Open SukkaW opened 7 hours ago
Interesting, thanks for the proposal!
I've been waiting on upgrading to eslint-plugin-sonarjs@^2
, because I was looking for a changelog (eslint-plugin-sonarjs@1.0.4
is 11MB). Moving to a different plugin / rules is an interesting alternative... 🤔 I'll have to consider whether any of the v2 rules are good enough to stick with it (or if there are good enough alternatives)
I have tried to submit a PR to
eslint-plugin-sonarjs
, but due to how they organize their monorepo and publish packages on npm, it seems impossible to move those dependencies to peer dependencies.
I would be interested in seeing the PR too - in case there's any chance that they would still approve and merge it, didn't see one in a first naive search
I have tried to submit a PR to
eslint-plugin-sonarjs
, but due to how they organize their monorepo and publish packages on npm, it seems impossible to move those dependencies to peer dependencies.I would be interested in seeing the PR too - in case there's any chance that they would still approve and merge it, didn't see one in a first naive search
I had a local copy of the repo and was trying to understand how they manage the monorepo and publish them to npm. But after experimenting here and there I eventually realize that I will have to submit a huge PR to change their building infrastructure completely. That's why I didn't submit a PR yet.
Ok thanks for the details!
cc @yassin-kammoun-sonarsource @vdiez in case you weren't aware of the size / dependency infrastructure issues with eslint-plugin-sonarjs
I've been waiting on upgrading to
eslint-plugin-sonarjs@^2
, because I was looking for a changelog (eslint-plugin-sonarjs@1.0.4
is 11MB).
BTW, it sounds a bit ironic as their eslint-plugin-sonarjs@1
repo (https://github.com/SonarSource/eslint-plugin-sonarjs) is very easy to contribute, but the SonarSource team has abandoned that repo and started maintaining eslint-plugin-sonarjs@2
in another repo (https://github.com/SonarSource/SonarJS) instead. The SonarJS
repo has a very bad code structure and a poor infrastructure.
https://pkg-size.dev/eslint-plugin-sonarjs
eslint-plugin-sonarjs
includes@babel/core
,vue-eslint-parser
,eslint-plugin-react
,eslint-plugin-import
,typescript-eslint@v7
all in its dependencies, resulting in an installation size of 87 MiB. It is ridiculous.I have tried to submit a PR to
eslint-plugin-sonarjs
, but due to how they organize their monorepo and publish packages on npm, it seems impossible to move those dependencies to peer dependencies.eslint-config-upleveled
only uses a few rules fromeslint-plugin-sonarjs
, but most of them have a replacement:sonarjs/no-duplicated-branches
andsonarjs/no-identical-conditions
@typescript-eslint/plugin
sonarjs/prefer-single-boolean-return
eslint-plugin-sonarjs
doesn't work on type, so the rule can only detect boolean literal, which might be limited.