search

urinieto / harmonixset

The Harmonix Set: Beats, Downbeats, and Structural Annotations for Pop Music
MIT License
149 stars 24 forks source link

Fix table structure in youtube_urls.csv #3

Open f90 opened 4 years ago

f90 commented 4 years ago

Hello again, thanks for providing the Youtube URLs. I just have a minor suggestion.

You also annotated in youtube_urls.csv if the Youtube version was slightly slower or faster than the version you used for annotating the dataset. Unfortunately you did not create another column in the csv for this, which makes automatic reading of the URLs a bit annoying since you have to cut off the extra comments after each URL.

Could you change it from this layout

File,URL
0046_castlesmadeofsand,https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=03lWKQtl9BU (backwards)

to this?

File,URL,Speed
0046_castlesmadeofsand,https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=03lWKQtl9BU, -1

where speed can indicate the factor by which to speed up or slow down (or reverse for negative values) the Youtube version?

Awesome work so far! Thanks!

urinieto commented 4 years ago

Good suggestion! Yeah, I was thinking about adding one or two extra columns with this. Will work on this in the next version.

I will keep this open until I change it.

Thanks!