ubcecon / comet-project

This repository stores our public notebooks for the COMET project: comet.arts.ubc.ca
Other
5 stars 7 forks source link

Working on ECON-325 Module 1 - Central Tendency #22

Closed amohaidly1996 closed 1 year ago

amohaidly1996 commented 1 year ago

Everything else looks good.

jlgraves-ubc commented 1 year ago

Great stuff; I'll let @oliverxjy organize fixing these issues.

oliverxjy commented 1 year ago

@jlgraves-ubc @amohaidly1996

Thank you @amohaidly1996 for the great feedback!

  1. Our original statement is specifically referring to how the whiskers are drawn by default in R's boxplot() function, while the online source provided is providing a more general understanding of what whiskers represent in a boxplot, without being specific to R's default implementation. The third bullet point is also specifically within the context of "variety of different variations of the boxplot, but in R the default to create a diagram where:". We could discuss if we should include a more general definition of whiskers in addition to our R-specific definition in the notebook.
  2. Yes, the idea is to guide students to use boxplot. Although there's no explicit lesson on distribution. The notebooks tries to implicitly guide students through. For example, we mentioned in the notebook : "Quantiles are equally divided sections of a distribution of values which together capture the full distribution of these values". We then introduce the concept of boxplot which is designed to visualize five number summary (quantiles). We could discuss if we should make the lesson of distribution more explicit rather than implicit.