usdot-jpo-ode / wzdx

The Work Zone Data Exchange (WZDx) Specification aims to make harmonized work zone data provided by infrastructure owners and operators (IOOs) available for third party use, making travel on public roads safer and more efficient through ubiquitous access to data on work zone activity.
Creative Commons Zero v1.0 Universal
89 stars 62 forks source link

Refine WorkerPresenceMethod enumerations #290

Open mark-mockett opened 2 years ago

mark-mockett commented 2 years ago

Summary

Consider adding/removing values from the WorkerPresenceMethod enumerated type in future versions of the spec to align better with the SwzDeviceFeed, data producer capabilities, and data consumer needs.

Motivation

Enumerated values for the WorkerPresenceMethod may need to be reviewed/refined in the future as the device feed's options change and as data producers begin implementing the WorkerPresence object.

The WorkerPresence object contains an option to specify by what means the data producer knows workers are in the field. As of v4.0, the WorkerPresenceMethod enumerated type includes the following values:

Value Description
camera-monitoring Cameras in the work zone event area show workers are present.
arrow-board-present A GPS-enabled arrow board is located in the work zone event area and broadcasting its location, implying that workers are present.
cones-present GPS-enabled cones are located in the road event area, implying that workers are present.
maintenance-vehicle-present A GPS-enabled maintenance vehicle is located in the road event area, implying that workers are present.
wearables-present Workers wearing wearable detection equipment are present in the work zone.
mobile-device-present Workers with GPS-enabled mobile device tracking are present in the work zone.
check-in-app Workers have checked into the work zone via a mobile app.
check-in-verbal Workers have checked into the work zone via phone or radio to a remote operations center.
scheduled Workers are scheduled to be in the road event area, but presence has not been confirmed.

Proposed changes

Several of the "proxy" enumerations - those that end with "implying that workers are present" - could be combined if data consumers don't find the differentiation between different equipment types to be useful.

Additionally, to align with the devices included in the SwzDeviceFeed, consider adding: Value Rationale
Hybrid Sign They could represent a digital speed limit sign which is used as proxy for worker presence in some states
Flashing Beacon Popular in many state to activate flashing beacon when workers are present
Location Marker That categories includes many others proxy for worker presence. EX: AFAD, flagger, work zone starts/end.

Worker Presence co-chairs propose revisiting the enumeration in a future version of the specification, not in the next release (v4.1, expected August 2022).