tsvwg / draft-ietf-tsvwg-udp-options

0 stars 0 forks source link

* Section 22: should compare TCP and UDP #11

Closed gorryfair closed 9 months ago

gorryfair commented 1 year ago

Erik: > * Section 22: The second paragraph seems intended to compare UDP options

with TCP options, but it uses only "UDP", resulting in the tautology that the UDP security implications are not substantially different from security implications of UDP options:

OLD:

Note that any user application that considers UDP options to affect security need not enable them. However, their use does not impact security in a way substantially different than UDP options;

NEW:

Note that any user application that considers UDP options to affect security need not enable them. However, their use does not impact security in a way substantially different than TCP options;

This issue was first raised in https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/tsvwg/ocDWz4jWZdqVP6CTuAhsBXer2Bc/ and also at earlier stages.

jtouch commented 9 months ago

Fixed in -23.

gorryfair commented 9 months ago

Discussed at Interim and closed.