ordered alphabetically, tips of Tips Guide are ordered by tip number(as a int not as str), it is confused. Also users can not get the latest tips by any one of the two orders.

L-Reid commented 3 months ago

@abn2357 There are many ways to display the table, but sorting the table by tip number will make it easier for us to find any tip and get the detailed information of it.

For the latest tips, we can get from Java-tron releases and TIP issues. Any Java-tron release may include several tips, any TIP will be discussed at TIP issues page, so we can get the latest tips from the latest release or TIP issues.

TARNA95 commented 3 months ago

AccessKey_5923321054688334.csv

Saraeutsza commented 3 months ago

https://github.com/tronprotocol/tips/issues/666#issuecomment-2241246094