ubc / iPeer

Peer Evaluation System
http://ipeer.ctlt.ubc.ca
Other
17 stars 18 forks source link

Mixed Evaluation - Duplicated Self-Evaluations #580

Open timkato opened 6 years ago

timkato commented 6 years ago

When creating a mixed evaluation event, the self-evaluation setting has unexpected results: -When self-eval disabled, works as expected -When self-eval enabled, you evaluate yourself twice: once as a group member, once as a self-evaluation (so if you are in a group of 5, you end up doing 6 evaluations, one for each peer and two for yourself)

UBC PRB0043717

kitsook commented 6 years ago

There are two sections in a mixed evaluation event: "Peer Evaluation Questions" for group members and "Self-Evaluation Questions" for the student. The questions in each section can be defined differently in the template.

If an event is created with "self-evaluation" enabled (doesn't matter whether the evaluation template has "self-evaluation" enabled or not), the "Peer Evaluation Questions" section will include the student as one of the group members being evaluated.

If the both (1) the evaluation template has "self-evaluation" enabled; and (2) the event has "self-evaluation" enabled, the student will see the "Self-Evaluation Questions" section.

i.e. It is possible for a student to self evaluate twice, once in each section. But it makes sense if the questions are different.

timkato commented 6 years ago

Caveat: If I include separate self-evaluation questions in my mixed evaluation, there's no way to display those without also displaying the peer evaluation questions self-eval portion created by setting the self-evaluation to enabled in the event settings. Specifically, the one self-evaluation setting flag controls the visibility of both self-evaluation sections.

Setting up a meeting in the Hub to discuss next steps.

timkato commented 6 years ago

Notes from meeting 4/10/2018: We will improve this by changing the behaviour of the event settings for mixed evaluations: -No option to set self-evaluation in the event settings -Always display self-evaluation questions that are part of the evaluation template regardless of event settings

Whomever fixes this should also address "UI Improvements to Add Event" Issue 561 as the two are closely related