Open mannycolon opened 8 years ago
Naturalness: “this is my language”
Accuracy
0 1 2 A complete list of all important words in the source text for this chapter has been used to help ensure all terms are present in the translation.
0 1 2 All important words are translated correctly in this chapter.
0 1 2 All important words are translated consistently in this chapter, as well as in other places where the important words appear.
0 1 2 Exegetical resources have been used for the entire chapter to identify and resolve potential translation challenges.
0 1 2 Historical details in the source text (like names, places, and events) have been preserved in the translation.
0 1 2 The meaning of each figure of speech in the translated chapter has been compared and aligned to the intent of the original.
0 1 2 The translation has been tested with native speakers who were not involved in creating the translation and they agree that the translation accurately communicates the intended meaning of the source text.
0 1 2 The translation of this chapter has been compared against at least two source texts.
0 1 2 The translation of this chapter has been compared against the original texts (Hebrew, Greek, Aramaic) to check for correct lexical definitions and intent of the original texts.
Church approval
no | yes Church leaders who have checked this translation are native speakers of the target language, and include someone who understands well one of the languages in which the source text is available.
no | yes People from at least two different church networks have reviewed the translation of this chapter and agree that it is natural and clear.* (Note: this addresses the first part of the community check for Level 2.)*
no | yes Church leaders from at least two different church networks have reviewed the translation of this chapter and agree that it is accurate. (This addresses the final aspect of Level 2, the Church check).
no | yes The leadership or their delegates of at least two different church networks have reviewed the translation of this chapter and endorse it as a faithful translation of this chapter of the Bible in this language. (This addresses Level 3.)
Overview
Naturalness
Tool to answer questions in the rubric:
https://unfoldingword.org/quality/
Groups/categories:
Some of these are binary, yes/no, and others are ternary, 0/1/2, disagree/somewhat agree/strongly agree.
What does it take to develop the tQ tool
Things to be determined: