search

tyrasd / overpass-turbo

A web based data mining tool for OpenStreetMap using the Overpass API.
https://overpass-turbo.eu
Other
939 stars 134 forks source link

Export as OSM-XML file #104

Open brycenesbitt opened 10 years ago

brycenesbitt commented 10 years ago

When exporting the options I'm given now are:

    as geoJSON  
    as GPX
    as KML
    raw data  (e.g. JSON)
    raw data directly from Overpass API (e.g. also JSON)
    load data into an OSM editor: JOSM, Level0
    save GeoJSON to gist

Would it be possible to add an option to output as ".osm" files (e.g. OSM XML)?

tyrasd commented 10 years ago

You can simply change your query to request OSM XML data (i.e. [out:xml]; or <osm-script output="xml" />), than the export options raw data and raw data from Overpass API will give you the desired OSM XML. As that is only a matter of re-running a query (and implementing an on-the-fly conversion between JSON and XML output sounds cumbersome), this is a wontfix, I'm afraid.

brycenesbitt commented 10 years ago

In terms of capability, that's the right answer. In terms of usability and discover-ability, that's an unfortunate answer. Can't the GUI "do this" in the same way it fixes queries directed at JOSM that don't include "meta"?

tyrasd commented 10 years ago

OK, I think you have a point here. Reopening

drolbr commented 10 years ago

Short remark:

I can assert that removing the first occurence of "[out:json]" from the query does the job. The only corner is an occurence in a comment.