search

ubports / ubports-installer

A simple tool to install Ubuntu Touch on UBports devices
https://github.com/ubports/ubports-installer/releases
GNU General Public License v3.0
546 stars 120 forks source link

VollaPhoneX detected as VollaPhone #2833

Closed OlThHoCa closed 2 years ago

OlThHoCa commented 2 years ago

UBports Installer 0.9.7-beta (snap) Environment: Ubuntu Core 20 linux 5.10.0-17-amd64 x64 NodeJS v16.15.0 Device: yggdrasilx (Volla Phone X) Target OS: Ubuntu Touch Settings: {"bootstrap":true,"channel":"16.04/arm64/android9/stable"} OPEN-CUTS run: N/A Pastebin: https://snip.hxrsh.in/ubi-1662915708146

Connected VollaPhoneX in fastboot mode and started ubports-installer. After this always the wrong VollaPhone device is selected. First time I bricked my Phone this way.

Flohack74 commented 2 years ago

@NotKit any ideas on this one?

NotKit commented 2 years ago

They identify with same BSP codename while in bootloader, so I have no idea how to tell them apart. Ideally bootloader should display a window to select the device between Volla and Volla X with picture.

maciek134 commented 2 years ago

Should we disable the ability to start the installation in fastboot for both until we can figure this out then?

amartinz commented 2 years ago

Should we disable the ability to start the installation in fastboot for both until we can figure this out then?

I think we should, as bootloaders are not guaranteed to report the correct product name / model.

OlThHoCa commented 2 years ago

In this case I would not be able to flash again about ubports- installer. Currently only the fastboot mode is available.

OlThHoCa commented 2 years ago

Currently the phone responds correct following to the model request: @.***:~$ fastboot devices -l GX290Pro0029432 fastboot usb:1-4

VollaPhone should respond with GS290Pro......

so fastboot responds with correct GX290... Id.

maciek134 commented 2 years ago

That's just the device ID, on most devices it doesn't include the model information so we can't rely on that. Maybe there is some info in the build versions, can you run fastboot getvar all and post the output somewhere (making sure to mask any potentially sensitive information like IMEI)

Flohack74 commented 2 years ago

Yes thats supposed to be the serial number of your device or whatever the vendor puts there :) - Of course we can create a mandatory device selection in this case. Auto-detection will not be possible in this case. Some vendors have that issue.

OlThHoCa commented 2 years ago

The output of  fastboot getvar all was: (bootloader) max-download-size: 0x8000000 (bootloader) variant: (bootloader) logical-block-size: 0x200 (bootloader) erase-block-size: 0x80000 (bootloader) hw-revision: ca01 (bootloader) battery-soc-ok: yes (bootloader) battery-voltage: 4148mV (bootloader) partition-size:sgpt: 4200 (bootloader) partition-type:sgpt: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:flashinfo: 1000000 (bootloader) partition-type:flashinfo: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:userdata: d416fbe00 (bootloader) partition-type:userdata: ext4 (bootloader) partition-size:cache: 1b000000 (bootloader) partition-type:cache: ext4 (bootloader) partition-size:system: e0000000 (bootloader) partition-type:system: ext4 (bootloader) partition-size:vendor: 32000000 (bootloader) partition-type:vendor: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:tee2: c00000 (bootloader) partition-type:tee2: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:tee1: 500000 (bootloader) partition-type:tee1: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:dtbo: 800000 (bootloader) partition-type:dtbo: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:logo: 800000 (bootloader) partition-type:logo: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:boot: 2000000 (bootloader) partition-type:boot: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:lk2: 100000 (bootloader) partition-type:lk2: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:lk: 100000 (bootloader) partition-type:lk: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:nvram: 4000000 (bootloader) partition-type:nvram: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:gz2: 1000000 (bootloader) partition-type:gz2: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:gz1: 1000000 (bootloader) partition-type:gz1: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:sspm_2: 100000 (bootloader) partition-type:sspm_2: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:sspm_1: 100000 (bootloader) partition-type:sspm_1: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:spmfw: 100000 (bootloader) partition-type:spmfw: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:md1dsp: 1000000 (bootloader) partition-type:md1dsp: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:md1img: 4000000 (bootloader) partition-type:md1img: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:sec1: 200000 (bootloader) partition-type:sec1: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:persist: 3000000 (bootloader) partition-type:persist: ext4 (bootloader) partition-size:seccfg: 800000 (bootloader) partition-type:seccfg: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:protect2: e78000 (bootloader) partition-type:protect2: ext4 (bootloader) partition-size:protect1: 800000 (bootloader) partition-type:protect1: ext4 (bootloader) partition-size:metadata: 2000000 (bootloader) partition-type:metadata: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:nvdata: 4000000 (bootloader) partition-type:nvdata: ext4 (bootloader) partition-size:nvcfg: 2000000 (bootloader) partition-type:nvcfg: ext4 (bootloader) partition-size:frp: 100000 (bootloader) partition-type:frp: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:expdb: 1400000 (bootloader) partition-type:expdb: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:para: 80000 (bootloader) partition-type:para: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:recovery: 2000000 (bootloader) partition-type:recovery: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:boot_para: 100000 (bootloader) partition-type:boot_para: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:proinfo: 300000 (bootloader) partition-type:proinfo: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:pgpt: 8000 (bootloader) partition-type:pgpt: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:preloader: 40000 (bootloader) partition-type:preloader: raw data (bootloader) serialno: GX290Pro0029432 (bootloader) off-mode-charge: 1 (bootloader) warranty: no (bootloader) unlocked: yes (bootloader) secure: no (bootloader) kernel: lk (bootloader) product: k63v2_64_bsp (bootloader) is-userspace: no (bootloader) slot-count: 0 (bootloader) version-baseband: MOLY.LR12A.R2.MP.V138.11 (bootloader) version-bootloader: k63v2_64_bsp-aa07ba143a- 20210814151502- (bootloader) version-preloader: (bootloader) version: 0.5 all: Done!! Finished. Total time: 0.008s

Also here the serialno is GX290.... what means the right one for VollaPhoneX.

maciek134 commented 2 years ago

That was run in fastbootd, can you check again in normal fastboot/bootloader? Again, serial number is supposed to be unique for each device, this is the first time I see the model included in it.

On Tue, Sep 13, 2022, 4:51 PM OlThHoCa @.***> wrote:

The output of fastboot getvar all was: (bootloader) max-download-size: 0x8000000 (bootloader) variant: (bootloader) logical-block-size: 0x200 (bootloader) erase-block-size: 0x80000 (bootloader) hw-revision: ca01 (bootloader) battery-soc-ok: yes (bootloader) battery-voltage: 4148mV (bootloader) partition-size:sgpt: 4200 (bootloader) partition-type:sgpt: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:flashinfo: 1000000 (bootloader) partition-type:flashinfo: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:userdata: d416fbe00 (bootloader) partition-type:userdata: ext4 (bootloader) partition-size:cache: 1b000000 (bootloader) partition-type:cache: ext4 (bootloader) partition-size:system: e0000000 (bootloader) partition-type:system: ext4 (bootloader) partition-size:vendor: 32000000 (bootloader) partition-type:vendor: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:tee2: c00000 (bootloader) partition-type:tee2: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:tee1: 500000 (bootloader) partition-type:tee1: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:dtbo: 800000 (bootloader) partition-type:dtbo: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:logo: 800000 (bootloader) partition-type:logo: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:boot: 2000000 (bootloader) partition-type:boot: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:lk2: 100000 (bootloader) partition-type:lk2: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:lk: 100000 (bootloader) partition-type:lk: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:nvram: 4000000 (bootloader) partition-type:nvram: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:gz2: 1000000 (bootloader) partition-type:gz2: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:gz1: 1000000 (bootloader) partition-type:gz1: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:sspm_2: 100000 (bootloader) partition-type:sspm_2: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:sspm_1: 100000 (bootloader) partition-type:sspm_1: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:spmfw: 100000 (bootloader) partition-type:spmfw: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:md1dsp: 1000000 (bootloader) partition-type:md1dsp: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:md1img: 4000000 (bootloader) partition-type:md1img: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:sec1: 200000 (bootloader) partition-type:sec1: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:persist: 3000000 (bootloader) partition-type:persist: ext4 (bootloader) partition-size:seccfg: 800000 (bootloader) partition-type:seccfg: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:protect2: e78000 (bootloader) partition-type:protect2: ext4 (bootloader) partition-size:protect1: 800000 (bootloader) partition-type:protect1: ext4 (bootloader) partition-size:metadata: 2000000 (bootloader) partition-type:metadata: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:nvdata: 4000000 (bootloader) partition-type:nvdata: ext4 (bootloader) partition-size:nvcfg: 2000000 (bootloader) partition-type:nvcfg: ext4 (bootloader) partition-size:frp: 100000 (bootloader) partition-type:frp: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:expdb: 1400000 (bootloader) partition-type:expdb: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:para: 80000 (bootloader) partition-type:para: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:recovery: 2000000 (bootloader) partition-type:recovery: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:boot_para: 100000 (bootloader) partition-type:boot_para: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:proinfo: 300000 (bootloader) partition-type:proinfo: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:pgpt: 8000 (bootloader) partition-type:pgpt: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:preloader: 40000 (bootloader) partition-type:preloader: raw data (bootloader) serialno: GX290Pro0029432 (bootloader) off-mode-charge: 1 (bootloader) warranty: no (bootloader) unlocked: yes (bootloader) secure: no (bootloader) kernel: lk (bootloader) product: k63v2_64_bsp (bootloader) is-userspace: no (bootloader) slot-count: 0 (bootloader) version-baseband: MOLY.LR12A.R2.MP.V138.11 (bootloader) version-bootloader: k63v2_64_bsp-aa07ba143a- 20210814151502- (bootloader) version-preloader: (bootloader) version: 0.5 all: Done!! Finished. Total time: 0.008s

Also here the serialno is GX290.... what means the right one for VollaPhoneX.

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/ubports/ubports-installer/issues/2833#issuecomment-1245529457, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAIX3RNI6V5SMAEEUQRPRITV6CIGZANCNFSM6AAAAAAQJ3PIN4 . You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID: @.***>

OlThHoCa commented 2 years ago

That was run in fastbootd, can you check again in normal fastboot/bootloader? Again, serial number is supposed to be unique for each device, this is the first time I see the model included in it.

OK the device doesn't start with power button. After this the Volla- Logo comes up an the Phone hangs. Starting the device with volume down and power button causes that the modeselection comes and the Phone hangs. Starting the device with volume up and power button has the result that the modeselection menue reacts to the buttons. from here the recovery mode will hang. The boot system option shows again the Volla-Logo and the system hangs. the Bootloader option starts the fastboot mode I used to generate the output last time. So from here i did following actions: @.:~$ fastboot reboot bootloader Rebooting into bootloader OKAY [ 0.003s] Finished. Total time: 0.053s @.:~$ fastboot getvar all (bootloader) max-download-size: 0x8000000 (bootloader) variant: (bootloader) logical-block-size: 0x200 (bootloader) erase-block-size: 0x80000 (bootloader) hw-revision: ca01 (bootloader) battery-soc-ok: yes (bootloader) battery-voltage: 4106mV (bootloader) partition-size:sgpt: 4200 (bootloader) partition-type:sgpt: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:flashinfo: 1000000 (bootloader) partition-type:flashinfo: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:userdata: d416fbe00 (bootloader) partition-type:userdata: ext4 (bootloader) partition-size:cache: 1b000000 (bootloader) partition-type:cache: ext4 (bootloader) partition-size:system: e0000000 (bootloader) partition-type:system: ext4 (bootloader) partition-size:vendor: 32000000 (bootloader) partition-type:vendor: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:tee2: c00000 (bootloader) partition-type:tee2: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:tee1: 500000 (bootloader) partition-type:tee1: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:dtbo: 800000 (bootloader) partition-type:dtbo: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:logo: 800000 (bootloader) partition-type:logo: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:boot: 2000000 (bootloader) partition-type:boot: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:lk2: 100000 (bootloader) partition-type:lk2: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:lk: 100000 (bootloader) partition-type:lk: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:nvram: 4000000 (bootloader) partition-type:nvram: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:gz2: 1000000 (bootloader) partition-type:gz2: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:gz1: 1000000 (bootloader) partition-type:gz1: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:sspm_2: 100000 (bootloader) partition-type:sspm_2: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:sspm_1: 100000 (bootloader) partition-type:sspm_1: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:spmfw: 100000 (bootloader) partition-type:spmfw: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:md1dsp: 1000000 (bootloader) partition-type:md1dsp: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:md1img: 4000000 (bootloader) partition-type:md1img: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:sec1: 200000 (bootloader) partition-type:sec1: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:persist: 3000000 (bootloader) partition-type:persist: ext4 (bootloader) partition-size:seccfg: 800000 (bootloader) partition-type:seccfg: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:protect2: e78000 (bootloader) partition-type:protect2: ext4 (bootloader) partition-size:protect1: 800000 (bootloader) partition-type:protect1: ext4 (bootloader) partition-size:metadata: 2000000 (bootloader) partition-type:metadata: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:nvdata: 4000000 (bootloader) partition-type:nvdata: ext4 (bootloader) partition-size:nvcfg: 2000000 (bootloader) partition-type:nvcfg: ext4 (bootloader) partition-size:frp: 100000 (bootloader) partition-type:frp: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:expdb: 1400000 (bootloader) partition-type:expdb: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:para: 80000 (bootloader) partition-type:para: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:recovery: 2000000 (bootloader) partition-type:recovery: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:boot_para: 100000 (bootloader) partition-type:boot_para: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:proinfo: 300000 (bootloader) partition-type:proinfo: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:pgpt: 8000 (bootloader) partition-type:pgpt: raw data (bootloader) partition-size:preloader: 40000 (bootloader) partition-type:preloader: raw data (bootloader) serialno: GX290Pro0029432 (bootloader) off-mode-charge: 1 (bootloader) warranty: no (bootloader) unlocked: yes (bootloader) secure: no (bootloader) kernel: lk (bootloader) product: k63v2_64_bsp (bootloader) is-userspace: no (bootloader) slot-count: 0 (bootloader) version-baseband: MOLY.LR12A.R2.MP.V138.11 (bootloader) version-bootloader: k63v2_64_bsp-aa07ba143a- 20210814151502- (bootloader) version-preloader: (bootloader) version: 0.5 all: Done!! Finished. Total time: 0.009s

I hope that helps... On any questions please ask me.

JamiKettunen commented 2 years ago

I think there's a simpler solution, we just don't include k63v2_64_bsp in aliases of yggdrasil.yml so the device doesn't get autodetected incorrectly in bootloader mode and the user instead has to choose it manually. Thoughts?

OlThHoCa commented 2 years ago

This would be nice. You can ask me to check it, if you want to verify the result.

OlThHoCa commented 2 years ago

This could be a solution.

JamiKettunen commented 2 years ago

@OlThHoCa That solution indeed was chosen already a month ago and has gone live, you could double-check this issue if you want :) Perhaps in the future a bootloader fix to report a more unique model for each device (yggdrasil and yggdrasilx) will be done so that they can still be auto-detected in bootloader mode as well.