search

urinieto / msaf

Music Structure Analysis Framework
MIT License
501 stars 79 forks source link

question about label id and effect on Chinese songs #151

Closed li-henan closed 1 year ago

li-henan commented 1 year ago

dear author, thanks for your contribution,it is a useful tool, there are several questions ,could you help ? I will appreciate it if you can reply 1、which boundaries_id and labels_id have best effect on Chinese songs and English songs? 2、when use different labels_id , different label ids are given, could you help to reply what label id represent?(verse, chorus and etc)

urinieto commented 1 year ago

Hi, find my answers below:

  1. I haven't done an experiment with Chinese songs, but my guess is that the best combination of algorithms is still sf (structural features) for boundaries and fmc2d (fourier magnitude coefficients 2D) for labels.
  2. Unfortunately, MSAF does not support classification of label identifiers into semantic labels such as verse, chorus, etc.