twbs / bootstrap

The most popular HTML, CSS, and JavaScript framework for developing responsive, mobile first projects on the web.
https://getbootstrap.com
MIT License
169.95k stars 78.74k forks source link

Inability to distinguish between error messages, if colourblind etc #54

Closed jamesweiner closed 13 years ago

jamesweiner commented 13 years ago

Might be a good idea to make the error messages have more colour contrast, and possibly throw in some icons too?

nimbupani commented 13 years ago

Can it be confirmed? I asked @tabatkins and he says it is pretty contrasting to him.

Also, I see no reason why icons would enhance the message.

tabatkins commented 13 years ago

Both the alerts and message blocks are sufficiently contrasting to be easily distinguishable to my brand of color-blindness (moderate blue/green, mild red/green)

fat commented 13 years ago

Icons definitely won't be added because we want to keep this project to a single resource.

We asked a few color bind people around the office -- and they too had no problem with the color contrast.

Closing for now -- feel free to reopen if you find evidence which says otherwise.

stephanerangaya commented 13 years ago

Icons would definitely enhance the message. For people with Protanopia or Deuteranopia (2% of males*), they can't see a difference between a success and a warning. IMO, increasing the contrast will not help, but adding icons will.

Check out these simulations http://imageshack.us/g/40/dys1.png/

(You can try by yourself by downloading this software: http://michelf.com/projects/sim-daltonism/)

fat commented 13 years ago

You can very easily add your own icons -- the alerts are flexible enough for that.

stephanerangaya commented 13 years ago

I agree.