Closed seeratawan01 closed 2 weeks ago
Here are some key observations to aid the review process:
๐ Score: 72 |
๐งช No relevant tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Recommended focus areas for review Possible Bug The `mergeConfig` method might cause a stack overflow if there are circular references in the configuration objects. This method uses recursion without handling circular references, which can lead to infinite recursion. Performance Issue The `trackInternal` method is called within a loop in the `RetryQueue` class, which could lead to performance issues if the queue is large. This method sends network requests and should be optimized for batch processing. Code Smell The `id` method in `UsermavenClient` class has a boolean parameter `doNotSendEvent` which leads to multiple responsibilities within the method. Consider splitting this method into two separate methods to handle identification and event sending distinctly. |
relevant file | packages/javascript-sdk/src/core/client.ts |
suggestion | Consider adding error handling for JSON parsing in the `mergeConfig` method to catch and handle potential exceptions that can arise from malformed input. [important] |
relevant line | const cleanConfig = JSON.parse(JSON.stringify(config)); |
relevant file | packages/javascript-sdk/src/core/client.ts |
suggestion | To improve the performance of the `trackInternal` method, consider implementing a batching mechanism that aggregates events and sends them in bulk rather than one at a time. This can reduce the number of network requests and improve the efficiency of data transmission. [important] |
relevant line | this.trackInternal(typeName, payload, directSend); |
relevant file | packages/javascript-sdk/src/core/client.ts |
suggestion | Refactor the `id` method by creating a separate method for sending the identification event. This separation of concerns can make the code cleaner and easier to maintain. [important] |
relevant line | if (!doNotSendEvent) { |
Explore these optional code suggestions:
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Possible bug |
Ensure all used functions are properly imported or defined to avoid runtime errors___ **Ensure that theisElementNode function is imported or defined in the current or a globally accessible scope, as it is used to check if el is an element node.**
[packages/javascript-sdk/src/utils/autocapture-utils.ts [171-172]](https://github.com/usermaven/usermaven-js/pull/99/files#diff-3421105f040b57611a61997529e3c66ca2a0ee572e2ff04008bd6bea93aa71a3R171-R172)
```diff
+import { isElementNode } from 'path/to/module';
+...
if (!el || !isElementNode(el)) {
return false;
}
```
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: The suggestion addresses a potential bug by ensuring that the `isElementNode` function is imported or defined, which is crucial for preventing runtime errors when the function is called. | 9 |
Enhance robustness by ensuring that objects and properties exist before accessing them___ **Consider checking for the existence ofwindow and document before accessing window.document.createElement to prevent potential reference errors in non-browser environments.** [packages/javascript-sdk/src/utils/common.ts [316-318]](https://github.com/usermaven/usermaven-js/pull/99/files#diff-43df5b60f1b780217be1dab54c8a87a626c72a97751bab7dcced7f4693fb56a9R316-R318) ```diff return typeof window !== 'undefined' && - window.document !== undefined && - window.document.createElement !== undefined; + typeof window.document !== 'undefined' && + typeof window.document.createElement === 'function'; ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: The suggestion improves the robustness of the code by ensuring that `window` and `document` are defined before accessing their properties, which is important for preventing reference errors in non-browser environments. | 8 | |
Add checks for required HTML attributes to prevent runtime errors___ **Consider checking for the presence of required attributes likedata-key and data-tracking-host in the HTMLScriptElement before using them to prevent runtime errors.** [packages/javascript-sdk/src/index.ts [27-29]](https://github.com/usermaven/usermaven-js/pull/99/files#diff-02046ed2ea7c73d60e8f714d301b8e29ef6141c1b53d9f8504cd73f187a55050R27-R29) ```diff -key: script.getAttribute('data-key') || undefined, -trackingHost: script.getAttribute('data-tracking-host') || 'https://events.usermaven.com', +key: script.getAttribute('data-key') || throw new Error('data-key attribute is required'), +trackingHost: script.getAttribute('data-tracking-host') || throw new Error('data-tracking-host attribute is required'), ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 3Why: The suggestion to check for required HTML attributes before using them is reasonable, but the proposed syntax is incorrect. The use of `throw` in a logical expression is not valid, reducing the effectiveness of the suggestion. | 3 | |
Validate the API key in the configuration to ensure it is not null or empty___ **Ensure that thekey attribute in the config object is validated for non-null and non-empty values to prevent runtime errors when the API key is required for operations.** [packages/javascript-sdk/src/index.ts [9-12]](https://github.com/usermaven/usermaven-js/pull/99/files#diff-02046ed2ea7c73d60e8f714d301b8e29ef6141c1b53d9f8504cd73f187a55050R9-R12) ```diff const cleanConfig = JSON.parse(JSON.stringify(config)); +if (!cleanConfig.key) { + throw new Error('API key cannot be null or empty.'); +} const camelCaseConfig = convertKeysToCamelCase(cleanConfig); const mergedConfig: Config = { ...defaultConfig, ...camelCaseConfig } as Config; ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 2Why: The suggestion to validate the API key for null or empty values is redundant because the existing code already throws an error if the key is not present. The improvement is minimal and doesn't significantly enhance the existing validation logic. | 2 | |
Enhancement |
Implement error handling for JSON parsing to manage exceptions from malformed configurations___ **Add error handling for JSON parsing to catch and manage potential exceptions frommalformed input configurations.** [packages/javascript-sdk/src/index.ts [10]](https://github.com/usermaven/usermaven-js/pull/99/files#diff-02046ed2ea7c73d60e8f714d301b8e29ef6141c1b53d9f8504cd73f187a55050R10-R10) ```diff -const cleanConfig = JSON.parse(JSON.stringify(config)); +let cleanConfig; +try { + cleanConfig = JSON.parse(JSON.stringify(config)); +} catch (error) { + throw new Error('Failed to parse configuration: ' + error.message); +} ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Adding error handling for JSON parsing is a valuable enhancement that can prevent runtime errors due to malformed configurations. This improves the robustness of the code by providing clear error messages when parsing fails. | 7 |
Use native JavaScript methods for better performance and standard practices___ **UseArray.isArray(obj) directly instead of a custom function to check if obj is an array, as it is more standard and performant.** [packages/javascript-sdk/src/utils/common.ts [19-20]](https://github.com/usermaven/usermaven-js/pull/99/files#diff-43df5b60f1b780217be1dab54c8a87a626c72a97751bab7dcced7f4693fb56a9R19-R20) ```diff function (obj: any): obj is any[] { - return toString.call(obj) === '[object Array]' + return Array.isArray(obj); } ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: The suggestion to use `Array.isArray(obj)` instead of a custom function aligns with standard practices and improves performance, making it a beneficial enhancement. | 7 | |
Replace JSON stringify/parse with a deep cloning function to handle complex object types more reliably___ **Use a more robust method for deep cloning theconfig object to avoid potential issues with JSON stringify/parse, such as losing methods or handling of special types like Date or undefined.** [packages/javascript-sdk/src/index.ts [10]](https://github.com/usermaven/usermaven-js/pull/99/files#diff-02046ed2ea7c73d60e8f714d301b8e29ef6141c1b53d9f8504cd73f187a55050R10-R10) ```diff -const cleanConfig = JSON.parse(JSON.stringify(config)); +const cleanConfig = deepClone(config); ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: Using a more robust deep cloning method can prevent issues related to JSON stringify/parse limitations, such as handling special types like Date or undefined. This suggestion improves the reliability of the code when dealing with complex objects. | 6 | |
Improve the
___
**Consider using a more descriptive | 5 | |
Possible issue |
Verify and test font file paths to ensure proper loading and rendering___ **Ensure that the font files are correctly loaded by verifying the paths and testingacross different browsers to avoid issues with font rendering.** [examples/next-app/src/app/layout.tsx [7-16]](https://github.com/usermaven/usermaven-js/pull/99/files#diff-11f17983113855f424000e9b0d58f859395eb340ff1ab567a144e3a3b17b7c6cR7-R16) ```diff +const geistSans = localFont({ + src: "./fonts/GeistVF.woff", + variable: "--font-geist-sans", + weight: "100 900", +}); +const geistMono = localFont({ + src: "./fonts/GeistMonoVF.woff", + variable: "--font-geist-mono", + weight: "100 900", +}); - ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 3Why: The suggestion to verify and test font file paths is valid but not actionable as it only advises on testing without providing specific code changes. It is a general recommendation rather than a direct code improvement. | 3 |
User description
This PR represents a significant refactoring and enhancement of the Usermaven JavaScript SDK. Key changes include:
Improved Architecture:
Enhanced Features:
Performance Optimizations:
Privacy and Security:
Developer Experience:
Testing and Quality:
Build System:
PR Type
Enhancement, Tests
Description
UsermavenClient
class with enhanced features including event tracking, user identification, and group identification.AutoCapture
class for automatic event capturing andFormTracking
class for tracking form submissions.RetryQueue
class for event retry logic andRageClick
class for detecting rage clicks.XhrTransport
,HttpsTransport
,FetchTransport
,BeaconTransport
) for different transport mechanisms.Changes walkthrough ๐
20 files
client.ts
Implement core client functionality with enhanced features
packages/javascript-sdk/src/core/client.ts
UsermavenClient
class with enhanced features.identification.
autocapture.ts
Add AutoCapture class for automatic event tracking
packages/javascript-sdk/src/tracking/autocapture.ts
AutoCapture
class for automatic event capturing.form-tracking.ts
Implement FormTracking class for form submission tracking
packages/javascript-sdk/src/tracking/form-tracking.ts
FormTracking
class for tracking form submissions.FormTracking
instance.index.ts
Export UsermavenClient and setup initialization functions
packages/javascript-sdk/src/index.ts
UsermavenClient
and related types.scroll-depth.ts
Refactor ScrollDepth class for improved scroll tracking
packages/javascript-sdk/src/extensions/scroll-depth.ts
ScrollDepth
class for tracking scroll depth.common.ts
Add utility functions for common operations
packages/javascript-sdk/src/utils/common.ts
useUsermaven.ts
Update useUsermaven hook for React integration
packages/react/src/useUsermaven.ts
useUsermaven
hook for React integration.cookie.ts
Implement CookieManager class for cookie operations
packages/javascript-sdk/src/utils/cookie.ts
CookieManager
class for cookie operations.queue.ts
Implement RetryQueue class for event retry logic
packages/javascript-sdk/src/utils/queue.ts
RetryQueue
class for event retry logic.autocapture-utils.ts
Add utility functions for autocapture operations
packages/javascript-sdk/src/utils/autocapture-utils.ts
usePageView.ts
Implement usePageView hook for page view tracking
packages/react/src/usePageView.ts
usePageView
hook for page view tracking.useUsermaven
hook.usePageView.ts
Implement usePageView hook for Next.js page view tracking
packages/nextjs/src/usePageView.ts
usePageView
hook for Next.js page view tracking.useUsermaven
hook.useUsermaven.ts
Update useUsermaven hook for Next.js integration
packages/nextjs/src/useUsermaven.ts
useUsermaven
hook for Next.js integration.rage-click.ts
Implement RageClick class for detecting rage clicks
packages/javascript-sdk/src/extensions/rage-click.ts
RageClick
class for detecting rage clicks.UsermavenClient
.helpers.ts
Add helper functions for common tasks
packages/javascript-sdk/src/utils/helpers.ts
xhr.ts
Implement XhrTransport class for XHR-based transport
packages/javascript-sdk/src/transport/xhr.ts
XhrTransport
class for XHR-based transport.UsermavenClient
.https.ts
Implement HttpsTransport class for HTTPS transport
packages/javascript-sdk/src/transport/https.ts
HttpsTransport
class for HTTPS transport.UsermavenClient
.config.ts
Define configuration interface for UsermavenClient
packages/javascript-sdk/src/core/config.ts
UsermavenClient
.fetch.ts
Implement FetchTransport class for Fetch API transport
packages/javascript-sdk/src/transport/fetch.ts
FetchTransport
class for Fetch API transport.UsermavenClient
.beacon.ts
Implement BeaconTransport class for Beacon API transport
packages/javascript-sdk/src/transport/beacon.ts
BeaconTransport
class for Beacon API transport.UsermavenClient
.3 files
event-tracking.test.ts
Add unit tests for event tracking in UsermavenClient
packages/javascript-sdk/test/unit/core/event-tracking.test.ts
UsermavenClient
event tracking.autocapture.
client.test.ts
Add unit tests for UsermavenClient methods
packages/javascript-sdk/test/unit/core/client.test.ts
UsermavenClient
methods.server-side-client.test.ts
Add unit tests for server-side UsermavenClient
packages/javascript-sdk/test/unit/core/server-side-client.test.ts
UsermavenClient
.2 files
page.tsx
Add example Next.js page component
examples/next-app/src/app/page.tsx
test.ts
Add example script for testing Usermaven SDK
packages/javascript-sdk/examples/test.ts
53 files
pageviews.ts
...
packages/javascript-sdk/src/tracking/pageviews.ts ...
vite.config.ts
...
packages/javascript-sdk/vite.config.ts ...
local-storage.ts
...
packages/javascript-sdk/src/persistence/local-storage.ts ...
App.tsx
...
examples/react-app/src/App.tsx ...
types.ts
...
packages/javascript-sdk/src/core/types.ts ...
UsermavenProvider.tsx
...
packages/react/src/UsermavenProvider.tsx ...
logger.ts
...
packages/javascript-sdk/src/utils/logger.ts ...
layout.tsx
...
examples/next-app/src/app/layout.tsx ...
main.tsx
...
examples/react-app/src/main.tsx ...
LayoutWrapper.tsx
...
examples/next-app/src/component/client/LayoutWrapper.tsx ...
setup.ts
...
packages/javascript-sdk/test/setup.ts ...
UsermavenProvider.tsx
...
packages/nextjs/src/UsermavenProvider.tsx ...
vitest.config.ts
...
packages/javascript-sdk/vitest.config.ts ...
middlewareEnv.ts
...
packages/nextjs/src/middlewareEnv.ts ...
memory.ts
...
packages/javascript-sdk/src/persistence/memory.ts ...
vitest.d.ts
...
packages/javascript-sdk/test/vitest.d.ts ...
vite.config.ts
...
examples/react-app/vite.config.ts ...
global.d.ts
...
packages/javascript-sdk/src/global.d.ts ...
transport.ts
...
packages/javascript-sdk/src/transport/transport.ts ...
vite-env.d.ts
...
examples/react-app/src/vite-env.d.ts ...
form-tracking.html
...
packages/javascript-sdk/examples/form-tracking.html ...
index.html
...
packages/javascript-sdk/examples/index.html ...
index.html
...
examples/react-app/index.html ...
mergeFiles.js
...
mergeFiles.js ...
mockServer.js
...
packages/javascript-sdk/server/mockServer.js ...
copyContents.js
...
scripts/copyContents.js ...
eslint.config.js
...
examples/react-app/eslint.config.js ...
page.module.css
...
examples/next-app/src/app/page.module.css ...
index.css
...
examples/react-app/src/index.css ...
App.css
...
examples/react-app/src/App.css ...
globals.css
...
examples/next-app/src/app/globals.css ...
pnpm-lock.yaml
...
pnpm-lock.yaml ...
README.md
...
packages/javascript-sdk/README.md ...
README.md
...
examples/react-app/README.md ...
package.json
...
packages/javascript-sdk/package.json ...
README.md
...
README.md ...
package.json
...
examples/react-app/package.json ...
tsconfig.json
...
packages/javascript-sdk/tsconfig.json ...
README.md
...
examples/next-app/README.md ...
package.json
...
package.json ...
README.md
...
packages/nextjs/README.md ...
tsconfig.json
...
examples/next-app/tsconfig.json ...
tsconfig.app.json
...
examples/react-app/tsconfig.app.json ...
package.json
...
examples/next-app/package.json ...
tsconfig.node.json
...
examples/react-app/tsconfig.node.json ...
README.md
...
packages/react/README.md ...
.eslintrc.json
...
packages/javascript-sdk/.eslintrc.json ...
package.json
...
packages/react/package.json ...
package.json
...
packages/nextjs/package.json ...
.prettierrc
...
packages/javascript-sdk/.prettierrc ...
tsconfig.json
...
examples/react-app/tsconfig.json ...
next.config.mjs
...
examples/next-app/next.config.mjs ...
pnpm-workspace.yaml
...
pnpm-workspace.yaml ...