search

u8sand / Baka-MPlayer

The libmpv based media player
https://u8sand.github.io/Baka-MPlayer/
GNU General Public License v2.0
431 stars 93 forks source link

Fullscreen mode is overly always-on-top (windows) #237

Open vith opened 7 years ago

vith commented 7 years ago

Not sure if this is partially intentional, but it causes some issues.

When you alt-tab, the player no longer has focus but stays on top of everything, including the alt-tab UI. So at that point you can no longer exit fullscreen or tell which window actually has focus.

The only reliable way out of this state I found (other than getting lucky alt-tabbing back to the player) is to Ctrl+Alt+Del. For some reason focus always returns to the player when returning out of that special menu.

Similar problems occur when opening the start menu with the Windows key. You can't see it, but it has focus and is accepting input, and the player is not.

OS: Windows 10 Baka-MPlayer: 2.0.4

vith commented 7 years ago

I should mention I have the On Top preference set to Never.

u8sand commented 7 years ago

So if I understand correctly: Alt-tab from Full screen mode causes this issue? Does this occur only when the video continues to be played in fullscreen mode?

vith commented 7 years ago

Yes, it only happens in fullscreen mode and the video keeps playing the whole time.

  1. start playing video
  2. enter fullscreen with keybind
  3. alt-tab (can't see the alt-tab UI but it still changes window focus)
  4. video is still fullscreen and still playing
  5. try to exit fullscreen mode with any of {same keybind, escape key, double click}, doesn't work because player doesn't have focus
u8sand commented 7 years ago

I'm under the impression this might be caused by mpv not paying attention to our window's focus. I imagine when we move to a shared gl context with mpv this will be resolved. I hate to say that this won't happen today, but rest assured we're working on it.