Closed koutsd closed 7 months ago
Hi @koutsd,
Thanks for this PR, there's quite a few changes so I won't have time to review it fully just yet. For the time being, can you note here what the latest results you managed to get with MR-NIRP were? When I get around to looking into this (apologies, I've been too occupied with a variety of things including moving across the country), the first thing I'd like to do is try to reproduce your results.
Hi @yahskapar,
Sorry that the PR is a bit all over the place. For some reason I thought that subsequent commits will not update the PR. Here is a list of what I changed to hopefully make reviewing the PR easier:
Here are some inference results using the pretrained models you provide in the toolbox:
There are some videos from the dataset that are excluded from the tests. You can find the config files used here: https://github.com/koutsd/rPPG-Toolbox/tree/main/configs/infer_configs They are the ones named MR-NIRP{model name}{train dataset}.yaml where train dataset is PURE, UBFC-rPPG or SCAMPS.
I am also working on some training results but there have been some issues regarding the loss function as you can see here: https://github.com/ubicomplab/rPPG-Toolbox/issues/254#issuecomment-1986452147
Thanks @koutsd, this is a great summary! I will try to get to this and taking a deeper look at #254 toward the tail-end of this week.
Regarding the pre-trained models you tried already, can you also try one of the motion augmented ones? For example, MA-UBFC_tscan.pth.
Hi @yahskapar,
Here are some the results with from MA-UBFC_tscan.pth. The same config file as before was used. I assumed this model also takes diff-normalized input.
Hi @koutsd,
Did you mean to close this? Sorry, I still haven't gotten around to reviewing it fully yet but can plan to take a thorough look on Friday.
Hi @yahskapar,
I apologize about this. I had to make the repo private for the moment. I do plan on making another PR with trained models when everything is cleared out.
No problem - sounds good, feel free to ping me when it's back up for me to take a look.