search

tuya / tuya-homebridge

Homebridge custom plugin for controlling Powered by Tuya (PBT) devices in HomeKit. This plugin is officially maintained by the Tuya Developer Team.
MIT License
332 stars 168 forks source link

Garage door change state not synchronized in homeKit (open/close/opening/closing) #287

Closed pacooka closed 1 year ago

pacooka commented 1 year ago

When using a garage a door opener controller, PBT, i.e. PBT ZigBee or PBT WiFi garage door opener (https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005003635582496.html or https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005003222899297.html ) Open /Close state not updating correctly.

Scenario to reproduce the bug:

  1. Install PBT garage door opener, Zigbee or WiFi, make sure to connect correctly the open/close sensor, Bring the sensor closer to simulate a close door state.
  2. Use latest ios16 Tuya app and bind the garage door to the app.
  3. Use Homebridge and install the plugin Homebridge-Tuya-Platform V 1.5.0
  4. Open the HomeKit app in ios16 and verify proper garage door opener display correctly, state closed.
  5. In HomeKit press the garage door icon to open the door, move the sensor away to simulated an open door state.
  6. Bring the sensor back closer to simulate a close door state and watch the HomeKit icon, state stuck on opening/closing instead of "closed" + continues multiple messages from the HomeKit app "door closed", "door open" - - > BUG

Impact: wrong behavior on HomeKit app garage icon, state unknown reproduce 1:1 in the described scenario workaround: press several times on the garage door icon in the HomeKit app expected results: I have an Athome garage door opener with homeKit firmware native and it works fine. I believe that the plugin might have some issue with the sensor state.

github-actions[bot] commented 1 year ago

Thank you for your feedback, we will solve this issue soon

0x5e commented 1 year ago

@pacooka Reimplemented Garage door opener in @0x5e/homebridge-tuya-platform v1.6.0-beta.10. Tested with virtual device. Hope it can solve your issue.

ObstructionDetected feature not implemented, it can't be tested with virtual device. could you please try the beta version and open the homebridge debug mode, and upload some logs during the door open and clode? I don't know how countdown_alarm and countdown_1 behaves.

github-actions[bot] commented 1 year ago

Stale issue. we will close the issue soon. If this issue has not been resolved, please update the issue and contact us in time.

pacooka commented 1 year ago

@0x5e Still Reproduce 1:1 in the described scenario, tested on Tuya plugin 1.7 beta 13. with iOS 16.2 Bug still exist, please try to reproduce as described in the scenario, step 6 will fail, status in HomeKit will be continues "Opening..."

0x5e commented 1 year ago

@pacooka Can you provide some debug logs, and device info json during your control? I don't have real device, and the virtual device can't simulate the opening/closing process.

pacooka commented 1 year ago

@pacooka Can you provide some debug logs, and device info json during your control? I don't have real device, and the virtual device can't simulate the opening/closing process.

Yes, can you advise how can i generate the logs? or where can i find them

0x5e commented 1 year ago

@pacooka Can you provide some debug logs, and device info json during your control? I don't have real device, and the virtual device can't simulate the opening/closing process.

Yes, can you advise how can i generate the logs? or where can i find them

Here it is, please see faq and troubleshooting section. https://github.com/0x5e/homebridge-tuya-platform#readme

github-actions[bot] commented 1 year ago

Stale issue. we will close the issue soon. If this issue has not been resolved, please update the issue and contact us in time.

pacooka commented 1 year ago

I'll connect it again and send you the logs during the weekend

pacooka commented 1 year ago

Hi @0x5e , I have the full debug log ready, where can i send you the debug log? it has some private data within, can you please advise with an email address? --Edit: Ok , sent you email with the debug log to - 0x5e@sina.cn

0x5e commented 1 year ago

@pacooka Thanks, the log is good, I will look at it later, sorry recently is always busy...

github-actions[bot] commented 1 year ago

Stale issue. we will close the issue soon. If this issue has not been resolved, please update the issue and contact us in time.

guillochon commented 1 year ago

Not stale

OliPetry commented 3 months ago

Same issue still persisting with 1.7 beta. The only way I can get the status to be correct is if I use only the homekit integration to open and close or press the homekit button several times exactly as original poster described.

pacooka commented 3 months ago

Same issue still persisting with 1.7 beta. The only way I can get the status to be correct is if I use only the homekit integration to open and close or press the homekit button several times exactly as original poster described.

I know, I gave up. Order from the following link, works great with Homekit and only $13 :-) https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005005906164250.html