Closed seeratawan01 closed 2 weeks ago
Here are some key observations to aid the review process:
๐ Score: 85 |
๐งช No relevant tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Recommended focus areas for review Error Handling The error handling in transport methods should be reviewed to ensure that they gracefully handle exceptions and provide useful feedback to the user or system. Local Storage Access The code should handle potential exceptions when accessing local storage more robustly, especially considering different browser security settings that might block local storage access. |
relevant file | packages/javascript-sdk/src/core/client.ts |
suggestion | Consider adding a fallback or default value for `config.namespace` to ensure it always has a valid value. [important] |
relevant line | this.namespace = config.namespace || 'usermaven'; |
relevant file | packages/javascript-sdk/src/core/client.ts |
suggestion | Ensure that `RetryQueue` initialization parameters are validated or have sensible defaults to prevent potential issues with extreme values. [medium] |
relevant line | this.retryQueue = new RetryQueue( |
relevant file | packages/javascript-sdk/src/persistence/local-storage.ts |
suggestion | Add error handling for JSON parsing in the `load` method to catch and handle potential exceptions from malformed data. [important] |
relevant line | this.logger.error('Error loading from localStorage:', error); |
relevant file | packages/javascript-sdk/src/transport/fetch.ts |
suggestion | Consider implementing retry logic in `FetchTransport.send` method for failed HTTP requests, especially for recoverable HTTP statuses. [medium] |
relevant line | throw new Error(`HTTP error! status: ${response.status}`); |
relevant file | packages/javascript-sdk/src/utils/helpers.ts |
suggestion | Refactor `parseLogLevel` to throw an error or log a warning when an unrecognized log level is passed. This will prevent silent failures. [medium] |
relevant line | return LogLevel.ERROR; |
Explore these optional code suggestions:
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Enhancement |
Implement error handling for JSON parsing in the
___
**Add error handling for JSON parsing in the | 9 |
Enhance the
___
**Refactor the | 6 | |
Possible bug |
Initialize the logger before it is used in the RetryQueue constructor___ **Ensure that thelogger is initialized before using it in the RetryQueue constructor to avoid potential reference errors.** [packages/javascript-sdk/src/core/client.ts [35-36]](https://github.com/usermaven/usermaven-js/pull/123/files#diff-cf1b46df259d6f5f7aa4358f3de9b0e4ca7051836cc3f55729ad1c56a5f7ac40R35-R36) ```diff +this.logger = getLogger(this.config.logLevel); this.retryQueue = new RetryQueue( this.transport, this.config.maxSendAttempts || 3, this.config.minSendTimeout || 1000, 10, 200, // Reduced interval to .2 second this.logger ); ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: The suggestion addresses a potential bug by ensuring the logger is initialized before being used in the RetryQueue constructor, which is crucial for preventing reference errors and ensuring proper logging functionality. | 8 |
Best practice |
Add validation for the
___
**Validate the | 7 |
PR Type
Enhancement, Bug fix
Description
Changes walkthrough ๐
10 files
client.ts
Improve logging configuration and integration in UsermavenClient
packages/javascript-sdk/src/core/client.ts
local-storage.ts
Integrate logger into LocalStoragePersistence
packages/javascript-sdk/src/persistence/local-storage.ts
autocapture.ts
Enhance logging and element handling in AutoCapture
packages/javascript-sdk/src/tracking/autocapture.ts
beacon.ts
Integrate logger into BeaconTransport
packages/javascript-sdk/src/transport/beacon.ts
fetch.ts
Integrate logger into FetchTransport
packages/javascript-sdk/src/transport/fetch.ts
https.ts
Integrate logger into HttpsTransport
packages/javascript-sdk/src/transport/https.ts
xhr.ts
Integrate logger into XhrTransport
packages/javascript-sdk/src/transport/xhr.ts
helpers.ts
Refine log level parsing and default setting
packages/javascript-sdk/src/utils/helpers.ts
logger.ts
Allow configurable log level in logger
packages/javascript-sdk/src/utils/logger.ts - Added log level parameter to getLogger function.
queue.ts
Integrate logger into RetryQueue
packages/javascript-sdk/src/utils/queue.ts
2 files
config.ts
Update default logging level to ERROR
packages/javascript-sdk/src/core/config.ts - Changed default log level from WARN to ERROR.
index.html
Simplify script tag by removing log level attribute
packages/javascript-sdk/examples/index.html - Removed data-log-level attribute from script tag.
1 files
common.ts
Adjust logging level for window availability check
packages/javascript-sdk/src/utils/common.ts - Changed logger call from error to warn for window availability.