search

tsunamayo / Starship-EVO

Welcome to Starship EVO bug tracking repo !
117 stars 17 forks source link

[BUG] Curved blocks have wonky hitboxes #5322

Open TIKIRobo opened 12 months ago

TIKIRobo commented 12 months ago

yes this is just a repeat of #5230 sorry

image curved hollow blocks have weird placement issues, the individual ones work but when stretched or at a higher scale they "clip"

image cubes don't work at all

image image wedges and arches need a significant gap limiting their use

image can't make things flush, I would like to either for a rounded blast door or since we don't have rounded decals yet it could be a neat way to do something similar in the meantime

image this issue seems to only apply to the insides of some the curved blocks

https://github.com/tsunamayo/Starship-EVO/assets/56371294/44f6e78a-439e-46dd-913f-ae3f8fa7abab

arch rounded corner has improper mirroring

Starship EVO 11_4_2023 3_45_38 PM Starship EVO 11_4_2023 3_45_50 PM

Starship EVO 10_30_2023 3_38_17 PM I recently started building with these curved blocks a lot recently but it wasn't until i started building these smaller robots (3m tall ish) that i noticed the issues with the hitboxes, I would love it if they could be improved so that we can build more complex and interesting round ships/building/whatever, also while im here would it be possible to add some sort of hollow arch block but with the tip cut off?
image ik this picture isn't great but i would love to be able to make hollow spheres that people could actually get into without having to split open the ball from time to time

CoasterBlock commented 12 months ago

I encountered this too! I was able to partly bypass this by clipping, but thats not a satisfying "solution" It seems when the brick is streched, that the center point-of-origin is the main "collision" box.

ProPeach commented 12 months ago

I hadn't noticed the mirroring bug, great spot! To turn this into a bit of a megathread for the rounded bricks, there are also these issues -

5022 - Rounded Arch/Arch Corners are locked to a 1x1 stretch ratio

5272 - Blocks with round faces in general missed out on the improvements made in #5228 which interrupts their smoothness

These issues and especially the ones Tiki mention all add up to make the rounded bricks a pretty inconsistent experience compared to the rest of the bricks in sevo, which is a real shame as they're a fantastic shape

ProPeach commented 12 months ago

ik this picture isn't great but i would love to be able to make hollow spheres that people could actually get into without having to split open the ball from time to time

Made a quick mockup of Tiki's shape suggestion for fun, it's a bit weird in terms of how it'd work ingame, but cool looking image image To get the hollow part in the middle looking good, it'd have have a base size of 0.5m radius even at 1/8th scale