search

unitedworldwrestling / arena-public

14 stars 5 forks source link

Mistake in Nordic tournament semifinals' singlet color #22

Closed theswix closed 3 years ago

theswix commented 3 years ago

Which application you are experiencing a problem with Arena 1.5.72.1

Describe the bug In the Nordic tournament's semifinals there is a mistake in singlet color: as a rule, the wrestlers from group A wear red, from the group B - blue. Arena does it vice versa.

To Reproduce Steps to reproduce the behavior:

  1. Create Nordic tournament with 6 or 7 people
  2. Check the singlet color Arena offers for semifinalists.

Expected behavior In Nordic tournamet wrestlers in semifinals wear the following singlets: wrestlers from group A wear red singlets, wrestlers from group B - blue singlets

Screenshots These are from test event and created intentionally for this bug report nordic_mistake.pdf nordic_mistake2.pdf

csabavirag commented 3 years ago

The way how the colours are assigned to wrestlers in Arena is not about their source group, but their ranking position within their group. 1st gets Red, while 2nd is Blue.

Red: group A 1st vs. Blue: group B 2nd Red: group B 1st vs. Blue: group A 2nd

Checking internally if this must be done differently.

theswix commented 3 years ago

Hello, @csabavirag. Thank you for swift reply.

Well... I talked with a few IS referees from different countries yesterday, everyone confirmed that it is supposed to be blue and they are aware of this Arena behavior. Yet they believe it needs to be fixed. Actually I've had a conversation with @bouaziz1991 at one of the recent "Grand-Prix Ivan Yaryguin" tournaments in Krasnoyarsk, Russia and he admitted that he also knows about this bug.

And last but not least. UWW rules (February 2021 ed.), Article 8 on page 12 states pretty much clear:

"The semi-final matches will consist with:

which by default leads us to the red singlets for wrestlers in group A and blue singlets for wrestlers in group B, since the first named and called to the mat wrestler is always in red.

Sorry for being so obnoxious, I used to be Q&A lead in one of the Russian Linux distribution company :)

csabavirag commented 3 years ago

Hello @theswix, no problem at all. Let's wait for the official answer from the sports dept. Their words will confirm if this is by design or a bug and we will proceed accordingly. So thanks for raising this concern!

csabavirag commented 3 years ago

Hello @theswix, the decision is to keep everything as is for now. At the next update of the rules book (most likely for the next Olympic season), we should expect clarification, but until that Arena remains and the top ranked wrestlers of their round robin group will get the "red singlet" associated.

Thanks for your understanding and patience.