search

tum-gis / citygml2-to-citygml3

A small Java program used to transform CityGML v2.0 to CityGML v3.0 files.
MIT License
13 stars 6 forks source link

gml IDs for semantics #7

Open RushiHFT opened 1 year ago

RushiHFT commented 1 year ago

Hello Developers,

I realised that the gml ID of semantic objects (e.g. RoofSurface, WallSurface, InteriorWallSurface etc) are dropped when converting from CityGML 2 to 3 using this tool despite being available in CityGML ver. 2 file. The same behaviour is seen in the sample dataset available in the output folder, and also most of the other CityGML v3 example dataset. Due to this, software like FME generates its own gml IDs and this creates issues if I want to integrate/join other attributes in CityGML 3 file using gml IDs of semantic objects as they are not available.

Can you guide me more on this issue ?

Thanks and best regards, Rushi

thomashkolbe commented 1 year ago

Hi, unfortunately we currently cannot spend time on bugfixing or further extending this tool.

However, there is now a usable replacement of our tool available, developed by Claus Nagel: https://github.com/citygml4j/citygml-tools The citygml4j tools are built into a Java command line processing tool that (among other functionalities) allows to upgrade CityGML 2 to CityGML 3 files. It should not have the problem that you indicated above.

Best regards Thomas Kolbe

RushiHFT commented 1 year ago

Dear Professor Dr. Kolbe,

thank you so much for your answer and guidance.

Best Regards, Rushi

From: Thomas H. Kolbe @.***> Sent: 06 February 2023 12:03:08 To: tum-gis/citygml2-to-citygml3 Cc: Rushikesh Padsala (Rushi); Author Subject: [EXTERN!]Re: [tum-gis/citygml2-to-citygml3] gml IDs for semantics (Issue #7)  

Hi, unfortunately we currently cannot spend time on bugfixing or further extending this tool. However, there is now a usable replacement of our tool available, developed by Claus Nagel: https://github.com/citygml4j/citygml-tools The citygml4j tools are built into a Java command line processing tool that (among other functionalities) allows to upgrade CityGML 2 to CityGML 3 files. It should not have the problem that you indicated above. Best regards Thomas Kolbe — Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe. You are receiving this because you authored the thread.Message ID: @.***>