search

tsalvo / nes-emu-ios

NES Emulator for iOS / iPadOS / macOS / tvOS, written in Swift
MIT License
134 stars 17 forks source link

Hash set filtering #132

Closed upintheairsheep closed 2 months ago

upintheairsheep commented 2 months ago

This app was recently pulled from the App Store in fear. To prevent piracy and allow the app on the App Store again, implement a hash-set containing all commercially released NES games, and on the App Store version, when a pirated (or legally dumped) ROM is uploaded, to prevent piracy, an anti-piracy screen comes up, and if a homebrew game is loaded, it will run. The emulator can then be uploaded back onto the App Store. This change should be on a separate branch for the App Store release, as GitHub compilers and users are more likely to have a device to dump legally obtained cartridges. To get the hash list, contact NO-INTRO on Discord, a collective that privately has an archive of cartridge games.

tsalvo commented 2 months ago

Thank you for the good suggestion. There might still be some slightly-modified-but-not-broken ROMs that would make it through, but the app would at least be making a reasonable effort to prevent it.

I don't plan on releasing it again, but I do appreciate the suggestion

upintheairsheep commented 2 months ago

Why won’t you re-release it, if there is no piracy problem, there is no DRM-breaking that emulators that target newer consoles use.

On Tuesday, April 16, 2024, Tom Salvo @.***> wrote:

Thank you for the good suggestion. There might still be some slightly-modified-but-not-broken ROMs that would make it through, but the app would at least be making a reasonable effort to prevent it.

I don't plan on releasing it again, but I do appreciate the suggestion

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/tsalvo/nes-emu-ios/issues/132#issuecomment-2060211215, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AKNKRXFN5AU45R5JG46MW5LY5XKZRAVCNFSM6AAAAABGKB3NUOVHI2DSMVQWIX3LMV43OSLTON2WKQ3PNVWWK3TUHMZDANRQGIYTCMRRGU . You are receiving this because you authored the thread.Message ID: @.***>

tsalvo commented 2 months ago

I know that technically you're right, and it shouldn't be an issue. I'm sorry to have let you and others down.

tsalvo commented 2 months ago

Also, that's not to say someone else couldn't take this code and try to release it themselves. It's a very permissive MIT license. I just realized after today that I really, really don't want to be that person

TCB13 commented 2 months ago

@tsalvo thank you for the initial release on the App Store. I understand your fears and while I believe @upintheairsheep suggestion makes the emulator very useless I also know that there are other emulators on the App Store that do what yours does and nobody got into trouble.

To be fair, I was perfectly fine with paying 10$ for your emulator on the App Store, just so it could be accessible from any iOS device and will be updated in the future.

I know this has some legal details, but you aren't providing ROMs so no copyright infringement, if it goes bad in some way, well, Apple takes it down and we all move on.

I hope you reconsider your position and offer this on the App Store again.

Thank you.