search

typemill / typemill

Typemill is a lightweight, flat-file CMS designed for simple, fast, and flexible website and eBook creation using Markdown.
https://typemill.net
MIT License
427 stars 60 forks source link

Any suggestion for a flat file comment system? #186

Closed Tekl closed 4 months ago

Tekl commented 3 years ago

I came to the point that I want some more interaction on my site. So I thought about adding a comment system. I don't like external providers like Disqus. So I'm looking for a simple self-hosted system. I know about HashOver, but it seems to use a database and is a content managment system by itself. ;-) Maybe someone knows about a more slick php script that fits well into Typemill.

ghost commented 3 years ago

Hi, googling "Self-Hosted Comment System php flat file", as the fourth proposal, simplecommentsystem, I found a very simple solution.

Tekl commented 3 years ago

Thanks. Well, I also found that, but I fear of secuirty issues. It's very old.

trendschau commented 3 years ago

I think pytes made a flat-file-comment-plugin for bludit: https://plugins.bludit.com/ I never tried it but it might be a starting point for a Typemill integration.

An alternative idea was to create a plugin for webmentions. Not exactly comments, but a modern rebirth of trackbacks. This is especially popular in the indieweb-community: https://github.com/typemill/typemill/issues/93

Maybe someone in the community finds time, my roadmap is pretty full with extensions for membership, invoices and pdf-generation right now...

trendschau commented 3 years ago

Another point: Typemill provides public forms that can be defined with yaml: https://typemill.net/forms/public-forms .This logic should be use by a comment plugin, too. An example of it is the contact form plugin that is not published yet, live demo is here: https://trendschau.net/kontakt

Tekl commented 3 years ago

Thanks for the investigation. A comment plugin would be the best solution, I think.

trendschau commented 4 months ago

Not on the near roadmap, so I close it for now, would be a good case for plugin contribution.