Larger hit count when adding quotes

[pgwillia]

Describe the bug Larger hit count when adding quotes, e.g. british missions south pacific gives 318 british missions "south pacific" gives 1351 Expected behaviour: adding quotes to a query reduces the number of hits

[pgwillia]

rawquerystring  "british missions \"south pacific\""
querystring "british missions \"south pacific\""
parsedquery "(+(DisjunctionMaxQuery(((subtitle_t:british)^25000.0 | (databasedescription_tesim:british)^50.0 | (gmd_tesim:british)^50.0 | (isbn_t:british)^100000.0 | (lc_callnum_display:british)^100000.0 | (subject_addl_t:british)^50.0 | (title_addl_t:british)^25000.0 | (subject_t:british)^500.0 | (later_title_tesim:british)^25000.0 | (subject_addl_unstem_search:british)^250.0 | (title_series_unstem_search:british)^25.0 | (issn_t:british)^100000.0 | (subject_topic_unstem_search:british)^1000.0 | (title_unstem_search:british)^100000.0 | (awards_note_tesim:british)^25.0 | (section_name_tesim:british)^10.0 | (earlier_title_tesim:british)^25000.0 | (title_addl_unstem_search:british)^25000.0 | (title_t:british)^25000.0 | (title_tesim:british)^100000.0 | (publisher_tesim:british)^1000.0 | (id:british)^100000.0 | (subtitle_unstem_search:british)^100000.0 | (title_series_t:british)^10.0 | (local_note_tesim:british)^25.0 | (author_unstem_search:british)^250.0 | (subject_unstem_search:british)^750.0 | (author_t:british)^100.0 | (author_addl_unstem_search:british)^250.0 | (contents_tesim:british)^50.0 | (author_addl_t:british)^50.0 | (title_added_entry_t:british)^1250.0 | (summary_holdings_tesim:british)^50.0 | (title_added_entry_unstem_search:british)^1500.0 | (section_number_tesim:british)^10.0)~0.01) DisjunctionMaxQuery(((subtitle_t:mission)^25000.0 | (databasedescription_tesim:mission)^50.0 | (gmd_tesim:mission)^50.0 | (isbn_t:mission)^100000.0 | (lc_callnum_display:mission)^100000.0 | (subject_addl_t:mission)^50.0 | (title_addl_t:mission)^25000.0 | (subject_t:mission)^500.0 | (later_title_tesim:mission)^25000.0 | (subject_addl_unstem_search:missions)^250.0 | (title_series_unstem_search:missions)^25.0 | (issn_t:mission)^100000.0 | (subject_topic_unstem_search:missions)^1000.0 | (title_unstem_search:missions)^100000.0 | (awards_note_tesim:mission)^25.0 | (section_name_tesim:mission)^10.0 | (earlier_title_tesim:mission)^25000.0 | (title_addl_unstem_search:missions)^25000.0 | (title_t:mission)^25000.0 | (title_tesim:mission)^100000.0 | (publisher_tesim:mission)^1000.0 | (id:mission)^100000.0 | (subtitle_unstem_search:missions)^100000.0 | (title_series_t:mission)^10.0 | (local_note_tesim:mission)^25.0 | (author_unstem_search:missions)^250.0 | (subject_unstem_search:missions)^750.0 | (author_t:mission)^100.0 | (author_addl_unstem_search:missions)^250.0 | (contents_tesim:mission)^50.0 | (author_addl_t:mission)^50.0 | (title_added_entry_t:mission)^1250.0 | (summary_holdings_tesim:mission)^50.0 | (title_added_entry_unstem_search:missions)^1500.0 | (section_number_tesim:mission)^10.0)~0.01) DisjunctionMaxQuery(((subtitle_t:\"south pacif\")^25000.0 | (databasedescription_tesim:\"south pacif\")^50.0 | (gmd_tesim:\"south pacif\")^50.0 | (isbn_t:\"south pacif\")^100000.0 | (lc_callnum_display:\"south pacif\")^100000.0 | (subject_addl_t:\"south pacif\")^50.0 | (title_addl_t:\"south pacif\")^25000.0 | (subject_t:\"south pacif\")^500.0 | (later_title_tesim:\"south pacif\")^25000.0 | (subject_addl_unstem_search:\"south pacific\")^250.0 | (title_series_unstem_search:\"south pacific\")^25.0 | (issn_t:\"south pacif\")^100000.0 | (subject_topic_unstem_search:\"south pacific\")^1000.0 | (title_unstem_search:\"south pacific\")^100000.0 | (awards_note_tesim:\"south pacif\")^25.0 | (section_name_tesim:\"south pacif\")^10.0 | (earlier_title_tesim:\"south pacif\")^25000.0 | (title_addl_unstem_search:\"south pacific\")^25000.0 | (title_t:\"south pacif\")^25000.0 | (title_tesim:\"south pacif\")^100000.0 | (publisher_tesim:\"south pacif\")^1000.0 | (id:\"south pacif\")^100000.0 | (subtitle_unstem_search:\"south pacific\")^100000.0 | (title_series_t:\"south pacif\")^10.0 | (local_note_tesim:\"south pacif\")^25.0 | (author_unstem_search:\"south pacific\")^250.0 | (subject_unstem_search:\"south pacific\")^750.0 | (author_t:\"south pacif\")^100.0 | (author_addl_unstem_search:\"south pacific\")^250.0 | (contents_tesim:\"south pacif\")^50.0 | (author_addl_t:\"south pacif\")^50.0 | (title_added_entry_t:\"south pacif\")^1250.0 | (summary_holdings_tesim:\"south pacif\")^50.0 | (title_added_entry_unstem_search:\"south pacific\")^1500.0 | (section_number_tesim:\"south pacif\")^10.0)~0.01))~2 DisjunctionMaxQuery(((subtitle_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^250000.0 | (databasedescription_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^500.0 | (gmd_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^500.0 | (isbn_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^1000000.0 | (lc_callnum_display:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^1000000.0 | (subject_addl_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^500.0 | (title_addl_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^25000.0 | (subject_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^5000.0 | (later_title_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^25000.0 | (subject_addl_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^2500.0 | (title_series_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^250.0 | (source:british missions south pacific)^100000.0 | (issn_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^1000000.0 | (subject_topic_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^10000.0 | (title_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^1000000.0 | (awards_note_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^250.0 | (section_name_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^100.0 | (earlier_title_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^25000.0 | (title_addl_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^250000.0 | (title_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^250000.0 | (title_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^1000000.0 | (publisher_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^10000.0 | (id:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^1000000.0 | (text:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^10.0 | (subtitle_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^1000000.0 | (title_series_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^100.0 | (local_note_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^250.0 | (author_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^2500.0 | (subject_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^7500.0 | (author_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^1000.0 | (author_addl_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^2500.0 | (subject_topic_facet:british missions south pacific)^6250.0 | (contents_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^500.0 | (author_addl_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^500.0 | (title_added_entry_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^12500.0 | (summary_holdings_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^500.0 | (title_added_entry_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^15000.0 | (section_number_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^100.0)~0.01))/no_coord"
parsedquery_toString    "+((((subtitle_t:british)^25000.0 | (databasedescription_tesim:british)^50.0 | (gmd_tesim:british)^50.0 | (isbn_t:british)^100000.0 | (lc_callnum_display:british)^100000.0 | (subject_addl_t:british)^50.0 | (title_addl_t:british)^25000.0 | (subject_t:british)^500.0 | (later_title_tesim:british)^25000.0 | (subject_addl_unstem_search:british)^250.0 | (title_series_unstem_search:british)^25.0 | (issn_t:british)^100000.0 | (subject_topic_unstem_search:british)^1000.0 | (title_unstem_search:british)^100000.0 | (awards_note_tesim:british)^25.0 | (section_name_tesim:british)^10.0 | (earlier_title_tesim:british)^25000.0 | (title_addl_unstem_search:british)^25000.0 | (title_t:british)^25000.0 | (title_tesim:british)^100000.0 | (publisher_tesim:british)^1000.0 | (id:british)^100000.0 | (subtitle_unstem_search:british)^100000.0 | (title_series_t:british)^10.0 | (local_note_tesim:british)^25.0 | (author_unstem_search:british)^250.0 | (subject_unstem_search:british)^750.0 | (author_t:british)^100.0 | (author_addl_unstem_search:british)^250.0 | (contents_tesim:british)^50.0 | (author_addl_t:british)^50.0 | (title_added_entry_t:british)^1250.0 | (summary_holdings_tesim:british)^50.0 | (title_added_entry_unstem_search:british)^1500.0 | (section_number_tesim:british)^10.0)~0.01 ((subtitle_t:mission)^25000.0 | (databasedescription_tesim:mission)^50.0 | (gmd_tesim:mission)^50.0 | (isbn_t:mission)^100000.0 | (lc_callnum_display:mission)^100000.0 | (subject_addl_t:mission)^50.0 | (title_addl_t:mission)^25000.0 | (subject_t:mission)^500.0 | (later_title_tesim:mission)^25000.0 | (subject_addl_unstem_search:missions)^250.0 | (title_series_unstem_search:missions)^25.0 | (issn_t:mission)^100000.0 | (subject_topic_unstem_search:missions)^1000.0 | (title_unstem_search:missions)^100000.0 | (awards_note_tesim:mission)^25.0 | (section_name_tesim:mission)^10.0 | (earlier_title_tesim:mission)^25000.0 | (title_addl_unstem_search:missions)^25000.0 | (title_t:mission)^25000.0 | (title_tesim:mission)^100000.0 | (publisher_tesim:mission)^1000.0 | (id:mission)^100000.0 | (subtitle_unstem_search:missions)^100000.0 | (title_series_t:mission)^10.0 | (local_note_tesim:mission)^25.0 | (author_unstem_search:missions)^250.0 | (subject_unstem_search:missions)^750.0 | (author_t:mission)^100.0 | (author_addl_unstem_search:missions)^250.0 | (contents_tesim:mission)^50.0 | (author_addl_t:mission)^50.0 | (title_added_entry_t:mission)^1250.0 | (summary_holdings_tesim:mission)^50.0 | (title_added_entry_unstem_search:missions)^1500.0 | (section_number_tesim:mission)^10.0)~0.01 ((subtitle_t:\"south pacif\")^25000.0 | (databasedescription_tesim:\"south pacif\")^50.0 | (gmd_tesim:\"south pacif\")^50.0 | (isbn_t:\"south pacif\")^100000.0 | (lc_callnum_display:\"south pacif\")^100000.0 | (subject_addl_t:\"south pacif\")^50.0 | (title_addl_t:\"south pacif\")^25000.0 | (subject_t:\"south pacif\")^500.0 | (later_title_tesim:\"south pacif\")^25000.0 | (subject_addl_unstem_search:\"south pacific\")^250.0 | (title_series_unstem_search:\"south pacific\")^25.0 | (issn_t:\"south pacif\")^100000.0 | (subject_topic_unstem_search:\"south pacific\")^1000.0 | (title_unstem_search:\"south pacific\")^100000.0 | (awards_note_tesim:\"south pacif\")^25.0 | (section_name_tesim:\"south pacif\")^10.0 | (earlier_title_tesim:\"south pacif\")^25000.0 | (title_addl_unstem_search:\"south pacific\")^25000.0 | (title_t:\"south pacif\")^25000.0 | (title_tesim:\"south pacif\")^100000.0 | (publisher_tesim:\"south pacif\")^1000.0 | (id:\"south pacif\")^100000.0 | (subtitle_unstem_search:\"south pacific\")^100000.0 | (title_series_t:\"south pacif\")^10.0 | (local_note_tesim:\"south pacif\")^25.0 | (author_unstem_search:\"south pacific\")^250.0 | (subject_unstem_search:\"south pacific\")^750.0 | (author_t:\"south pacif\")^100.0 | (author_addl_unstem_search:\"south pacific\")^250.0 | (contents_tesim:\"south pacif\")^50.0 | (author_addl_t:\"south pacif\")^50.0 | (title_added_entry_t:\"south pacif\")^1250.0 | (summary_holdings_tesim:\"south pacif\")^50.0 | (title_added_entry_unstem_search:\"south pacific\")^1500.0 | (section_number_tesim:\"south pacif\")^10.0)~0.01)~2) ((subtitle_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^250000.0 | (databasedescription_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^500.0 | (gmd_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^500.0 | (isbn_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^1000000.0 | (lc_callnum_display:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^1000000.0 | (subject_addl_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^500.0 | (title_addl_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^25000.0 | (subject_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^5000.0 | (later_title_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^25000.0 | (subject_addl_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^2500.0 | (title_series_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^250.0 | (source:british missions south pacific)^100000.0 | (issn_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^1000000.0 | (subject_topic_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^10000.0 | (title_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^1000000.0 | (awards_note_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^250.0 | (section_name_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^100.0 | (earlier_title_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^25000.0 | (title_addl_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^250000.0 | (title_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^250000.0 | (title_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^1000000.0 | (publisher_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^10000.0 | (id:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^1000000.0 | (text:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^10.0 | (subtitle_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^1000000.0 | (title_series_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^100.0 | (local_note_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^250.0 | (author_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^2500.0 | (subject_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^7500.0 | (author_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^1000.0 | (author_addl_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^2500.0 | (subject_topic_facet:british missions south pacific)^6250.0 | (contents_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^500.0 | (author_addl_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^500.0 | (title_added_entry_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^12500.0 | (summary_holdings_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^500.0 | (title_added_entry_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^15000.0 | (section_number_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^100.0)~0.01"

http://solrcloud-test.library.ualberta.ca:8080/solr/discovery-test-2018-09-12/select?debugQuery=on&indent=on&wt=json&facet.field=electronic_tesim&facet.field=institution_tesim&facet.field=location_tesim&facet.field=lc_1letter_facet&facet.field=format&facet.field=pub_date&facet.field=author_display&facet.field=subject_topic_facet&facet.field=language_facet&facet.field=subject_geo_facet&facet.field=subject_era_facet&facet.field=owning_library_tesim&qt=search&f.subject_era_facet.facet.limit=11&f.lc_1letter_facet.facet.limit=11&f.location_tesim.facet.sort=index&sort=score+desc,+pub_date_sort+desc,+title_sort+asc&rows=25&q=british+missions+%22south+pacific%22&f.subject_topic_facet.facet.limit=21&f.subject_geo_facet.facet.limit=11&stats=true&f.author_display.facet.limit=21&wt=ruby&facet=true&f.format.facet.limit=11&f.language_facet.facet.limit=11&stats.field=pub_date&hl=true

numFound    1023
  "highlighting":{
    "940078":{
      "subject_t":["<em>British</em> -- Oceania"],
      "title_t":["<em>British</em> policy in the <em>South</em> <em>Pacific</em>, 1786-1893 /"]},
    "1977856":{
      "title_t":["Education policy in <em>British</em> <em>South</em> <em>Pacific</em> islands,"]},
    "20350":{
      "subject_addl_t":["<em>Missions</em>"],
      "subject_t":["<em>Missions</em>, <em>British</em>"],
      "title_t":["<em>British</em> Protestant <em>missions</em>."]},
    "6406745":{
      "subject_t":["<em>Missions</em>, <em>British</em>"],
      "title_t":["The Spirit of <em>British</em> <em>missions</em>"]},
    "6349854":{
      "subtitle_t":["addressed to the Protestant ministers of the <em>British</em> churches /"],
      "subject_addl_t":["<em>Missions</em> Early works to 1800"],
      "subject_t":["<em>Missions</em> -- Early works to 1800"],
      "title_t":["Letters on <em>missions</em>"]},
...
    "3537384":{
      "contents_tesim":[" / Paul G. Stanwood -- The prayer book outside England -- Plantations, <em>missions</em>, and colonies / William L"]},
    "7000957":{
      "contents_tesim":[". Unlocking stories from objects: some ancient near eastern case-studies based on new research at the <em>British</em>"]},
    "6242015":{
      "contents_tesim":[" Jenkins; overcoming success -- Paul-Emile Léger; a man with a <em>mission</em> -- James F. Macleod; a man of his"]},
    "7847151":{
      "contents_tesim":[", vocals ; Hollywood Bowl Orchestra ; John Mauceri, conductor) -- Fantasia on <em>British</em> sea song"]},
    "4175286":{
      "contents_tesim":[" the <em>Mission</em> of Sainte Croix in the Montagnais country, at Tadoussac.\"; doc. 46 1667 Treaty of Breda; doc. 47"]}},

rawquerystring  "british missions south pacific"
querystring "british missions south pacific"
parsedquery "(+(DisjunctionMaxQuery(((subtitle_t:british)^25000.0 | (databasedescription_tesim:british)^50.0 | (gmd_tesim:british)^50.0 | (isbn_t:british)^100000.0 | (lc_callnum_display:british)^100000.0 | (subject_addl_t:british)^50.0 | (title_addl_t:british)^25000.0 | (subject_t:british)^500.0 | (later_title_tesim:british)^25000.0 | (subject_addl_unstem_search:british)^250.0 | (title_series_unstem_search:british)^25.0 | (issn_t:british)^100000.0 | (subject_topic_unstem_search:british)^1000.0 | (title_unstem_search:british)^100000.0 | (awards_note_tesim:british)^25.0 | (section_name_tesim:british)^10.0 | (earlier_title_tesim:british)^25000.0 | (title_addl_unstem_search:british)^25000.0 | (title_t:british)^25000.0 | (title_tesim:british)^100000.0 | (publisher_tesim:british)^1000.0 | (id:british)^100000.0 | (subtitle_unstem_search:british)^100000.0 | (title_series_t:british)^10.0 | (local_note_tesim:british)^25.0 | (author_unstem_search:british)^250.0 | (subject_unstem_search:british)^750.0 | (author_t:british)^100.0 | (author_addl_unstem_search:british)^250.0 | (contents_tesim:british)^50.0 | (author_addl_t:british)^50.0 | (title_added_entry_t:british)^1250.0 | (summary_holdings_tesim:british)^50.0 | (title_added_entry_unstem_search:british)^1500.0 | (section_number_tesim:british)^10.0)~0.01) DisjunctionMaxQuery(((subtitle_t:mission)^25000.0 | (databasedescription_tesim:mission)^50.0 | (gmd_tesim:mission)^50.0 | (isbn_t:mission)^100000.0 | (lc_callnum_display:mission)^100000.0 | (subject_addl_t:mission)^50.0 | (title_addl_t:mission)^25000.0 | (subject_t:mission)^500.0 | (later_title_tesim:mission)^25000.0 | (subject_addl_unstem_search:missions)^250.0 | (title_series_unstem_search:missions)^25.0 | (issn_t:mission)^100000.0 | (subject_topic_unstem_search:missions)^1000.0 | (title_unstem_search:missions)^100000.0 | (awards_note_tesim:mission)^25.0 | (section_name_tesim:mission)^10.0 | (earlier_title_tesim:mission)^25000.0 | (title_addl_unstem_search:missions)^25000.0 | (title_t:mission)^25000.0 | (title_tesim:mission)^100000.0 | (publisher_tesim:mission)^1000.0 | (id:mission)^100000.0 | (subtitle_unstem_search:missions)^100000.0 | (title_series_t:mission)^10.0 | (local_note_tesim:mission)^25.0 | (author_unstem_search:missions)^250.0 | (subject_unstem_search:missions)^750.0 | (author_t:mission)^100.0 | (author_addl_unstem_search:missions)^250.0 | (contents_tesim:mission)^50.0 | (author_addl_t:mission)^50.0 | (title_added_entry_t:mission)^1250.0 | (summary_holdings_tesim:mission)^50.0 | (title_added_entry_unstem_search:missions)^1500.0 | (section_number_tesim:mission)^10.0)~0.01) DisjunctionMaxQuery(((subtitle_t:south)^25000.0 | (databasedescription_tesim:south)^50.0 | (gmd_tesim:south)^50.0 | (isbn_t:south)^100000.0 | (lc_callnum_display:south)^100000.0 | (subject_addl_t:south)^50.0 | (title_addl_t:south)^25000.0 | (subject_t:south)^500.0 | (later_title_tesim:south)^25000.0 | (subject_addl_unstem_search:south)^250.0 | (title_series_unstem_search:south)^25.0 | (issn_t:south)^100000.0 | (subject_topic_unstem_search:south)^1000.0 | (title_unstem_search:south)^100000.0 | (awards_note_tesim:south)^25.0 | (section_name_tesim:south)^10.0 | (earlier_title_tesim:south)^25000.0 | (title_addl_unstem_search:south)^25000.0 | (title_t:south)^25000.0 | (title_tesim:south)^100000.0 | (publisher_tesim:south)^1000.0 | (id:south)^100000.0 | (subtitle_unstem_search:south)^100000.0 | (title_series_t:south)^10.0 | (local_note_tesim:south)^25.0 | (author_unstem_search:south)^250.0 | (subject_unstem_search:south)^750.0 | (author_t:south)^100.0 | (author_addl_unstem_search:south)^250.0 | (contents_tesim:south)^50.0 | (author_addl_t:south)^50.0 | (title_added_entry_t:south)^1250.0 | (summary_holdings_tesim:south)^50.0 | (title_added_entry_unstem_search:south)^1500.0 | (section_number_tesim:south)^10.0)~0.01) DisjunctionMaxQuery(((subtitle_t:pacif)^25000.0 | (databasedescription_tesim:pacif)^50.0 | (gmd_tesim:pacif)^50.0 | (isbn_t:pacif)^100000.0 | (lc_callnum_display:pacif)^100000.0 | (subject_addl_t:pacif)^50.0 | (title_addl_t:pacif)^25000.0 | (subject_t:pacif)^500.0 | (later_title_tesim:pacif)^25000.0 | (subject_addl_unstem_search:pacific)^250.0 | (title_series_unstem_search:pacific)^25.0 | (issn_t:pacif)^100000.0 | (subject_topic_unstem_search:pacific)^1000.0 | (title_unstem_search:pacific)^100000.0 | (awards_note_tesim:pacif)^25.0 | (section_name_tesim:pacif)^10.0 | (earlier_title_tesim:pacif)^25000.0 | (title_addl_unstem_search:pacific)^25000.0 | (title_t:pacif)^25000.0 | (title_tesim:pacif)^100000.0 | (publisher_tesim:pacif)^1000.0 | (id:pacif)^100000.0 | (subtitle_unstem_search:pacific)^100000.0 | (title_series_t:pacif)^10.0 | (local_note_tesim:pacif)^25.0 | (author_unstem_search:pacific)^250.0 | (subject_unstem_search:pacific)^750.0 | (author_t:pacif)^100.0 | (author_addl_unstem_search:pacific)^250.0 | (contents_tesim:pacif)^50.0 | (author_addl_t:pacif)^50.0 | (title_added_entry_t:pacif)^1250.0 | (summary_holdings_tesim:pacif)^50.0 | (title_added_entry_unstem_search:pacific)^1500.0 | (section_number_tesim:pacif)^10.0)~0.01))~3 DisjunctionMaxQuery(((subtitle_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^250000.0 | (databasedescription_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^500.0 | (gmd_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^500.0 | (isbn_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^1000000.0 | (lc_callnum_display:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^1000000.0 | (subject_addl_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^500.0 | (title_addl_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^25000.0 | (subject_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^5000.0 | (later_title_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^25000.0 | (subject_addl_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^2500.0 | (title_series_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^250.0 | (source:british missions south pacific)^100000.0 | (issn_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^1000000.0 | (subject_topic_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^10000.0 | (title_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^1000000.0 | (awards_note_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^250.0 | (section_name_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^100.0 | (earlier_title_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^25000.0 | (title_addl_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^250000.0 | (title_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^250000.0 | (title_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^1000000.0 | (publisher_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^10000.0 | (id:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^1000000.0 | (text:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^10.0 | (subtitle_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^1000000.0 | (title_series_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^100.0 | (local_note_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^250.0 | (author_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^2500.0 | (subject_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^7500.0 | (author_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^1000.0 | (author_addl_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^2500.0 | (subject_topic_facet:british missions south pacific)^6250.0 | (contents_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^500.0 | (author_addl_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^500.0 | (title_added_entry_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^12500.0 | (summary_holdings_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^500.0 | (title_added_entry_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^15000.0 | (section_number_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^100.0)~0.01))/no_coord"
parsedquery_toString    "+((((subtitle_t:british)^25000.0 | (databasedescription_tesim:british)^50.0 | (gmd_tesim:british)^50.0 | (isbn_t:british)^100000.0 | (lc_callnum_display:british)^100000.0 | (subject_addl_t:british)^50.0 | (title_addl_t:british)^25000.0 | (subject_t:british)^500.0 | (later_title_tesim:british)^25000.0 | (subject_addl_unstem_search:british)^250.0 | (title_series_unstem_search:british)^25.0 | (issn_t:british)^100000.0 | (subject_topic_unstem_search:british)^1000.0 | (title_unstem_search:british)^100000.0 | (awards_note_tesim:british)^25.0 | (section_name_tesim:british)^10.0 | (earlier_title_tesim:british)^25000.0 | (title_addl_unstem_search:british)^25000.0 | (title_t:british)^25000.0 | (title_tesim:british)^100000.0 | (publisher_tesim:british)^1000.0 | (id:british)^100000.0 | (subtitle_unstem_search:british)^100000.0 | (title_series_t:british)^10.0 | (local_note_tesim:british)^25.0 | (author_unstem_search:british)^250.0 | (subject_unstem_search:british)^750.0 | (author_t:british)^100.0 | (author_addl_unstem_search:british)^250.0 | (contents_tesim:british)^50.0 | (author_addl_t:british)^50.0 | (title_added_entry_t:british)^1250.0 | (summary_holdings_tesim:british)^50.0 | (title_added_entry_unstem_search:british)^1500.0 | (section_number_tesim:british)^10.0)~0.01 ((subtitle_t:mission)^25000.0 | (databasedescription_tesim:mission)^50.0 | (gmd_tesim:mission)^50.0 | (isbn_t:mission)^100000.0 | (lc_callnum_display:mission)^100000.0 | (subject_addl_t:mission)^50.0 | (title_addl_t:mission)^25000.0 | (subject_t:mission)^500.0 | (later_title_tesim:mission)^25000.0 | (subject_addl_unstem_search:missions)^250.0 | (title_series_unstem_search:missions)^25.0 | (issn_t:mission)^100000.0 | (subject_topic_unstem_search:missions)^1000.0 | (title_unstem_search:missions)^100000.0 | (awards_note_tesim:mission)^25.0 | (section_name_tesim:mission)^10.0 | (earlier_title_tesim:mission)^25000.0 | (title_addl_unstem_search:missions)^25000.0 | (title_t:mission)^25000.0 | (title_tesim:mission)^100000.0 | (publisher_tesim:mission)^1000.0 | (id:mission)^100000.0 | (subtitle_unstem_search:missions)^100000.0 | (title_series_t:mission)^10.0 | (local_note_tesim:mission)^25.0 | (author_unstem_search:missions)^250.0 | (subject_unstem_search:missions)^750.0 | (author_t:mission)^100.0 | (author_addl_unstem_search:missions)^250.0 | (contents_tesim:mission)^50.0 | (author_addl_t:mission)^50.0 | (title_added_entry_t:mission)^1250.0 | (summary_holdings_tesim:mission)^50.0 | (title_added_entry_unstem_search:missions)^1500.0 | (section_number_tesim:mission)^10.0)~0.01 ((subtitle_t:south)^25000.0 | (databasedescription_tesim:south)^50.0 | (gmd_tesim:south)^50.0 | (isbn_t:south)^100000.0 | (lc_callnum_display:south)^100000.0 | (subject_addl_t:south)^50.0 | (title_addl_t:south)^25000.0 | (subject_t:south)^500.0 | (later_title_tesim:south)^25000.0 | (subject_addl_unstem_search:south)^250.0 | (title_series_unstem_search:south)^25.0 | (issn_t:south)^100000.0 | (subject_topic_unstem_search:south)^1000.0 | (title_unstem_search:south)^100000.0 | (awards_note_tesim:south)^25.0 | (section_name_tesim:south)^10.0 | (earlier_title_tesim:south)^25000.0 | (title_addl_unstem_search:south)^25000.0 | (title_t:south)^25000.0 | (title_tesim:south)^100000.0 | (publisher_tesim:south)^1000.0 | (id:south)^100000.0 | (subtitle_unstem_search:south)^100000.0 | (title_series_t:south)^10.0 | (local_note_tesim:south)^25.0 | (author_unstem_search:south)^250.0 | (subject_unstem_search:south)^750.0 | (author_t:south)^100.0 | (author_addl_unstem_search:south)^250.0 | (contents_tesim:south)^50.0 | (author_addl_t:south)^50.0 | (title_added_entry_t:south)^1250.0 | (summary_holdings_tesim:south)^50.0 | (title_added_entry_unstem_search:south)^1500.0 | (section_number_tesim:south)^10.0)~0.01 ((subtitle_t:pacif)^25000.0 | (databasedescription_tesim:pacif)^50.0 | (gmd_tesim:pacif)^50.0 | (isbn_t:pacif)^100000.0 | (lc_callnum_display:pacif)^100000.0 | (subject_addl_t:pacif)^50.0 | (title_addl_t:pacif)^25000.0 | (subject_t:pacif)^500.0 | (later_title_tesim:pacif)^25000.0 | (subject_addl_unstem_search:pacific)^250.0 | (title_series_unstem_search:pacific)^25.0 | (issn_t:pacif)^100000.0 | (subject_topic_unstem_search:pacific)^1000.0 | (title_unstem_search:pacific)^100000.0 | (awards_note_tesim:pacif)^25.0 | (section_name_tesim:pacif)^10.0 | (earlier_title_tesim:pacif)^25000.0 | (title_addl_unstem_search:pacific)^25000.0 | (title_t:pacif)^25000.0 | (title_tesim:pacif)^100000.0 | (publisher_tesim:pacif)^1000.0 | (id:pacif)^100000.0 | (subtitle_unstem_search:pacific)^100000.0 | (title_series_t:pacif)^10.0 | (local_note_tesim:pacif)^25.0 | (author_unstem_search:pacific)^250.0 | (subject_unstem_search:pacific)^750.0 | (author_t:pacif)^100.0 | (author_addl_unstem_search:pacific)^250.0 | (contents_tesim:pacif)^50.0 | (author_addl_t:pacif)^50.0 | (title_added_entry_t:pacif)^1250.0 | (summary_holdings_tesim:pacif)^50.0 | (title_added_entry_unstem_search:pacific)^1500.0 | (section_number_tesim:pacif)^10.0)~0.01)~3) ((subtitle_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^250000.0 | (databasedescription_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^500.0 | (gmd_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^500.0 | (isbn_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^1000000.0 | (lc_callnum_display:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^1000000.0 | (subject_addl_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^500.0 | (title_addl_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^25000.0 | (subject_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^5000.0 | (later_title_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^25000.0 | (subject_addl_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^2500.0 | (title_series_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^250.0 | (source:british missions south pacific)^100000.0 | (issn_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^1000000.0 | (subject_topic_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^10000.0 | (title_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^1000000.0 | (awards_note_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^250.0 | (section_name_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^100.0 | (earlier_title_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^25000.0 | (title_addl_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^250000.0 | (title_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^250000.0 | (title_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^1000000.0 | (publisher_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^10000.0 | (id:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^1000000.0 | (text:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^10.0 | (subtitle_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^1000000.0 | (title_series_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^100.0 | (local_note_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^250.0 | (author_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^2500.0 | (subject_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^7500.0 | (author_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^1000.0 | (author_addl_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^2500.0 | (subject_topic_facet:british missions south pacific)^6250.0 | (contents_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^500.0 | (author_addl_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^500.0 | (title_added_entry_t:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^12500.0 | (summary_holdings_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^500.0 | (title_added_entry_unstem_search:\"british missions south pacific\"~3)^15000.0 | (section_number_tesim:\"british mission south pacif\"~3)^100.0)~0.01"

http://solrcloud-test.library.ualberta.ca:8080/solr/discovery-test-2018-09-12/select?debugQuery=on&indent=on&wt=json&facet.field=electronic_tesim&facet.field=institution_tesim&facet.field=location_tesim&facet.field=lc_1letter_facet&facet.field=format&facet.field=pub_date&facet.field=author_display&facet.field=subject_topic_facet&facet.field=language_facet&facet.field=subject_geo_facet&facet.field=subject_era_facet&facet.field=owning_library_tesim&qt=search&f.subject_era_facet.facet.limit=11&f.lc_1letter_facet.facet.limit=11&f.location_tesim.facet.sort=index&sort=score+desc,+pub_date_sort+desc,+title_sort+asc&rows=25&q=british+missions+south+pacific&f.subject_topic_facet.facet.limit=21&f.subject_geo_facet.facet.limit=11&stats=true&f.author_display.facet.limit=21&wt=ruby&facet=true&f.format.facet.limit=11&f.language_facet.facet.limit=11&stats.field=pub_date&hl=true

numFound    291
"highlighting":{
    "940078":{
      "subject_t":["<em>British</em> -- Oceania"],
      "title_t":["<em>British</em> policy in the <em>South</em> <em>Pacific</em>, 1786-1893 /"]},
    "1977856":{
      "title_t":["Education policy in <em>British</em> <em>South</em> <em>Pacific</em> islands,"]},
    "1439211":{
      "subtitle_t":["government and reconstruction in New Caledonia, the New Hebrides, and the <em>British</em> Solomon Islands"],
      "title_t":["Island administration in the <em>South</em> West <em>Pacific</em>;"]},
    "6405981":{
      "subject_addl_t":["<em>British</em> Columbia <em>Pacific</em> Coast <em>Missions</em>"],
      "subject_t":["Indians of North America -- <em>British</em> Columbia -- <em>Pacific</em> Coast -- <em>Missions</em>"],
      "title_t":["Alaska and <em>missions</em> on the north <em>Pacific</em> coast"]},
    "88584":{
      "subtitle_t":["a study of post-war rehabilitation and reconstruction in three <em>British</em> <em>Pacific</em> dependencies."],
      "title_t":["The <em>South</em> Seas in transition :"]},
...
    "5177849":{
      "contents_tesim":[" Formation, Alberta and <em>British</em> Columbia) / J. L. McKay, F. J. Longstaffe and A. G. Plint -- Non"]},
    "1762233":{
      "contents_tesim":["1. Prologue / Robin Cohen -- 2. European colonization and settlement. The <em>British</em> colonies"]},
    "5169148":{
      "contents_tesim":[" (1894-1952) -- <em>British</em> army -- Bugeaud, Marshal Thomas-Robert (1784-1849) -- Burma -- Cabral, Amilcar"]},
    "4175286":{
      "contents_tesim":[" Estuary, New Brunswick - 1980 survey; doc. 3 Allen, Patricia Marlene. 1981 Miramichi Bay <em>South</em> shore"]},
    "948258":{
      "contents_tesim":[") -- Columbus Discovers <em>South</em> America (A.D. 1498) -- Establishment of Swiss Independence (A.D. 1499) -- Amerigo"]}},

[pgwillia]

https://github.com/ualbertalib/blacklight_solr_conf/blob/bc89d514ca857214c57bc2cb023e0d6dfe4a79c6/solr/blacklight-core/conf/solrconfig.xml#L101 <str name="mm">2&lt;-1 5&lt;-2 6&lt;90%</str>

mm is Minimum Should Match

If there are 1 or 2 clauses, then both are required. 2<-1 If there is 3, 4 or 5 clauses then all but one is required. 5<-2 If there is 6 clauses then all but two is required. 6<90% If there are more than 6 clauses then 90% are required.

So for these queries, british missions south pacific (319) has four clauses, three are required. And for british missions "south pacific" (1,358) has three clauses, two are required. (You can see this in the debugged query where ~2 vs ~3 slop is used).

So, I believe that british missions "south pacific" returns more because british missions (1,297) satisfies this condition.

[seanluyk]

Interesting @pgwillia, thanks for investigating. The weird part of this still is that typically in libraries we would think of quotes as reducing the number of hits because the expectation is that all terms in that 1 clause in quotes are required. I'm still confused as to why other Blacklight institutions don't experience this problem, so I'm wondering if it actually relates to a data/mapping problem? Not sure if this is significant but here is Stanford's mm parameter: 6<-1 6<90%

[pgwillia]

Stanford's example confuses me a little bit. Here's how I'd interpret it:

If there are 1, 2, 3, 4,5 or 6 clauses, then all are required. 6<-1 If there are more then 6 clauses, all but one is required. But I think this is overridden by the next value. 6<90% If there are more then 6 clauses, 90% are required.

Playing with some values, this plays out http://solrcloud-test.library.ualberta.ca:8080/solr/discovery-test-2018-09-12/select?debugQuery=on&indent=on&wt=json&rows=0&q=one+two+three+four+five+six&mm=6%3C-1+6%3C90%25 Expect ~6

http://solrcloud-test.library.ualberta.ca:8080/solr/discovery-test-2018-09-12/select?debugQuery=on&indent=on&wt=json&rows=0&q=one+two+three+four+five+six+seven&mm=6%3C-1+6%3C90%25 Expect ~6 (7*.09 = 6.3)

http://solrcloud-test.library.ualberta.ca:8080/solr/discovery-test-2018-09-12/select?debugQuery=on&indent=on&wt=json&rows=0&q=one+two+three+four+five+six+seven+eight+nine+ten+eleven+twelve+thirteen+fourteen+fifteen+sixteen+seventeen+eighteen+nineteen+twenty&mm=6%3C-1+6%3C90%25 Expect ~18 (20*.0.9 = 18)

From the Solr documentation: Defines multiple conditions, each one being valid only for numbers greater than the one before it. https://lucene.apache.org/solr/guide/6_6/the-dismax-query-parser.html#TheDisMaxQueryParser-Themm_MinimumShouldMatch_Parameter

[pgwillia]

No, I don't think it relates to a data/mapping problem. Increasing the minimum to match (like Stanford using 6) would hide this behaviour.

If you're looking to require a clause, try something like british missions +"south pacific" . The + will mark that clause as required.

[seanluyk]

@pgwillia it's interesting even to compare hit counts of a query for just british missions south pacific between UAL and other libraries using SOLR. With the exception of John's Hopkins, our results always tend to stand out. By comparison:

• John's Hopkins: 520 results
• UAL: 320 results
• Stanford: 59 results
• Indiana: 43 results
• Columbia: 41 results
• UW-Madison: 28 results
• Brown: 24 results
• Cornell: 18 results
  • Princeton: 14 results

It's possible that we've got much more on this topic that other institutions, but unlikely that the discrepancy would be this high considering these are very large libraries. It seems as if most libraries have increased the minimum to match parameter so that SOLR behaves more like a library catalogue

[pgwillia]

After changing the mm value and applying the searches against symphony data from December (5916198 docs), british missions south pacific numFound: 10

• 3537384
• 5266522
• 5395326
• 5972395
• 6271828
• 6754131
• 6992728
• 7519557
• 7638654
• 8231646

british missions "south pacific" numFound: 2

• 6271828
• 8231646

[seanluyk]

Thanks for testing this @pgwillia, it's good to see more precision when phrase searches are added to a query. Looking at these results, I wonder if phrase slop is also an issue in our SOLR config? The terms in question are pretty far apart in these fields. I know that this can be specified at either the SOLR config level or at the query, and it would be interesting to experiment with this

[seanluyk]

Read some other interesting discussions about this problem, with one recommendation being to move to other indexing schemes link ngrams, analyzing after stopwords are removed

[pgwillia]

I wonder if phrase slop is also an issue in our SOLR config? The terms in question are pretty far apart in these fields.

I'm not sure what you mean? The terms in the phrase "south pacific" look adjacent to me?

[seanluyk]

@pgwillia I think I was talking about the results from the first query (British missions south pacific). For example, in the first record, terms are quite far apart in fields: https://search.library.ualberta.ca/catalog/3537384

[pgwillia]

@pgwillia interesting, I had completely forgotten about that discussion. So are you saying that our current mm configuration was intended to fix a problem with stopwords? I assume that the changes to make sure stopwords were configured the same in all relevant qf fields was done, so would it make sense to undo the fix?

No. I was completely wrong. This was addressed correctly by the qf fields.

[pgwillia]

@pgwillia I think I was talking about the results from the first query (British missions south pacific). For example, in the first record, terms are quite far apart in fields: https://search.library.ualberta.ca/catalog/3537384

Looking at this fresh today, I'm not sure why I had that (alpha?) order. Seeing the score let's us know that there are three that are very relevant and the other seven not as much. Maybe this makes more sense:

"docs":[
      {
        "id":"6271828",
        "score":716832.5},
      {
        "id":"6992728",
        "score":643882.75},
      {
        "id":"7519557",
        "score":608439.8},
      {
        "id":"5972395",
        "score":4127.9355},
      {
        "id":"8231646",
        "score":580.38135},
      {
        "id":"7638654",
        "score":537.97925},
      {
        "id":"5395326",
        "score":488.1419},
      {
        "id":"6754131",
        "score":488.1419},
      {
        "id":"5266522",
        "score":381.17313},
      {
        "id":"3537384",
        "score":219.21783}]
  },

"highlighting":{
    "6271828":{
      "title_addl_t":["<em>British</em>-U.S. Air <em>Mission</em> Inspects Far East Bases"],
      "section_name_tesim":["<em>British</em>-U.S. Air <em>Mission</em> Inspects Far East Bases"],
      "title_t":["United News. Release 40 (1943), <em>British</em>-U.S. Air <em>Mission</em> Inspects Far East Bases [electronic"],
      "contents_tesim":["<em>British</em>-U.S. Air <em>Mission</em> Inspects Far East Bases (1:23) -- Australia Cheers Reinforcements From"]},
    "6992728":{
      "subject_addl_t":["<em>British</em> Columbia Lower Mainland Guidebooks"],
      "title_addl_t":["One hundred and nine walks in <em>British</em> Columbia's Lower Mainland"],
      "subject_t":["Walking -- <em>British</em> Columbia -- Lower Mainland -- Guidebooks"],
      "title_t":["109 walks in <em>British</em> Columbia's Lower Mainland [electronic resource] / Mary & David Macaree"],
      "contents_tesim":[") -- 2 UBC Botanical Garden -- 3 <em>Pacific</em> Spirit Regional Park -- 4 Chancellor Woods -- 5 Point Grey -- 6"]},
    "7519557":{
      "subject_t":["<em>Missions</em> -- Oceania -- Early works to 1800"],
      "title_t":["A missionary voyage to the southern <em>Pacific</em> ocean [electronic resource] : performed in the years"],
      "author_addl_t":["<em>British</em> Library."]},
    "5972395":{
      "publisher_tesim":["Omnibus Program for Social Studies-Cultural Heritage, Trust Territory of the <em>Pacific</em> Islands"],
      "contents_tesim":[": the Spanish in the Marianas 1668-1700 -- The <em>mission</em> to the Palaos: missionary attempts in the western"]},
    "8231646":{
      "contents_tesim":[" in New Zealand and the <em>South</em> <em>Pacific</em> / Allan K. Davidson -- 18. Anglicanism in Latin America, 1810"]},
    "7638654":{
      "contents_tesim":["': <em>Pacification</em> 1885-1914 -- 'White savages': Hearts of Darkness -- 'We go where we are led': <em>Missions</em>"]},
    "5395326":{
      "contents_tesim":[" operation, 1800-1960: an overview / George A. Kiersch and James R. Underwood -- 3. <em>British</em> military"]},
    "6754131":{
      "contents_tesim":[" operation, 1800-1960 : an overview / George A. Kiersch and James R. Underwood -- 3. <em>British</em> military"]},
    "5266522":{
      "contents_tesim":[" are no better in this part of Africa either -- PART 4: ASIA AND THE <em>PACIFIC</em>: All in the family: North and <em>South</em>"]},
    "3537384":{
      "contents_tesim":[" / Paul G. Stanwood -- The prayer book outside England -- Plantations, <em>missions</em>, and colonies / William L"]}},

[pgwillia]

https://github.com/ualbertalib/blacklight_solr_conf/pull/4