ufieeehw / IEEE2015

GNU General Public License v2.0
5 stars 9 forks source link

xmega_connector should use IEEE2015 serial proxy #12

Closed jpanikulam closed 9 years ago

jpanikulam commented 9 years ago

We have added last year's xmega_connector as the ros-end of serial communication. This effectively replaces the old ieee2015_xmega_driver package, but there is still too much uncertainty to remove the old project.

The ideal path is to replace the communication components of the new one with the old one.

Advantages of the old serial proxy:

Advantages of new serial communication:

khaledhassan commented 9 years ago

Is the "old serial proxy" the one used in the 2014 competition, and the "new" one is what you guys wrote for this year's?

-- begin potentially obvious comment -- The message handling code on the XMEGA from last year only supported one message at a time, which necessitated the lock on the ROS side. If you want to remove the lock, you'd have to change the XMEGA firmware as well. -- end potentially obvious comment --

jpanikulam commented 9 years ago

@khaledhassan By old I mean new. Called "IEEE2015 Serial Proxy" from here on:

I think the real solution is somewhere in the middle. Key features to desire from the IEEE2015 proxy are:

Also: Props for being the first comment on an IEEE2015 issue.

jpanikulam commented 9 years ago

Migrated!