Closed seeratawan01 closed 2 weeks ago
Here are some key observations to aid the review process:
๐ Score: 85 |
๐งช No relevant tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Recommended focus areas for review Possible Bug The method `extractTopLevelDomain` uses a regex that might not correctly handle all valid TLDs, especially newer or less common ones. Performance Issue The `extractHostname` method could be optimized by using URL parsing instead of manual string operations, which might be error-prone and less efficient. |
relevant file | packages/javascript-sdk/src/utils/cookie.ts |
suggestion | Consider using the URL API for parsing and handling URLs in the `extractHostname` method to improve reliability and readability. [important] |
relevant line | let hostname: string; |
relevant file | packages/javascript-sdk/src/utils/cookie.ts |
suggestion | Refactor the `extractTopLevelDomain` method to use a more comprehensive regex or a dedicated library for TLD extraction to ensure accuracy. [important] |
relevant line | const DOMAIN_MATCH_REGEX = /[a-z0-9][a-z0-9-]+\.[a-z.]{2,6}$/i; |
Explore these optional code suggestions:
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Enhancement |
Improve the reliability and accuracy of hostname extraction by utilizing URL parsing___ **Optimize theextractHostname method by using URL parsing instead of manual string operations to improve reliability and handle edge cases.** [packages/javascript-sdk/src/utils/cookie.ts [68-74]](https://github.com/usermaven/usermaven-js/pull/125/files#diff-304a2517b554eaf957917f59494746ca14cd003a21f6076e2db28255dcafe5ccR68-R74) ```diff -if (url.indexOf("//") > -1) { - hostname = url.split('/')[2]; -} else { - hostname = url.split('/')[0]; -} -hostname = hostname.split(':')[0]; -hostname = hostname.split('?')[0]; +const parsedUrl = new URL(url); +return parsedUrl.hostname; ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: This suggestion significantly enhances the reliability of hostname extraction by using the URL API, which is more robust and handles edge cases better than manual string operations. | 9 |
Improve error handling by catching exceptions that occur when attempting to set cookies___ **Add error handling for the case wheredocument.cookie is not accessible or modifiable, such as in some restricted environments or when cookies are blocked by the browser.** [packages/javascript-sdk/src/utils/cookie.ts [16]](https://github.com/usermaven/usermaven-js/pull/125/files#diff-304a2517b554eaf957917f59494746ca14cd003a21f6076e2db28255dcafe5ccR16-R16) ```diff -document.cookie = `${name}=${value};${expires};path=/;domain=${this.cookieDomain}${secureFlag}${httpOnlyFlag}`; +try { + document.cookie = `${name}=${value};${expires};path=/;domain=${this.cookieDomain}${secureFlag}${httpOnlyFlag}`; +} catch (e) { + console.error('Failed to set cookie:', e); +} ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Adding error handling for setting cookies is beneficial, especially in environments where cookies might be restricted. This enhances the code's robustness by preventing unhandled exceptions. | 7 | |
Possible issue |
Enhance the robustness of the cookie deletion process by handling potential undefined or empty domain values___ **Ensure that thedelete method correctly handles the case where this.cookieDomain might be undefined or an empty string, which could lead to an invalid cookie deletion command.** [packages/javascript-sdk/src/utils/cookie.ts [32]](https://github.com/usermaven/usermaven-js/pull/125/files#diff-304a2517b554eaf957917f59494746ca14cd003a21f6076e2db28255dcafe5ccR32-R32) ```diff -document.cookie = `${name}=; expires=Thu, 01 Jan 1970 00:00:00 UTC; path=${path};domain=${this.cookieDomain}`; +document.cookie = `${name}=; expires=Thu, 01 Jan 1970 00:00:00 UTC; path=${path};domain=${this.cookieDomain || 'defaultDomain.com'}`; ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: This suggestion addresses a potential issue where the cookie deletion might fail if `this.cookieDomain` is undefined or empty. By providing a default domain, it ensures that the deletion command remains valid, enhancing robustness. | 8 |
Best practice |
Enhance the accuracy and maintainability of IP address validation___ **Refactor theisIpAddress method to use a regular expression for IP address validation to ensure accuracy and improve maintainability.** [packages/javascript-sdk/src/utils/cookie.ts [62-63]](https://github.com/usermaven/usermaven-js/pull/125/files#diff-304a2517b554eaf957917f59494746ca14cd003a21f6076e2db28255dcafe5ccR62-R63) ```diff -const parts = url.split('.'); -return parts.length === 4 && parts.every(part => !isNaN(Number(part))); +return /^(\d{1,3}\.){3}\d{1,3}$/.test(url); ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: Using a regular expression for IP address validation improves accuracy and maintainability, as it simplifies the logic and reduces potential errors in manual parsing. | 6 |
PR Type
Enhancement, Bug fix
Description
get
method inCookieManager
to decode cookie values, ensuring correct retrieval.isIpAddress
,extractHostname
,extractRootDomain
, andextractTopLevelDomain
.delete
method to accept an optionalpath
parameter, providing more flexibility in cookie management.Changes walkthrough ๐
cookie.ts
Enhance cookie management and domain extraction logic
packages/javascript-sdk/src/utils/cookie.ts
robustly.