search

uberhalit / EldenRingFpsUnlockAndMore

A small utility to remove frame rate limit, change FOV, add widescreen support and more for Elden Ring
MIT License
1.21k stars 111 forks source link

Above 60 fps bugs Stormhawk barrel throw #30

Open leopardturret opened 2 years ago

leopardturret commented 2 years ago

There are a few Stormhawks in Stormveil Castle that throw explosive barrels at you; The enemies outside the door at "Rampart Tower" site of grace. When playing at above 60fps (I had the game capped at 120fps when testing this) the barrels crumble the exact frame they leave the Stormhawks claws when throwing at you. They're supposed to throw the barrel at you and explode on impact, but instead they break instantly mid-air (with no explosion).

uberhalit commented 2 years ago

Hmm that could be a bug but I don't have a save file that is that far yet. I've spent about 20 minutes ingame since release... Could you try lowering game speed with the latest 0.0.0.4 release and record it?

leopardturret commented 2 years ago

Hi, Here's a video showing the bug at 60fps and 120fps and lowered game speed: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rKqooO6DU3o

uberhalit commented 2 years ago

So this also happens at 60fps with lower game speed? That would indicate a game/engine bug rather than an issue with the unlock itself.

designgears commented 2 years ago

I can confirm this is a bug with the fps unlock, I can toggle it off and on, on the barrel disappears, off the barrel is thrown and explodes just fine. Game speed doesn't seem to help with unlocked fps.

Here's my save, load it up, walk outside and you'll see the 2 birds. ER0000.zip

uberhalit commented 2 years ago

I can confirm this is a bug with the fps unlock, I can toggle it off and on, on the barrel disappears, off the barrel is thrown and explodes just fine. Game speed doesn't seem to help with unlocked fps.

Here's my save, load it up, walk outside and you'll see the 2 birds. ER0000.zip

So it does not happen on your end with 60fps lock and reduced game speed?

lizfinite commented 2 years ago

I can confirm this is a bug with the fps unlock, I can toggle it off and on, on the barrel disappears, off the barrel is thrown and explodes just fine. Game speed doesn't seem to help with unlocked fps. Here's my save, load it up, walk outside and you'll see the 2 birds. ER0000.zip

So it does not happen on your end with 60fps lock and reduced game speed?

Game speed stopped the issue at 80% game speed for myself, shown in the comparison videos below.

144 FPS Cap, 100% Game Speed 60 FPS Cap, 100% Game Speed 144 FPS Cap, 80% Game Speed

Silentfan86 commented 2 years ago

I can confirm this is a bug with the fps unlock, I can toggle it off and on, on the barrel disappears, off the barrel is thrown and explodes just fine. Game speed doesn't seem to help with unlocked fps. Here's my save, load it up, walk outside and you'll see the 2 birds. ER0000.zip

So it does not happen on your end with 60fps lock and reduced game speed?

Game speed stopped the issue at 80% game speed for myself, shown in the comparison videos below.

144 FPS Cap, 100% Game Speed 60 FPS Cap, 100% Game Speed 144 FPS Cap, 80% Game Speed

Useful, thanks. Can you test a cap at 75 fps with 100% Game Speed for me? Thanks in advance! 75 are already much smoother than 60 fps. And there aren`t many fps at outdoor-areals.

lizfinite commented 2 years ago

Anything 72 FPS or above at 100% game speed causes the barrel issue. 71 and down to 60 and the bird throw the barrels like normal.

uberhalit commented 2 years ago

This sounds like a timing issue of the engine as the barrel is thrown normally even at 165fps on 75% speed. Probably not much we can do other than hoping FromSoft will fix their engine, although I haven't looked into it yet.

cmhamiche commented 2 years ago

I just went through this section and had no bug. Barrels exploded as intended.

Edit: I tried changing fov early game and clipped through the floor. It didn't happened since I disabled this option. Maybe related ? It was pre 0.0.0.5.

designgears commented 2 years ago

I just went through this section and had no bug. Barrels exploded as intended.

  • ER FPS Unlock v1.0.0.1, with only frame rate lock ticked and set at 144.
  • Nvidia gtx 1060 6gb with a slight overclock, driver version 511.79, preferred refresh rate to highest available and vsync Off.
  • Game is "onsl" 1.02.3, set to high, 36>52 fps depending on the scenery.
  • Windows 11.
  • No Huds, no mods, no FPS counters; no Geforce Experience or anything that could be interfering.
  • Simple144 Hz monitor without gsync.

Edit: I tried changing fov early game and clipped through the floor. It didn't happened since I disabled this option. Maybe related ? It was pre 0.0.0.5.

You're not even hitting 60fps, of course it won't trigger the bug.

cmhamiche commented 2 years ago

My bad.

Filoppi commented 1 year ago

This is literally the only known relevant bug that happens when the frame rate is unlocked. It was definately worth of From Software to lock the entire game at 60fps for everybody, instead of just fixing this 👍, which would have probably taken 10 minutes.