search

unexpectedpanda / retool

Retool: a better filter tool for Redump and No-Intro DAT files.
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
343 stars 22 forks source link

[Bug] Clone being left in 1G1R output for No Intro "Atari - Lynx" DAT #296

Closed Daeymon closed 6 months ago

Daeymon commented 7 months ago

Using the DAT file "Atari - Lynx (LYX) (20231231-205835)"

Both of these are making it into the 1G1R output despite one being a clone of the other within the DAT: "Find a Way to My Heart (World) (Aftermarket) (Unl)" "Find a Way to My Heart (World) (Atari Lynx 30th Birthday) (Aftermarket) (Unl)"

Edit: On second look, its doing this with all the "(Atari Lynx 30th Birthday)" clones.

unexpectedpanda commented 7 months ago

Thanks for the heads up!

Parent/clone relationships in DAT files are ignored in favor of Retool's own processing (far too many issues with parent/clone to rely on it).

Generally I update Retool's clone lists about once a month, which means occasionally fresh titles in DAT files slip the net. The 30th birthday entries were only recently added at the end of December.

So not a bug, just the nature of how things work. Given No-Intro and Redump are very unlikely to ever support proper 1G1R, it's the best we've got. That and reports like this that let me sneak in a specific change before my usual regular updates :)

I'll make an update later today so Retool recognizes the 30th birthday titles.

unexpectedpanda commented 6 months ago

Resolved. Looks like No-Intro came in with a 1-2 whammy and also renamed the Lynx DATs to include a format, which bypassed the clone list. You'll need Retool v2.01.9 and updated clone lists for full clone detection to resume.