urbanlaunchpad / new-market-goods

The digital storefront for New Market Goods
http://urbanlaunchpad.github.io/new-market-goods/
4 stars 5 forks source link

Filter selection for Yearbook images #72

Open ohsk opened 9 years ago

ohsk commented 9 years ago

Likely chosing a vsco filter, or one close to it, to generate more visual consistency in photo editing.

ohsk commented 9 years ago

I think I'm leaning toward M5... thoughts?

M5

1411521972 387129 img_3152

A4

1411521972 387129 img_3152 1

ohsk commented 9 years ago

Also liking the general brightness and quality of these photos on TRNK

Worried ours might get a little too yellowish...

buzoherbert commented 9 years ago

I also like M5 better. I'll start doing the script on photoshop. When do you want them ready?

buzoherbert commented 9 years ago

What do you thik about this one? I have a macro on photoshop for this one with color matching, contrast and brightness and some curves... ![Uploading test.jpg . . .]()

buzoherbert commented 9 years ago

test

ohsk commented 9 years ago

Looking pretty good! The main difference I see is more "white hotspots", for example on the right side of his face...

buzoherbert commented 9 years ago

Mmm, this is kind of different... Maybe too saturated? img_5804

buzoherbert commented 9 years ago

Less saturated img_5804

buzoherbert commented 9 years ago

An exact matching method. It would require adjustments image by image, more so on the colors.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WHvfVc_8eMc

ohsk commented 9 years ago

WHOA that curves adjustment approach is NUTS.

I do like the latest approach that you posted. In the interest of not overworking all the images, why don't we wait to do the photo editing until I've selected the ones we'll be using in the actual layout?

ohsk commented 9 years ago

I like the general effect of this VSCO cam one, but I think it makes the Bangladeshi skintones a bit too red...

Number Original LV3
1 photo oct 13 9 52 17 pm photo oct 13 9 53 12 pm
2 photo sep 24 6 56 12 am photo sep 24 6 56 12 am hdr
3 photo oct 13 9 53 49 pm photo oct 13 9 55 49 pm
4 photo sep 24 6 08 27 am photo sep 24 6 08 27 am 1
ohsk commented 9 years ago

Now with a bit of skin tone adjustment...

Number LV3 LV3 + skin tone
1 photo oct 13 9 53 12 pm photo oct 13 10 10 02 pm hdr
2 photo sep 24 6 56 12 am hdr photo sep 24 6 56 12 am 1
3 photo sep 24 6 08 27 am 1 photo sep 24 6 08 27 am 2
ohsk commented 9 years ago

And here's are old working one for reference with LV3 as well. Very close!

Your version LV3
77fb80fe-4fb4-11e4-8c11-1b44bfd6d9c1 77fb80fe-4fb4-11e4-8c11-1b44bfd6d9c1
ohsk commented 9 years ago

ohsk commented 9 years ago

Hey @buzoherbert, here's a quick update on the design of the yearbook (printed, at least). I decided to go grayscale for the images because (1) it's way cheaper in print production to limit the number of colors and (2) I think it actually makes everyone's faces stand out more. The eyes really pop, rather than just looking at a flurry of colors (although that is part of what makes it all beautiful!).

image

I have all the files linked, so what may be helpful is just doing a bit of contrast adjustment and white balancing as needed.

buzoherbert commented 9 years ago

Hey Sk, here is my take on the editing process, it took me only 1 minute per image tops and it consists on custom b&W conversion highlighing the main colors of the clothes people are wearing and some custom sharpening. There's no script, so each one of them would be custom, but it doesn't take that much time. What do you think on the general feel of them? Also, if you like the, could you do a test print to see if they look good on paper?

test 1 test 2 test 3

ohsk commented 9 years ago

Hey the edits are looking really good! Only a few seemed to get a little grainy; not sure if it's the original focus or any sharpening that was done...

Pankaj Hore.jpg image

Tarek.jpg image

Abu Zahid.jpg image

buzoherbert commented 9 years ago

Hey! I'll check those. I made the sharpening thinking about the small size of the final print, but still those maybe a little overdone...