unlicense / unlicense.org

The source repository for the Unlicense.org website.
https://unlicense.org
49 stars 14 forks source link

License URI #74

Closed gkellogg closed 3 years ago

gkellogg commented 4 years ago

The difference between UNLICENSE and Public Domain (now obsoleted in favor of CC0) is obscure, if there is any.

As a license URI is commonly used on Description of a Project files as the value of doap:license, the difference might be described, but it would be good to have a specific versioned URL to use other than https://unlicense.org/ as an appropriate value, or explicitly suggest using an appropriate Creative Commons URI.

Hexstream commented 4 years ago

The difference between UNLICENSE and Public Domain (now obsoleted in favor of CC0) is obscure, if there is any.

My understanding is that the Unlicense is well-defined in all countries, whereas Public Domain is NOT well-defined in many countries.

artob commented 4 years ago

@gkellogg One option for an existing RDF URI would be https://unlicense.org/UNLICENSE, which contains the actual license text. In the unlikely event that there would be an Unlicense 2.0 in the future, that would definitely get a new, distinct URL.

Alternatively, we could go ahead and define an arbitrary and absolutely unambiguous URI, such as https://unlicense.org/1.0. I'm fine with either approach, let me know what you prefer.

@Hexstream This question is more about machine-readable URIs for ontologies than anything to do with legal matters.

gkellogg commented 4 years ago

I’d say the https://unlicense.org/1.0/ sends the right message, even thought there’s never likely the need for a 2.0, but who knows how regulation may affect the need for change.

It may also make sense for the link in the UNLICENCE text should refer there, rather than the site.

artob commented 4 years ago

@gkellogg We aren't changing the UNLICENSE text, it was bad enough to have to change it by a single character to migrate from HTTP to HTTPS :)

But OK, let's consider https://unlicense.org/1.0/ the canonical machine-readable URI for the 2010 revision of the Unlicense from hereon out. When I find the time, I'll sprinkle some JSON-LD over yonder when the site eventually gets rebooted (delayed due to current events).