search

tsightler / ring-mqtt

Ring devices to MQTT Bridge
MIT License
603 stars 106 forks source link

Choppy audio in Homekit #795

Closed miwagner1 closed 8 months ago

miwagner1 commented 8 months ago

Describe the Bug

Choppy audio in Homekit

Steps to Reproduce

ring-mqtt > go2rtc > Home Assistant > homekit

Expected Behavior

audio to not be choppy

Log Output

Go2rtc v1.8.5 - 2024-01-01 Fixes the issue

Add support Rockchip hardware transcoding #768 by @MarcA711
Add support OPUS codec for MPEG-TS source #788
Add log viewer to WebUI #780 by @skrashevich
Add support subtype for Tapo source #792
Add error for wrong HomeKit source #805
Add support H265 to FLV source #822
Ensure exit code is within valid range #785 by @skrashevich
Fix buggy SDP from D-Link cameras #771
Fix support FFmpeg device on Windows #794
Fix CORS support in WHEP/WHIP API #798 by @MPTres
Fix H265 support from OpenIPC project
Fix exec source leaves zombie processes after fail #814
Fix hardware profiles for H265 templates #809 by @MPTres
Fix OPUS choppy audio for HomeKit server #667 #843 by @civita
Fix mdns log message #843 by @civita
Fix support Aqara G2H #793 by @duncanleo
Fix panic on reconnect #828

Screenshots

No response

Config File

Go2rtc v1.8.5 - 2024-01-01 Fixes the issue

Add support Rockchip hardware transcoding #768 by @MarcA711
Add support OPUS codec for MPEG-TS source #788
Add log viewer to WebUI #780 by @skrashevich
Add support subtype for Tapo source #792
Add error for wrong HomeKit source #805
Add support H265 to FLV source #822
Ensure exit code is within valid range #785 by @skrashevich
Fix buggy SDP from D-Link cameras #771
Fix support FFmpeg device on Windows #794
Fix CORS support in WHEP/WHIP API #798 by @MPTres
Fix H265 support from OpenIPC project
Fix exec source leaves zombie processes after fail #814
Fix hardware profiles for H265 templates #809 by @MPTres
Fix OPUS choppy audio for HomeKit server #667 #843 by @civita
Fix mdns log message #843 by @civita
Fix support Aqara G2H #793 by @duncanleo
Fix panic on reconnect #828

Install Type

docker

Version

5.6.3

Operating System

Fedora IoT

Architecture

x86_64

Machine Details

n100

tsightler commented 8 months ago

I don't really understand what you are posting. You posted about go2rtc versions, but you can use whatever version of go2rtc you like, including the latest version, although I think that fix is only for the case where HomeKit is served directly from go2rtc, while you are using Home Assistant to expose the device to HomeKit.

Regardless, none of this has anything to do with ring-mqtt itself, it simply passes through the RTP packets containing Opus audio from the Ring cameras directly, without any manipulation at all. Homekit has very specific requirements for Opus audio to work correctly without being choppy, so it's up to whatever is provides the bridge to Homekit to deal with that.