search

unfoldedcircle / feature-and-bug-tracker

Feature and bug tracker repository for Unfolded Circle products
22 stars 0 forks source link

[bug] Activity in group does not behave as expected. #333

Closed uvjim closed 3 months ago

uvjim commented 4 months ago

Is there an existing issue for this?

Description

I have 2 activities: Watch TV and Watch Roku. Both are in an activity group. They have an on sequence and an off sequence. Currently these sequences only turn the relevant devices either on or off. I have placed the two activities on a page so that I can switch between them. However, here's the scenario as it plays out at present: -

Activity group details ```json { "group_id": "e82c77e3-8027-4a60-a203-a5003c3c14ea", "name": { "en": "Lounge" }, "description": {}, "options": { "remove_turn_on_delays": "previous_cmd_skipped", "turn_off_unused_entities": "always" }, "activities": [ { "entity_id": "uc.main.2b73e863-4542-4572-81df-2ab18b073ece", "name": { "en": "Watch TV" }, "icon": "uc:tv", "state": "ON" }, { "entity_id": "uc.main.042a222c-e6d6-40b5-9e79-a59f3a381586", "name": { "en": "Watch Roku" }, "icon": "custom:roku.png", "state": "OFF" } ], "state": "ACTIVE" } ```
Activity Definition (from REST API) ```json { "entity_id": "uc.main.2b73e863-4542-4572-81df-2ab18b073ece", "entity_type": "activity", "integration_id": "uc.main", "name": { "en": "Watch TV" }, "icon": "uc:tv", "features": [ "start" ], "description": { "en": "Activity for watching TV using the TiVo" }, "options": { "activity_group": { "group_id": "e82c77e3-8027-4a60-a203-a5003c3c14ea", "name": { "en": "Lounge" } }, "button_mapping": [ { "button": "BACK" }, { "button": "HOME" }, { "button": "VOICE" }, { "button": "VOLUME_UP", "short_press": { "cmd_id": "media_player.volume_up", "entity_id": "uc_androidtv_driver.main.FC017C39709A", "params": {} } }, { "button": "VOLUME_DOWN", "short_press": { "cmd_id": "media_player.volume_down", "entity_id": "uc_androidtv_driver.main.FC017C39709A", "params": {} } }, { "button": "GREEN", "short_press": { "cmd_id": "media_player.function_green", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec", "params": {} } }, { "button": "DPAD_UP", "short_press": { "cmd_id": "media_player.cursor_up", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec", "params": {} } }, { "button": "YELLOW", "short_press": { "cmd_id": "media_player.function_yellow", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec", "params": {} } }, { "button": "DPAD_LEFT", "short_press": { "cmd_id": "media_player.cursor_left", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec", "params": {} } }, { "button": "DPAD_MIDDLE", "short_press": { "cmd_id": "media_player.cursor_enter", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec", "params": {} } }, { "button": "DPAD_RIGHT", "short_press": { "cmd_id": "media_player.cursor_right", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec", "params": {} } }, { "button": "RED", "short_press": { "cmd_id": "media_player.function_red", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec", "params": {} } }, { "button": "DPAD_DOWN", "short_press": { "cmd_id": "media_player.cursor_down", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec", "params": {} } }, { "button": "BLUE", "short_press": { "cmd_id": "media_player.function_blue", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec", "params": {} } }, { "button": "CHANNEL_UP", "short_press": { "cmd_id": "media_player.channel_up", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec", "params": {} } }, { "button": "CHANNEL_DOWN", "short_press": { "cmd_id": "media_player.channel_down", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec", "params": {} } }, { "button": "MUTE", "short_press": { "cmd_id": "media_player.mute_toggle", "entity_id": "uc_androidtv_driver.main.FC017C39709A", "params": {} } }, { "button": "PREV", "short_press": { "cmd_id": "media_player.rewind", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec", "params": {} } }, { "button": "PLAY", "short_press": { "cmd_id": "media_player.play_pause", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec", "params": {} } }, { "button": "NEXT", "short_press": { "cmd_id": "media_player.fast_forward", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec", "params": {} } }, { "button": "POWER" } ], "included_entities": [ { "entity_commands": [ "media_player.on", "media_player.off", "media_player.volume", "media_player.volume_up", "media_player.volume_down", "media_player.mute_toggle", "media_player.play_pause", "media_player.next", "media_player.previous", "media_player.home", "media_player.back", "media_player.channel_up", "media_player.channel_down", "media_player.cursor_up", "media_player.cursor_down", "media_player.cursor_left", "media_player.cursor_right", "media_player.cursor_enter", "media_player.select_source" ], "entity_id": "uc_androidtv_driver.main.FC017C39709A", "entity_type": "media_player", "integration": { "icon": "uc:integration", "name": { "en": "Android TV" } }, "name": { "en": "KD-65XF9005" } }, { "entity_commands": [ "media_player.channel_up", "media_player.channel_down", "media_player.function_red", "media_player.function_green", "media_player.function_yellow", "media_player.function_blue", "media_player.cursor_up", "media_player.cursor_down", "media_player.cursor_left", "media_player.cursor_right", "media_player.cursor_enter", "media_player.fast_forward", "media_player.home", "media_player.back", "media_player.menu", "media_player.on", "media_player.off", "media_player.play_pause", "media_player.previous", "media_player.rewind", "media_player.stop" ], "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec", "entity_type": "media_player", "integration": { "icon": "uc:integration", "name": { "en": "Virgin Media TiVo (NEW DEV)" } }, "name": { "en": "Lounge TiVo" } }, { "entity_commands": [ "button.push" ], "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_guide", "entity_type": "button", "integration": { "icon": "uc:integration", "name": { "en": "Virgin Media TiVo (NEW DEV)" } }, "name": { "en": "Lounge TiVo: Guide" } }, { "entity_commands": [ "button.push" ], "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_info", "entity_type": "button", "integration": { "icon": "uc:integration", "name": { "en": "Virgin Media TiVo (NEW DEV)" } }, "name": { "en": "Lounge TiVo: Info" } }, { "entity_commands": [ "button.push" ], "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_num0", "entity_type": "button", "integration": { "icon": "uc:integration", "name": { "en": "Virgin Media TiVo (NEW DEV)" } }, "name": { "en": "Lounge TiVo: 0" } }, { "entity_commands": [ "button.push" ], "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_num1", "entity_type": "button", "integration": { "icon": "uc:integration", "name": { "en": "Virgin Media TiVo (NEW DEV)" } }, "name": { "en": "Lounge TiVo: 1" } }, { "entity_commands": [ "button.push" ], "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_num2", "entity_type": "button", "integration": { "icon": "uc:integration", "name": { "en": "Virgin Media TiVo (NEW DEV)" } }, "name": { "en": "Lounge TiVo: 2" } }, { "entity_commands": [ "button.push" ], "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_num3", "entity_type": "button", "integration": { "icon": "uc:integration", "name": { "en": "Virgin Media TiVo (NEW DEV)" } }, "name": { "en": "Lounge TiVo: 3" } }, { "entity_commands": [ "button.push" ], "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_num4", "entity_type": "button", "integration": { "icon": "uc:integration", "name": { "en": "Virgin Media TiVo (NEW DEV)" } }, "name": { "en": "Lounge TiVo: 4" } }, { "entity_commands": [ "button.push" ], "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_num5", "entity_type": "button", "integration": { "icon": "uc:integration", "name": { "en": "Virgin Media TiVo (NEW DEV)" } }, "name": { "en": "Lounge TiVo: 5" } }, { "entity_commands": [ "button.push" ], "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_num6", "entity_type": "button", "integration": { "icon": "uc:integration", "name": { "en": "Virgin Media TiVo (NEW DEV)" } }, "name": { "en": "Lounge TiVo: 6" } }, { "entity_commands": [ "button.push" ], "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_num7", "entity_type": "button", "integration": { "icon": "uc:integration", "name": { "en": "Virgin Media TiVo (NEW DEV)" } }, "name": { "en": "Lounge TiVo: 7" } }, { "entity_commands": [ "button.push" ], "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_num8", "entity_type": "button", "integration": { "icon": "uc:integration", "name": { "en": "Virgin Media TiVo (NEW DEV)" } }, "name": { "en": "Lounge TiVo: 8" } }, { "entity_commands": [ "button.push" ], "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_num9", "entity_type": "button", "integration": { "icon": "uc:integration", "name": { "en": "Virgin Media TiVo (NEW DEV)" } }, "name": { "en": "Lounge TiVo: 9" } }, { "entity_commands": [ "button.push" ], "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_record", "entity_type": "button", "integration": { "icon": "uc:integration", "name": { "en": "Virgin Media TiVo (NEW DEV)" } }, "name": { "en": "Lounge TiVo: Record" } }, { "entity_commands": [ "button.push" ], "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_thumbsdown", "entity_type": "button", "integration": { "icon": "uc:integration", "name": { "en": "Virgin Media TiVo (NEW DEV)" } }, "name": { "en": "Lounge TiVo: Thumbs Down" } }, { "entity_commands": [ "button.push" ], "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_thumbsup", "entity_type": "button", "integration": { "icon": "uc:integration", "name": { "en": "Virgin Media TiVo (NEW DEV)" } }, "name": { "en": "Lounge TiVo: Thumbs Up" } } ], "prevent_sleep": false, "sequences": { "off": [ { "command": { "cmd_id": "media_player.off", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec", "params": {} }, "type": "command" }, { "command": { "cmd_id": "media_player.off", "entity_id": "uc_androidtv_driver.main.FC017C39709A", "params": {} }, "type": "command" } ], "on": [ { "command": { "cmd_id": "media_player.on", "entity_id": "uc_androidtv_driver.main.FC017C39709A", "params": {} }, "type": "command" }, { "command": { "cmd_id": "media_player.on", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec", "params": {} }, "type": "command" } ] }, "user_interface": { "pages": [ { "grid": { "height": 5, "width": 3 }, "items": [ { "command": { "cmd_id": "button.push", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_guide", "params": {} }, "icon": "custom:television-guide-custom__1_.png", "location": { "x": 2, "y": 4 }, "size": { "height": 1, "width": 1 }, "type": "icon" }, { "command": { "cmd_id": "button.push", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_info", "params": {} }, "icon": "custom:information-variant-custom__1_.png", "location": { "x": 2, "y": 3 }, "size": { "height": 1, "width": 1 }, "type": "icon" }, { "command": { "cmd_id": "media_player.previous", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec", "params": {} }, "icon": "custom:swap-horizontal-bold-custom__1_.png", "location": { "x": 0, "y": 4 }, "size": { "height": 1, "width": 1 }, "type": "icon" }, { "command": { "cmd_id": "button.push", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_record", "params": {} }, "icon": "custom:record-rec-custom.png", "location": { "x": 0, "y": 3 }, "size": { "height": 1, "width": 1 }, "type": "icon" }, { "command": { "cmd_id": "media_player.menu", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec", "params": {} }, "icon": "custom:menu-custom.png", "location": { "x": 1, "y": 4 }, "size": { "height": 1, "width": 1 }, "type": "icon" }, { "command": { "cmd_id": "button.push", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_num0", "params": {} }, "icon": "custom:numeric-0-custom.png", "location": { "x": 1, "y": 3 }, "size": { "height": 1, "width": 1 }, "type": "icon" }, { "command": { "cmd_id": "button.push", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_num7", "params": {} }, "icon": "custom:numeric-7-custom.png", "location": { "x": 0, "y": 2 }, "size": { "height": 1, "width": 1 }, "type": "icon" }, { "command": { "cmd_id": "button.push", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_num8", "params": {} }, "icon": "custom:numeric-8-custom.png", "location": { "x": 1, "y": 2 }, "size": { "height": 1, "width": 1 }, "type": "icon" }, { "command": { "cmd_id": "button.push", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_num9", "params": {} }, "icon": "custom:numeric-9-custom.png", "location": { "x": 2, "y": 2 }, "size": { "height": 1, "width": 1 }, "type": "icon" }, { "command": { "cmd_id": "button.push", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_num6", "params": {} }, "icon": "custom:numeric-6-custom.png", "location": { "x": 2, "y": 1 }, "size": { "height": 1, "width": 1 }, "type": "icon" }, { "command": { "cmd_id": "button.push", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_num5", "params": {} }, "icon": "custom:numeric-5-custom.png", "location": { "x": 1, "y": 1 }, "size": { "height": 1, "width": 1 }, "type": "icon" }, { "command": { "cmd_id": "button.push", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_num4", "params": {} }, "icon": "custom:numeric-4-custom.png", "location": { "x": 0, "y": 1 }, "size": { "height": 1, "width": 1 }, "type": "icon" }, { "command": { "cmd_id": "button.push", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_num3", "params": {} }, "icon": "custom:numeric-3-custom.png", "location": { "x": 2, "y": 0 }, "size": { "height": 1, "width": 1 }, "type": "icon" }, { "command": { "cmd_id": "button.push", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_num2", "params": {} }, "icon": "custom:numeric-2-custom.png", "location": { "x": 1, "y": 0 }, "size": { "height": 1, "width": 1 }, "type": "icon" }, { "command": { "cmd_id": "button.push", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec_num1", "params": {} }, "icon": "custom:numeric-1-custom.png", "location": { "x": 0, "y": 0 }, "size": { "height": 1, "width": 1 }, "type": "icon" } ], "name": "New page", "page_id": "main" }, { "grid": { "height": 4, "width": 4 }, "items": [ { "command": { "cmd_id": "media_player.on", "entity_id": "uc_androidtv_driver.main.FC017C39709A", "params": {} }, "location": { "x": 0, "y": 3 }, "size": { "height": 1, "width": 2 }, "text": "TV Power", "type": "text" }, { "command": { "cmd_id": "media_player.on", "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec", "params": {} }, "location": { "x": 0, "y": 0 }, "size": { "height": 1, "width": 2 }, "text": "TiVo Power", "type": "text" } ], "name": "Misc", "page_id": "67ff90d1-3b1e-4ed3-b133-415b2cc35935" } ] } }, "attributes": { "state": "ON" }, "enabled": true } ```
Device details when Watch TV is first pressed (from REST API) DVR: - ```json { "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec", "device_class": "set_top_box", "entity_type": "media_player", "integration_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main", "name": { "en": "Lounge TiVo" }, "features": [ "channel_switcher", "color_buttons", "dpad", "fast_forward", "home", "menu", "on_off", "play_pause", "previous", "rewind", "stop" ], "description": {}, "options": null, "attributes": { "state": "ON" }, "enabled": true } ``` TV: - ```json { "entity_id": "uc_androidtv_driver.main.FC017C39709A", "device_class": "tv", "entity_type": "media_player", "integration_id": "uc_androidtv_driver.main", "name": { "en": "KD-65XF9005" }, "features": [ "on_off", "volume", "volume_up_down", "mute_toggle", "play_pause", "next", "previous", "home", "channel_switcher", "dpad", "select_source", "media_title" ], "description": {}, "options": null, "attributes": { "media_title": "com.sony.dtv.tvx", "muted": false, "source": "com.sony.dtv.tvx", "source_list": [ "Youtube", "Prime Video", "Plex", "Netflix", "HBO Max", "Max", "Emby", "Disney+", "Apple TV", "Spotify", "Ziggo", "Videoland", "Steam Link" ], "state": "ON", "volume": 22 }, "enabled": true } ```
Device details when Watch Roku is pressed (from REST API) DVR: - ```json { "entity_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main.fc5273bf14cd49d3b54cd4700b9771ec", "device_class": "set_top_box", "entity_type": "media_player", "integration_id": "uvjim_virginmediatv_dev_driver.main", "name": { "en": "Lounge TiVo" }, "features": [ "channel_switcher", "color_buttons", "dpad", "fast_forward", "home", "menu", "on_off", "play_pause", "previous", "rewind", "stop" ], "description": {}, "options": null, "attributes": { "state": "OFF" }, "enabled": true } ``` TV: - ```json { "entity_id": "uc_androidtv_driver.main.FC017C39709A", "device_class": "tv", "entity_type": "media_player", "integration_id": "uc_androidtv_driver.main", "name": { "en": "KD-65XF9005" }, "features": [ "on_off", "volume", "volume_up_down", "mute_toggle", "play_pause", "next", "previous", "home", "channel_switcher", "dpad", "select_source", "media_title" ], "description": {}, "options": null, "attributes": { "media_title": "com.sony.dtv.tvx", "muted": false, "source": "com.sony.dtv.tvx", "source_list": [ "Youtube", "Prime Video", "Plex", "Netflix", "HBO Max", "Max", "Emby", "Disney+", "Apple TV", "Spotify", "Ziggo", "Videoland", "Steam Link" ], "state": "ON", "volume": 22 }, "enabled": true } ```
Device details when changing back to Watch TV (from REST API) TV: - ```json { "entity_id": "uc_androidtv_driver.main.FC017C39709A", "device_class": "tv", "entity_type": "media_player", "integration_id": "uc_androidtv_driver.main", "name": { "en": "KD-65XF9005" }, "features": [ "on_off", "volume", "volume_up_down", "mute_toggle", "play_pause", "next", "previous", "home", "channel_switcher", "dpad", "select_source", "media_title" ], "description": {}, "options": null, "attributes": { "media_title": "com.sony.dtv.tvx", "muted": true, "source": "com.sony.dtv.tvx", "source_list": [ "Youtube", "Prime Video", "Plex", "Netflix", "HBO Max", "Max", "Emby", "Disney+", "Apple TV", "Spotify", "Ziggo", "Videoland", "Steam Link" ], "state": "OFF", "volume": 0 }, "enabled": true } ```
When using a button on the remote to turn the TV power on (from REST API) TV: - ```json { "entity_id": "uc_androidtv_driver.main.FC017C39709A", "device_class": "tv", "entity_type": "media_player", "integration_id": "uc_androidtv_driver.main", "name": { "en": "KD-65XF9005" }, "features": [ "on_off", "volume", "volume_up_down", "mute_toggle", "play_pause", "next", "previous", "home", "channel_switcher", "dpad", "select_source", "media_title" ], "description": {}, "options": null, "attributes": { "media_title": "com.sony.dtv.tvx", "muted": false, "source": "com.sony.dtv.tvx", "source_list": [ "Youtube", "Prime Video", "Plex", "Netflix", "HBO Max", "Max", "Emby", "Disney+", "Apple TV", "Spotify", "Ziggo", "Videoland", "Steam Link" ], "state": "ON", "volume": 22 }, "enabled": true } ```

How to Reproduce

As per description.

Expected behavior

The TV should stay on when switching back from Watch Roku to Watch TV because the device is still required to be on.

System version

1.6.10

What part of the system affected by the problem?

Core

Additional context

No response

uvjim commented 3 months ago

I'll close this. I think the issue is between keyboard and chair. Not in a position to test for a while, but I'm pretty sure it's an HDMI-CEC thing.