tdarr-node outdated compared to tdarr

tws101 commented 1 year ago

App Name

tdarr-node

SCALE Version

22.12.0

Train Name

stable

App Version

'Tdarr-node' 2.00.19.1_5.0.11 and 'Tdarr' 2.00.20.1_5.0.12

Latest Available Container Version

2.00.20.1

Link to Container https://github.com/truecharts/containers/pkgs/container/tdarr_node

Additional Context

The True charts app "Tdarr" has been updated to application version 2.00.20.1 Seen here https://truecharts.org/charts/stable/tdarr/

The True Charts app 'Tdarr-node' is still on the old application version version 2.00.19.1 Seen here https://truecharts.org/charts/stable/tdarr-node/

If I update my Tdarr server "Tdarr" app which is running on 2.00.19.1_5.0.9 OLD version the main application will be moved to current ( 2.00.20.1 ) and the "Tdarr-node" application is still back on 2.00.19.1 which is NOT compatible

*** I am resolving my issue currently by NOT updating "Tdarr" so the "Tdarr-nodes" will all still work, BUT if I was doing a fresh install this would not be an option and the "Tdarr-Node" app would not work

Resolution being requests in the application "Tdarr-node" to be updated to Application Version 2.00.20.1

I've read and agree with the following

[X] I've checked all open and closed issues and my issue is not there.

tws101 commented 1 year ago

Link to Container https://github.com/truecharts/containers/pkgs/container/tdarr_node

Sorry I missed that when I filled it out

jwynn6 commented 1 year ago

+1 I'm having the same issue.

mhos commented 1 year ago

I setup Tdarr for the first time and then just found this out. Kind of hurts. Stumbling through setup only to find the Stable release of server is 20.00.20 and node is 20.00.19. I appreciate all the hard work keeping these things up to date just sad I cannot use it because of version mismatch. Know its not TC issue on that but would think releasing matching versions of server and node at the same time would be a thing to do.

tws101 commented 1 year ago

I setup Tdarr for the first time and then just found this out. Kind of hurts. Stumbling through setup only to find the Stable release of server is 20.00.20 and node is 20.00.19. I appreciate all the hard work keeping these things up to date just sad I cannot use it because of version mismatch. Know its not TC issue on that but would think releasing matching versions of server and node at the same time would be a thing to do.

Could not agree more... I still need the nodes updated as I am forced to use the old version of tdarr... People keep saying on the discord that "You don't need nodes, just use the internal" that idea fails to understand that with a server rack you run ONE Tdarr and MANY nodes

PrivatePuffin commented 1 year ago

+1 I'm having the same issue.

OBVIOUSLY you have, because the issue is still open. Never make +1 comments.

PrivatePuffin commented 1 year ago

I setup Tdarr for the first time and then just found this out. Kind of hurts. Stumbling through setup only to find the Stable release of server is 20.00.20 and node is 20.00.19. I appreciate all the hard work keeping these things up to date just sad I cannot use it because of version mismatch. Know its not TC issue on that but would think releasing matching versions of server and node at the same time would be a thing to do.

Could not agree more... I still need the nodes updated as I am forced to use the old version of tdarr... People keep saying on the discord that "You don't need nodes, just use the internal" that idea fails to understand that with a server rack you run ONE Tdarr and MANY nodes

That's because most of our users use TrueNAS SCALE, if you use something else (that is multi-node) please be explicit about it. It takes time for the community to adapt to us supporting other platforms.

@stavros-k with the multi-pod changes, shouldn't this be relatively easy to merge into a single chart btw?

mhos commented 1 year ago

Thank you Ornias1993, I'm still new to all this and really do appreciate the work of all who are involved. I am using TN SCALE just setting up the tdarr server and tdarr-node on the same server from the apps section. Happily waiting for update to tdarr-node.

tws101 commented 1 year ago

I setup Tdarr for the first time and then just found this out. Kind of hurts. Stumbling through setup only to find the Stable release of server is 20.00.20 and node is 20.00.19. I appreciate all the hard work keeping these things up to date just sad I cannot use it because of version mismatch. Know its not TC issue on that but would think releasing matching versions of server and node at the same time would be a thing to do.

Could not agree more... I still need the nodes updated as I am forced to use the old version of tdarr... People keep saying on the discord that "You don't need nodes, just use the internal" that idea fails to understand that with a server rack you run ONE Tdarr and MANY nodes

That's because most of our users use TrueNAS SCALE, if you use something else (that is multi-node) please be explicit about it. It takes time for the community to adapt to us supporting other platforms.

@stavros-k with the multi-pod changes, shouldn't this be relatively easy to merge into a single chart btw?

All the servers in question are using TrueNas Scale.... When you have a rack with 5 Truenas Scale servers and three servers have video cards to run Tdarr conversions you use the node on all but one server meaning the main server has the internal node and the other 4 truenas servers all just have the node installed

RinnosukeETQW commented 1 year ago

I setup Tdarr for the first time and then just found this out. Kind of hurts. Stumbling through setup only to find the Stable release of server is 20.00.20 and node is 20.00.19. I appreciate all the hard work keeping these things up to date just sad I cannot use it because of version mismatch. Know its not TC issue on that but would think releasing matching versions of server and node at the same time would be a thing to do.

Could not agree more... I still need the nodes updated as I am forced to use the old version of tdarr... People keep saying on the discord that "You don't need nodes, just use the internal" that idea fails to understand that with a server rack you run ONE Tdarr and MANY nodes

That's because most of our users use TrueNAS SCALE, if you use something else (that is multi-node) please be explicit about it. It takes time for the community to adapt to us supporting other platforms. @stavros-k with the multi-pod changes, shouldn't this be relatively easy to merge into a single chart btw?

All the servers in question are using TrueNas Scale.... When you have a rack with 5 Truenas Scale servers and three servers have video cards to run Tdarr conversions you use the node on all but one server meaning the main server has the internal node and the other 4 truenas servers all just have the node installed

Also useful if you want to use both QSV and an Nvidia card.

PrivatePuffin commented 1 year ago

I setup Tdarr for the first time and then just found this out. Kind of hurts. Stumbling through setup only to find the Stable release of server is 20.00.20 and node is 20.00.19. I appreciate all the hard work keeping these things up to date just sad I cannot use it because of version mismatch. Know its not TC issue on that but would think releasing matching versions of server and node at the same time would be a thing to do.

Could not agree more... I still need the nodes updated as I am forced to use the old version of tdarr... People keep saying on the discord that "You don't need nodes, just use the internal" that idea fails to understand that with a server rack you run ONE Tdarr and MANY nodes

That's because most of our users use TrueNAS SCALE, if you use something else (that is multi-node) please be explicit about it. It takes time for the community to adapt to us supporting other platforms. @stavros-k with the multi-pod changes, shouldn't this be relatively easy to merge into a single chart btw?

All the servers in question are using TrueNas Scale.... When you have a rack with 5 Truenas Scale servers and three servers have video cards to run Tdarr conversions you use the node on all but one server meaning the main server has the internal node and the other 4 truenas servers all just have the node installed

Also useful if you want to use both QSV and an Nvidia card.

Don't spam obvious info.

PrivatePuffin commented 1 year ago

I setup Tdarr for the first time and then just found this out. Kind of hurts. Stumbling through setup only to find the Stable release of server is 20.00.20 and node is 20.00.19. I appreciate all the hard work keeping these things up to date just sad I cannot use it because of version mismatch. Know its not TC issue on that but would think releasing matching versions of server and node at the same time would be a thing to do.

Could not agree more... I still need the nodes updated as I am forced to use the old version of tdarr... People keep saying on the discord that "You don't need nodes, just use the internal" that idea fails to understand that with a server rack you run ONE Tdarr and MANY nodes

That's because most of our users use TrueNAS SCALE, if you use something else (that is multi-node) please be explicit about it. It takes time for the community to adapt to us supporting other platforms. @stavros-k with the multi-pod changes, shouldn't this be relatively easy to merge into a single chart btw?

All the servers in question are using TrueNas Scale.... When you have a rack with 5 Truenas Scale servers and three servers have video cards to run Tdarr conversions you use the node on all but one server meaning the main server has the internal node and the other 4 truenas servers all just have the node installed

Honestly: Don't use TrueNAS SCALE if you need anywhere close to clustering. None of our Apps take it into account for TrueNAS SCALE deployments, it really is single-node-only. Both from iX' perspective and ours as well (when it comes to TrueNAS SCALE, more is possible with helm and truecharts directly).

Simply put: You picked the wrong OS for your usecase. Tdarr node was never added as a seperate App to do what you're doing, but was added because we had technical difficulties at the time combining the two.

PrivatePuffin commented 1 year ago

Locking due to the insane amount of comments just explaining usecases. your personal usecases have nothing to do with this bugreport, the cause is clear, no discussion is warranted.

truecharts / public