ua-snap / northern-climate-reports

MIT License
2 stars 0 forks source link

These locations are probably missing GIPL - how to handle? #189

Closed charparr closed 2 years ago

charparr commented 2 years ago

I’d expect these locations to lack GIPL data and have a chart failure because of the GIPL grid misses. They all seem to be coastal at first glance. Should these coordinates get bumped, or be should the query be fuzzied with a nearest-neighbor search? This an expansion of #176

id name alt_name latitude longitude api_test
AK2 Akhiok Kasukuak 56.9455 -154.17 fail
AK14 Anchor Point nan 59.7766 -151.831 fail
AK18 Angoon Aangóon 57.5033 -134.584 fail
AK20 Annette nan 55.063 -131.541 fail
AK23 Atka Atx̂ax̂ 52.191 -174.189 fail
AK27 Auke Bay nan 58.383 -134.657 fail
AK32 Belkofski Taxtamax̂ 55.0905 -162.034 fail
AK33 Bell Island Hot Springs nan 55.933 -131.566 fail
AK41 Biorka nan 53.831 -166.208 fail
AK44 Bird Point nan 60.9311 -149.358 fail
AK47 Brevig Mission Sitaisaq 65.3347 -166.489 fail
AK51 Cape Lisburne nan 68.8678 -166.193 fail
AK52 Cape Pole nan 55.965 -133.798 fail
AK53 Cape Yakataga nan 60.0652 -142.428 fail
AK60 Chatham nan 57.514 -134.924 fail
AK63 Chenega Bay Caniqaq 60.0746 -148.003 fail
AK68 Chignik Lagoon Nanwarnaq 56.3104 -158.536 fail
AK446 Chilkat River Critical Habitat Area nan 59.373 -135.86 fail
AK79 Clam Gulch nan 60.2311 -151.394 fail
AK80 Clark's Point Saguyaq 58.8441 -158.551 fail
AK82 Clover Pass nan 55.472 -131.791 fail
AK83 Coffman Cove nan 56.0119 -132.83 fail
AK84 Cohoe nan 60.3671 -151.3 fail
AK89 Cordova nan 60.5428 -145.757 fail
AK91 Craig Sháan Séet 55.4764 -133.148 fail
AK449 Decision Point State Marine Park nan 60.8016 -148.464 fail
AK94 Deering Ipnatchiaq 66.0755 -162.717 fail
AK97 Diomede Iŋaliq 65.7648 -168.911 fail
AK101 Dutch Harbor nan 53.891 -166.535 fail
AK107 Egavik nan 64.0332 -160.917 fail
AK108 Egegik Igyagiiq 58.2155 -157.376 fail
AK109 Egorkovskoi nan 53.564 -168 fail
AK110 Eklutna Idlughet 61.458 -149.362 fail
AK114 Elfin Cove nan 58.1944 -136.343 fail
AK115 Elim Neviarcaurluq 64.6175 -162.26 fail
AK123 Eyak Igya’aq 60.5652 -145.7 fail
AK134 Gambell Sivuqaq 63.7797 -171.741 fail
AK136 Girdwood nan 60.9421 -149.167 fail
AK138 Golovin Cingik / Siŋik 64.5433 -163.029 fail
AK139 Goodnews Bay Mamterat 59.1186 -161.589 fail
AK152 Homer nan 59.6425 -151.548 fail
AK153 Hoonah Xunaa / Gaaw Yat’aḵ Aan 58.11 -135.444 fail
AK154 Hooper Bay Naparyaarmiut 61.5311 -166.097 fail
AK155 Hope nan 60.9203 -149.64 fail
AK159 Hydaburg Higdáa G̱ándlaay 55.208 -132.827 fail
AK163 Ikatan nan 54.75 -163.308 fail
AK166 Indian nan 60.9881 -149.513 fail
AK172 Juneau Dzánti K'ihéeni 58.3019 -134.42 fail
AK176 Kaktovik Qaaktuġvik 70.1319 -143.624 fail
AK181 Karluk Kal’ut 57.5719 -154.455 fail
AK182 Kasaan Gasa'áan 55.5389 -132.401 fail
AK194 King Cove Agdaaĝux̂ 55.0629 -162.31 fail
AK195 King Island Ugiuvak 64.9694 -168.065 fail
AK198 Kivalina Kivaliñiq 67.7269 -164.533 fail
AK200 Klawock Lawaak 55.5522 -133.096 fail
AK203 Knik nan 61.4578 -149.729 fail
AK205 Kodiak Sun'aq 57.79 -152.407 fail
AK211 Kotzebue Qikiqtaġruk 66.8983 -162.597 fail
AK212 Koyuk Kuuyuk 64.9319 -161.157 fail
AK214 Kupreanof nan 56.8153 -133.006 fail
AK215 Kustatan Qezdeghnen 60.7171 -151.75 fail
AK223 Latouche nan 60.0511 -147.9 fail
AK225 Lena Beach nan 58.393 -134.746 fail
AK227 Libbyville nan 58.7781 -157.056 fail
AK243 Meakerville nan 60.5421 -145.008 fail
AK249 Meyers Chuck nan 55.7408 -132.256 fail
AK252 Morzhovoi nan 54.91 -163.303 fail
AK259 Nanwalek English Bay 59.354 -151.916 fail
AK264 Nash Harbor nan 60.2041 -166.939 fail
AK266 Nelson Lagoon Niilsanam Alĝuudaa 56.0012 -161.201 fail
AK273 Nikiski nan 60.6394 -151.334 fail
AK276 Nikolski Chalukax̂ 52.938 -168.868 fail
AK277 Nilikluguk nan 60.6501 -165.15 fail
AK278 Ninilchik nan 60.0514 -151.669 fail
AK298 Ouzinkie Uusenkaa 57.9236 -152.496 fail
AK308 Petersburg Séet Ká 56.8125 -132.955 fail
AK316 Point Hope Tikiġaq 68.3477 -166.808 fail
AK324 Port Lions Masiqsirraq 57.8675 -152.882 fail
AK326 Port Moller nan 55.99 -160.577 fail
AK330 Portlock nan 59.2144 -151.746 fail
AK332 Quinhagak Kuinerraq 59.7489 -161.916 fail
AK336 Refuge Cove nan 55.407 -131.741 fail
AK339 Saint George Anĝaaxchalux̂ 56.603 -169.545 fail
AK342 Saint Paul Tanax̂ Amix̂ 57.1221 -170.276 fail
AK346 Sanak nan 54.4831 -162.814 fail
AK347 Sand Point nan 55.3397 -160.497 fail
AK349 Savoonga Sivunga 63.6904 -170.481 fail
AK350 Saxman nan 55.3183 -131.596 fail
AK352 Selawik Siiḷivik / Akuliġaq 66.6039 -160.007 fail
AK353 Seldovia Angagkitaqnuuq 59.438 -151.711 fail
AK358 Shishmaref Qigiqtaq 66.2567 -166.072 fail
AK369 Spenard nan 61.1881 -149.917 fail
AK370 Squaw Harbor nan 55.2433 -160.553 fail
AK372 Stebbins Tapraq 63.5222 -162.288 fail
AK461 Sunny Cove State Marine Park nan 59.9024 -149.345 fail
AK377 Sunrise nan 60.8921 -149.425 fail
AK386 Tatitlek Taatiilaaq 60.8647 -146.679 fail
AK388 Tee Harbor nan 58.41 -134.757 fail
AK396 Thorne Bay nan 55.7274 -132.471 fail
AK463 Thumb Cove State Marine Park nan 60.004 -149.301 fail
AK397 Tin City nan 65.5502 -167.851 fail
AK400 Tokeen nan 55.938 -133.324 fail
AK401 Toksook Bay Nunakauyaq 60.5303 -165.102 fail
AK406 Tununak Tununeq 60.5855 -165.256 fail
AK408 Tyonek Qaggeyshlat 61.0681 -151.137 fail
AK409 Ugashik Ugaasaq 57.513 -157.397 fail
AK412 Umkumiute nan 60.4983 -165.199 fail
AK413 Umnak nan 53.267 -168.217 fail
AK414 Unalakleet Uŋalaqłiit 63.873 -160.788 fail
AK415 Unalaska Iluulux̂ 53.8733 -166.533 fail
AK416 Unga Uĝnaasaqax̂ 55.1828 -160.506 fail
AK418 Utqiaġvik Barrow 71.2905 -156.789 fail
AK421 Valdez Suacit 61.1369 -146.347 fail
AK423 Wainwright Ulġuniq 70.6369 -160.038 fail
AK425 Ward Cove nan 55.408 -131.724 fail
AK429 Whittier nan 60.773 -148.684 fail
AK433 Woody Island nan 57.78 -152.355 fail
AK434 Wrangell Shtax’héen 56.4708 -132.377 fail
AK464 Ziegler Cove State Marine Park nan 60.8381 -148.321 fail
charparr commented 2 years ago

After interpolating coastward many of the locations now have data. Pending a change to the API we would now expect that all point locations have permafrost data with the exception of the following:

id name latitude longitude http
AK26 Attu 52.9365 173.24 <Response [404]>
AK466 Bogoslof Island Refuge 53.9379 -168.044 <Response [404]>
AK441 Eareckson Air Station 52.7122 174.114 <Response [404]>
AK159 Hydaburg 55.208 -132.827 <Response [200]>
AK453 Joe Mace Island State Marine Park 56.3473 -133.635 <Response [404]>
AK479 Nunivak Island Refuge 59.8228 -165.281 <Response [404]>
AK357 Shemya Station 52.7246 174.112 <Response [404]>

and

id name latitude longitude http
AK97 Diomede 65.7648 -168.911 <Response [200]>
AK176 Kaktovik 70.1319 -143.624 <Response [200]>
AK195 King Island 64.9694 -168.065 <Response [200]>
AK266 Nelson Lagoon 56.0012 -161.201 <Response [200]>
AK316 Point Hope 68.3477 -166.808 <Response [200]>
AK339 Saint George 56.603 -169.545 <Response [200]>
AK484 Shelter Island State Marine Park 58.4513 -134.881 <Response [200]>
AK358 Shishmaref 66.2567 -166.072 <Response [200]>

Some of these (Point Hope, Kaktovik) can be addressed via a coordinate wiggle (https://github.com/ua-snap/geospatial-vector-veracity/issues/58)

charparr commented 2 years ago

Perhaps a good candidate to close via #233 ?

List is now:

id name latitude longitude http
AK26 Attu 52.9365 173.24 404
AK466 Bogoslof Island Refuge 53.9379 -168.044 404
AK441 Eareckson Air Station 52.7122 174.114 404
AK453 Joe Mace Island State Marine Park 56.3473 -133.635 404
AK479 Nunivak Island Refuge 59.8228 -165.281 404
AK357 Shemya Station 52.7246 174.112 404

plus

id name latitude longitude http
AK97 Diomede 65.7648 -168.911 200
AK176 Kaktovik 70.1319 -143.624 200
AK195 King Island 64.9694 -168.065 200
AK266 Nelson Lagoon 56.0012 -161.201 200
AK339 Saint George 56.603 -169.545 200
AK484 Shelter Island State Marine Park 58.4513 -134.881 200
AK358 Shishmaref 66.2567 -166.072 200
cstephen commented 2 years ago

With ef728cdf2f2a4a9bf31ee7532dcb0763fb913b5d, the web app is now handing GIPL null values properly. This ticket is now closeable by #233 (and the PR description has been updated to indicate this).