Require a new pair of attributes for the <verse> element to be used for unambiguously identifying the start and end location for a verse or verse range.
Add the attribute sid for identifying the verse start location
Add the attribute 'eid for identifying the verse end location
Add the attribute vid to the <para> and <cell> elements in order to (re-)identify the current verse when the previous <para> or <cell> closed prior the end of the verse text.
Background
A milestone type markup is required when a document has two or more structures that interact in a non-hierarchical manner. This is also referred to as overlapping or concurrent markup. A principle example of this type of overlapping structure in scripture text is the contrast between 1) the paragraph structures used to express the discourse / narrative of the text and 2) the division of the text into books, chapters and verses. In scripture texts encoded using USX, the paragraph level markup forms the main structure of the document, while <chapter> and` elements are empty milestones which identify the location where the chapter or verse begins.
USX 3.0 adds a pair of attributes to <verse> (sid and eid) which are used to unambiguously identify the start and end position for scripture verse text within the scripture discourse structure. A companion attribute vid is added to <para> and <cell> in order to re-identify the current verse when the previous <para> or <cell> closed prior the end of the current verse text.
In USX 3.0 a <verse/> milestone is required at the start and at the end of the verse text, with corresponding sid and eid attributes. In previous versions of USX, only a <verse/> start milestone was required.
Example
Genesis 2:23-25
<para style="p">
<verse number="21" style="v" sid="GEN 2:21" />Then the <char style="nd">Lord</char> God
made the man fall into a deep sleep, and while he was sleeping, he took out one of the
man's ribs and closed up the flesh.<verse eid="GEN 2:21" />
<verse number="22" style="v" sid="GEN 2:22"/>He formed a woman out of the rib and brought
her to him.<verse eid="GEN 2:22" />
<verse number="23" style="v" sid="GEN 2:23" />Then the man said,
</para>
<para style="q1" vid="GEN 2:23">“At last, here is one of my own kind—</para>
<para style="q1" vid="GEN 2:23">Bone taken from my bone, and flesh from my flesh.</para>
<para style="q1" vid="GEN 2:23">‘Woman’ is her name because she was taken out of man.”
<verse eid="GEN 2:23" />
</para>
<para style="m">
<verse number="24" style="v" sid="GEN 2:24" />That is why a man leaves his father and mother
and is united with his wife, and they become one.<verse eid="GEN 2:24" />
</para>
<para style="p">
<verse number="25" style="v" sid="GEN 2:25" />The man and the woman were both naked, but
they were not embarrassed.<verse eid="GEN 2:25" />
</para>
Proposal
<verse>
element to be used for unambiguously identifying the start and end location for a verse or verse range.sid
for identifying the verse start location'eid
for identifying the verse end locationvid
to the<para>
and<cell>
elements in order to (re-)identify the current verse when the previous<para>
or<cell>
closed prior the end of the verse text.Background
A milestone type markup is required when a document has two or more structures that interact in a non-hierarchical manner. This is also referred to as overlapping or concurrent markup. A principle example of this type of overlapping structure in scripture text is the contrast between 1) the paragraph structures used to express the discourse / narrative of the text and 2) the division of the text into books, chapters and verses. In scripture texts encoded using USX, the paragraph level markup forms the main structure of the document, while` elements are empty milestones which identify the location where the chapter or verse begins.
<chapter> and
USX 3.0 adds a pair of attributes to
<verse>
(sid
andeid
) which are used to unambiguously identify the start and end position for scripture verse text within the scripture discourse structure. A companion attributevid
is added to<para>
and<cell>
in order to re-identify the current verse when the previous<para>
or<cell>
closed prior the end of the current verse text.In USX 3.0 a
<verse/>
milestone is required at the start and at the end of the verse text, with correspondingsid
andeid
attributes. In previous versions of USX, only a<verse/>
start milestone was required.Example
Genesis 2:23-25