search

tt-acm / DynamoSAP

Dynamo <> SAP interoperability.
Other
29 stars 19 forks source link

We need Update nodes for elements (frame,shell etc) ! #30

Open eertugrul opened 9 years ago

eertugrul commented 9 years ago

One of the workflows we have discussed beginning of this project: for SAP > Dynamo > SAP I think we need also update nodes to modify structural elements in Dynamo ! we have only Frame.Decompose node so we can watch the properties of each element after we read from SAP but actually we don't to update any of object properties in Dynamo now. I think we need Frame.Update nodes

Scenario one:

input Frame as Element (read from SAP) -Line or EndPoints

Scenario Two:

I wish we were able to make some of these input as 'optional' somehow in Dynamo. If this is not happening we might to create individual nodes for each updates such as Frame.Update (for just geometry) get either Line or end Points ) / UpdateSectionprop etc.

Any thoughts on this ? we can also name as 'Modify' !

bhowes-tt commented 9 years ago

I'm going to call this a wish for now... As per our discussion today, we are already able to update things like groups and loads and stuff, but [probably] not geometry. We should test and make sure this is the case.

And in the future if everyone says they need geometrical update components we can revisit this.

anagpuyol commented 9 years ago

In my tests today with read and edit sample, I have seen that this is possible. In terms of getting updated from SAP2000, it is about running the 'Read' component again (set boolean to false, then run Dynamo, set it to true, run again).

bhowes-tt commented 9 years ago

@anagpuyol - to confirm... we can update a sap model in dynamo? Read from sap > edit geometry > bake back to sap??

anagpuyol commented 9 years ago

To clarify this: we need update nodes to update the geometry of objects read from SAP

bhowes-tt commented 9 years ago

got it. That's what we thought.