Closed EyalPazz closed 11 months ago
@CodiumAI-Agent
๐ฏ Main theme: Adding 'top_p' parameter to text completion methods
๐ Description and title: No
๐ Type of PR: Enhancement
๐งช Relevant tests added: Yes
โจ Minimal and focused: Yes, the PR is minimal and focused as it only adds a new parameter to the text completion methods and updates the corresponding tests.
๐ Security concerns: No, the PR does not introduce any obvious security concerns. It only adds a new parameter to existing methods and does not involve any sensitive data or security-critical operations.
๐ก General PR suggestions: The PR lacks a description which is important to understand the context and reason for the changes. It would be helpful to add a description explaining why the 'top_p' parameter was added and how it affects the text completion methods.
๐ค Code suggestions:
relevant file: llm_client/llm_api_client/base_llm_api_client.py suggestion content: Consider adding a docstring to the 'text_completion' method to explain the new 'top_p' parameter. This will help other developers understand its purpose and how it should be used. [important]
relevant file: tests/llm_api_client/openai_client/test_openai.py suggestion content: It would be beneficial to add some tests that specifically check the behavior of the 'top_p' parameter. For instance, you could test how the method behaves with different 'top_p' values. [medium]
relevant file: llm_client/llm_api_client/ai21_client.py suggestion content: In the 'text_completion' method, the 'top_p' parameter is set to None by default. It would be better to set a default value that reflects the typical use case, or if None is a valid value, explain what it means in the method's docstring. [medium]
relevant file: llm_client/llm_api_client/anthropic_client.py suggestion content: In the 'text_completion' method, the 'top_p' parameter is set to -1 by default. It would be better to set a default value that reflects the typical use case, or if -1 is a valid value, explain what it means in the method's docstring. [medium]
Tag me in a comment '@CodiumAI-Agent' to ask for a new review after you update the PR. You can also tag me and ask any question, for example '@CodiumAI-Agent is the PR ready for merge?'
You didn't update BaseLLMAPIClient.text_completion function