Open racheljohns opened 4 years ago
Hi Rachel, thank you for the detailed information!
We are investigating to see if issue 1 above is related to the conversion to XML or the source SGML data. I'll get back to you on this one.
Regarding the images referenced in issue 2, please check out the ZIP file of images available in https://www.govinfo.gov/bulkdata/ECFR/title-49. Each CFR Title folder contains a ZIP file of images. For example in ECFR-title49-graphics.zip, there are images named ec01au91.007.gif and er02fe95.014.gif.
Hi Rachel, I have more information about issue 1.
Please note that the site which is referenced in your message, gov.ecfr.io, is not a Government site that is maintained by GPO/OFR.
The eCFR Government website that maintained by GPO/OFR is www.ecfr.gov, and XML bulk data is available on GPO's govinfo at www.govinfo.gov/bulkdata/ECFR.
Regarding issue 1, the nesting in the XML appears to be correct, but but the hierarchy display seems to be misleading. Here is the XML content structure:
Section “90.601 Scope” is a child node of “Subpart S – Regulations Governing.” Next, at the same level (under Subpart S) is a subgroup titled “Application for Authorizations.” Sections 90.603 through 90.609 are within that subgroup. Similarly, the next subgroup under “Subpart S” is “Policies Governing the Processing”, and that subgroup contains sections 90.613 thru 90.633.
The problem (as shown in the image in your message) seems to be those subgroups are displayed slightly indented relative to Scope (making them appear to be nested under Scope). Those subgroups should not be indented relative to Scope.
Also, as displayed above, the content does not end prematurely at section 90.621.
The image links are also correct in the XML. See below.
XML:
<P>(b) Fill the hose assembly with brake fluid, seal the lower end, and place the test assembly in an oven in a vertical position.</P>
<img src="http://www.ecfr.gov/graphics/ec01au91.007.gif"/>
Display:
(b) Fill the hose assembly with brake fluid, seal the lower end, and place the test assembly in an oven in a vertical position.
I hope this helps!
Hello @llaplant thank you for your detailed response on this!
I will relay this information back to our team. Thank you again!
Hello @llaplant ,
I spoke to our team about this, and we believe the above is referring to the ECFR? I actually was referring to the CFR Annual Edition, I apologize for the mistake.
Do you know if the same thing applies in that version of the CFR? The data our team has looks like this:
One of the developers wrote:
"You can see how we go from 90.621 straight to Chapter II
.
That means that the sections up to 90.633 are missing? And the chapters "118 Technical Regulations Regarding" and 119 and 120? From what I can tell, the data after 90.621 has somehow made it into the the "Content" field of 90.621.
E.g. if I search for "Technical Regulations Regarding" I find that string in the Content of 90.621. It looks like this "<SUBJGRP> <p>Technical Regulations Regarding the Use of Frequencies in the 806-824 MHz, 851-869 MHz, 896-901 MHz, and 935-940 MHz Bands</p>"
Or, if I search for "90.633" it shows up in the Content of 90.621 like this: " <SECTION> <SECTNO>§ 90.633</SECTNO>"
Please let me know if our team is on the right track, and I truly appreciate your help!
@racheljohns could you send me a link to the CFR source data XML file you are using from govinfo? I want to make sure we are discussing the same file.
ECFR files can be found here: https://www.govinfo.gov/bulkdata/ECFR
CFR Annual edition files can be found here: https://www.govinfo.gov/bulkdata/CFR
Hello @llaplant,
Thank you for all your help! We are using the Annual edition files at https://www.govinfo.gov/bulkdata/CFR.
Hi @racheljohns, could you verify this is the specific file you are using?
https://www.govinfo.gov/bulkdata/CFR/2019/title-47/CFR-2019-title47-vol5.xml
Section 90.623:
PDF for reference on structure: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CFR-2019-title47-vol5/pdf/CFR-2019-title47-vol5.pdf
TOC:
@llaplant on our side some of the tags have been converted but based on the files I have in front of me they appear to be based on this specific file yes!
@racheljohns does the structure represented in the XML file and screenshot above answer your questions or do you need additional information?
@llaplant is it possible for the developers I'm speaking with to reach out to you directly? Is there an email I could give to them? They can probably explain what they are having trouble with better than I can!
@racheljohns is it possible for developers to join the conversation here?
@llaplant I have informed them and sent them a link to this issue! Thank you so much for your help!
Thanks, @llaplant!
I took a look at the original XML file (https://www.govinfo.gov/bulkdata/CFR/2019/title-47/CFR-2019-title47-vol5.xml).
As best I can tell, the issue is with sect. 90.621. It has an EDNOTE
that doesn't close in the correct spot. On line 69,451 it opens. It contains revised text of 90.621. I suspect it was intended to be closed at line 69,642. Since it does not close, the next sections (90.623++) end up within the EDNOTE
of 90.621.
If it helps, the current closing tag for the EDNOTE
on line 69,451 appears to be on line 96,235. If this is correct, the closing SECTION
tag for 90.621 would also need to be moved to match.
Could you double check and tell me if I'm missing something?
Cheers!
@gholker, great catch!
Apologize for the delay.
Took some time to troubleshoot, correct in source data, and make available in systems.
Updated file is now available.
https://www.govinfo.gov/bulkdata/CFR/2019/title-47/CFR-2019-title47-vol5.xml
Here's what we did in section 90.621.
Opening Before Fix with <EDNOTE><SUPERSED><SECTION>
:
Opening After Fix with <EDNOTE><REVTXT><SECTION>
:
Closing Before Fix with <STARS/></SECTION><SECTION>
:
Closing After Fix with <STARS/></SECTION></REVTXT></EDNOTE></SECTION><SECTION>
:
Happy to continue the discussion if this does not fully resolve the issue or answer your question.
Thanks, @llaplant! Did a diff and it looks good to me 👍
@llaplant, I went further and wrote a script to look for this type of issue. You can find it here: https://gist.github.com/gholker/cc978acc387a3d8fe52472182277f5e5
Essentially it searches for SECTION
s that contain other SECTION
s whose SECTNO
doesn't match the parent's `SECTNO'. The full output is here:
output-2019.txt
There are 8 that stood out to me (listed below). I haven't had a chance to manually inspect them, but suspect they may be similar situations to 90.621
from above.
Checking file at path: ./CFR-2019/title-36/CFR-2019-title36-vol3.xml
§ 327.30
contains mismatched sections § 327.31,§ 328.1,§ 328.2,§ 328.3,§ 328.4,§ 328.5,§ 328.6,§ 328.7,§ 330.1,§ 330.2,§ 330.3,§ 330.4,§ 330.5,§ 330.6,§ 330.7,§ 330.8,§ 331.1,§ 331.2,§ 331.3,§ 331.4,§ 331.5,§ 331.6,§ 331.7,§ 331.8,§ 331.9,§ 331.10,§ 331.11,§ 331.12,§ 331.13,§ 331.14,§ 331.15,§ 331.16,§ 331.17,§ 331.18,§ 331.19,§ 331.20,§ 331.21,§ 331.22,§ 331.23,§ 331.24,§ 331.25
Checking file at path: ./CFR-2019/title-31/CFR-2019-title31-vol1.xml
§ 50.115
contains mismatched sections § 56.1,§ 56.2,§ 82.1,§ 82.2,§ 82.3,§ 82.4,§ 91.1,§ 91.2,§ 91.3,§ 91.4,§ 91.5,§ 91.6,§ 91.7,§ 91.8,§ 91.9,§ 91.10,§ 91.11,§ 91.12,§ 91.13,§ 91.14,§ 92.1,§ 92.2,§ 92.3,§ 92.4,§ 92.5,§ 92.6,§ 92.11,§ 92.12,§ 92.13,§ 92.14,§ 92.15,§ 92.16,§ 92.17,§ 92.18,§ 100.2,§ 100.3,§ 100.4,§ 100.5,§ 100.6,§ 100.7,§ 100.8,§ 100.9,§ 100.10,§ 100.11,§ 100.12,§ 100.13,§ 100.16,§ 100.17,§ 100.18,§ 100.19,§ 101.1,§ 101.2,§ 101.3,§ 101.4,§ 101.5,§ 101.6,§ 101.7,§ 101.8,§ 128.1,§ 128.2,§ 128.3,§ 128.4,§ 128.5,§ 128.11,§ 128.12,§ 128.13,§ 128.21,§ 128.22,§ 128.23,§ 129.1,§ 129.2,§ 129.3,§ 129.4,§ 129.5,§ 129.6,§ 132.1,§ 132.2,§ 132.3,§ 132.4,§ 132.5,§ 132.6,§ 132.7,§ 148.1,§ 148.2,§ 148.3,§ 148.4,§ 149.1,§ 149.2,§ 149.3,§ 150.1,§ 150.2,§ 150.3,§ 150.4,§ 150.5,§ 150.6
Checking file at path: ./CFR-2019/title-7/CFR-2019-title7-vol6.xml
§ 400.768
contains mismatched sections § 400.765,§ 400.766,§ 400.767,§ 402.1,§ 402.2,§ 402.3,§ 402.4,§ 407.1,§ 407.2,§ 407.3,§ 407.4,§ 407.5,§ 407.6,§ 407.7,§ 407.8,§ 407.9,§ 407.10,§ 407.11,§ 407.12,§ 407.13,§ 407.14,§ 407.15,§ 407.16,§ 407.17,§ 412.1,§ 412.2,§ 412.3,§ 412.4,§ 412.5,§ 412.6,§ 457.1,§ 457.2,§ 457.3,§ 457.4,§ 457.5,§ 457.6,§ 457.7,§ 457.8,§ 457.9,§§ 457.10-457.100,§ 457.101,§ 457.102,§ 457.103,§ 457.104,§ 457.105,§ 457.106,§ 457.107,§ 457.108,§ 457.109,§ 457.110,§ 457.111,§ 457.112,§ 457.113,§§ 457.114-457.115,§ 457.116,§ 457.117,§ 457.118,§ 457.119,§ 457.120,§ 457.121,§ 457.122,§ 457.123,§ 457.124,§ 457.125,§ 457.126,§ 457.127,§ 457.128,§ 457.129,§ 457.130,§ 457.131,§ 457.132,§ 457.133,§ 457.134,§ 457.135,§ 457.136,§ 457.137,§ 457.138,§ 457.139,§ 457.140,§ 457.141,§ 457.142,§ 457.143,§ 457.144,§ 457.145,§ 457.146,§ 457.147,§ 457.148,§ 457.149,§ 457.150,§ 457.151,§ 457.151,§ 457.152,§ 457.153,§ 457.154,§ 457.155,§§ 457.156-457.157,§ 457.158,§ 457.159,§ 457.160,§ 457.161,§ 457.162,§ 457.163,§ 457.164,§ 457.165,§ 457.166,§ 457.167,§ 457.168,§ 457.169,§ 457.170,§ 457.171,§ 457.172,§ 457.173,§ 457.174,§ 457.175,§ 457.176
Checking file at path: ./CFR-2019/title-12/CFR-2019-title12-vol7.xml
§ 702.206
contains mismatched sections § 702.201,§ 702.202,§ 702.203,§ 702.204,§ 702.205,§ 702.207,§ 702.208,§ 702.209,§ 702.210,§ 702.301,§ 702.302,§ 702.303,§ 702.304,§ 702.305,§ 702.306,§ 702.307,§ 702.401,§ 702.402,§ 702.403,§ 702.501,§ 702.502,§ 702.503,§ 702.504,§ 702.505,§ 702.506,§ 703.1,§ 703.2,§ 703.3,§ 703.4,§ 703.5,§ 703.6,§ 703.7,§ 703.8,§ 703.9,§ 703.10,§ 703.11,§ 703.12,§ 703.13,§ 703.14,§ 703.15,§ 703.16,§ 703.17,§ 703.18,§ 703.19,§ 703.20,§ 703.100,§ 703.101,§ 703.102,§ 703.103,§ 703.104,§ 703.105,§ 703.106,§ 703.107,§ 703.108,§ 703.109,§ 703.110,§ 703.111,§ 703.112,§ 703.113,§ 703.114,§ 704.1,§ 704.2,§ 704.3,§ 704.4,§ 704.5,§ 704.6,§ 704.7,§ 704.8,§ 704.9,§ 704.10,§ 704.11,§ 704.12,§ 704.13,§ 704.14,§ 704.15,§ 704.16,§ 704.17,§ 704.18,§ 704.19,§ 704.21,§ 704.22,§ 705.1,§ 705.2,§ 705.3,§ 705.4,§ 705.5,§ 705.6,§ 705.7,§ 705.8,§ 705.9,§ 705.10,§ 707.1,§ 707.2,§ 707.3,§ 707.4,§ 707.5,§ 707.6,§ 707.7,§ 707.8,§ 707.9,§ 707.10,§ 707.11,§ 708a.101,§ 708a.102,§ 708a.103,§ 708a.104,§ 708a.105,§ 708a.106,§ 708a.107,§ 708a.108,§ 708a.109,§ 708a.110,§ 708a.111,§ 708a.112,§ 708a.113,§ 708a.301,§ 708a.302,§ 708a.303,§ 708a.304,§ 708a.305,§ 708a.306,§ 708a.307,§ 708a.308,§ 708a.309,§ 708a.310,§ 708a.311,§ 708a.312,§ 708b.1,§ 708b.2,§ 708b.101,§ 708b.102,§ 708b.103,§ 708b.104,§ 708b.105,§ 708b.106,§ 708b.107,§ 708b.108,§ 708b.201,§ 708b.202,§ 708b.203,§ 708b.204,§ 708b.205,§ 708b.206,§ 708b.301,§ 708b.302,§ 708b.303,§ 708b.304,§ 709.0,§ 709.1,§ 709.2,§ 709.3,§ 709.4,§ 709.5,§ 709.6,§ 709.7,§ 709.8,§ 709.9,§ 709.10,§ 709.11,§ 709.12,§ 710.0,§ 710.1,§ 710.2,§ 710.3,§ 710.4,§ 710.5,§ 710.6,§ 710.7,§ 710.8,§ 710.9,§ 711.1,§ 711.2,§ 711.3,§ 711.4,§ 711.5,§ 711.6,§ 711.7,§ 711.8,§ 712.1,§ 712.2,§ 712.3,§ 712.4,§ 712.5,§ 712.6,§ 712.8,§ 712.9,§ 712.10,§ 712.11,§ 713.1,§ 713.2,§ 713.3,§ 713.4,§ 713.5,§ 713.6,§ 713.6,§ 713.7,§ 714.1,§ 714.2,§ 714.3,§ 714.4,§ 714.5,§ 714.6,§ 714.7,§ 714.8,§ 714.9,§ 714.10,§ 715.1,§ 715.2,§ 715.3,§ 715.4,§ 715.5,§ 715.6,§ 715.7,§ 715.8,§ 715.9,§ 715.10,§ 715.11,§ 715.12,§ 716.1,§ 717.1,§ 717.2,§ 717.3,§ 717.20,§ 717.21,§ 717.22,§ 717.23,§ 717.24,§ 717.25,§ 717.26,§ 717.27,§ 717.28,§ 717.30,§ 717.31,§ 717.32,§ 717.40,§ 717.41,§ 717.42,§ 717.43,§§ 717.80-717.81,§ 717.82,§ 717.83,§ 717.90,§ 717.91,§ 721.1,§ 721.2,§ 721.3,§ 721.4,§ 721.5,§ 721.6,§ 721.7,§ 722.1,§ 722.2,§ 722.3,§ 722.4,§ 722.5,§ 722.6,§ 722.7,§ 723.1,§ 723.2,§ 723.3,§ 723.4,§ 723.5,§ 723.6,§ 723.7,§ 723.8,§ 723.9,§ 723.10,§ 724.1,§ 724.2,§ 724.3,§ 725.1,§ 725.2,§ 725.3,§ 725.4,§ 725.5,§ 725.6,§ 725.7,§§ 725.8-725.16,§ 725.17,§ 725.18,§ 725.19,§ 725.20,§ 725.21,§ 725.22,§ 725.23,§ 740.0,§ 740.1,§ 740.2,§ 740.3,§ 740.4,§ 740.5,§ 741.0,§ 741.1,§ 741.2,§ 741.3,§ 741.4,§ 741.5,§ 741.6,§ 741.7,§ 741.8,§ 741.9,§ 741.10,§ 741.11,§ 741.12,§ 741.13,§ 741.201,§ 741.202,§ 741.203,§ 741.204,§ 741.205,§ 741.206,§ 741.207,§ 741.208,§ 741.209,§ 741.210,§ 741.211,§ 741.212,§ 741.213,§ 741.214,§ 741.215,§ 741.216,§ 741.217,§ 741.218,§ 741.219,§ 741.220,§ 741.221,§ 741.222,§ 741.223,§ 741.224,§ 741.225,§ 745.0,§ 745.1,§ 745.2,§ 745.3,§ 745.4,§ 745.5,§ 745.6,§ 745.7,§ 745.8,§ 745.9-1,§ 745.9-2,§ 745.10,§ 745.11,§ 745.12,§ 745.13,§ 745.14,§ 745.200,§ 745.201,§ 745.202,§ 746.101,§ 746.102,§ 746.103,§ 746.104,§ 746.105,§ 746.106,§ 746.107,§ 746.108,§ 746.109,§ 746.110,§ 746.111,§ 746.112,§ 746.113,§ 746.201,§ 746.202,§ 746.203,§ 746.204,§ 746.205,§ 746.206,§ 746.207,§ 747.0,§ 747.1,§ 747.2,§ 747.3,§ 747.4,§ 747.5,§ 747.6,§ 747.7,§ 747.8,§ 747.9,§ 747.10,§ 747.11,§ 747.12,§ 747.13,§ 747.14,§ 747.15,§ 747.16,§ 747.17,§ 747.18,§ 747.19,§ 747.20,§ 747.21,§ 747.22,§ 747.23,§ 747.24,§ 747.25,§ 747.26,§ 747.27,§ 747.28,§ 747.29,§ 747.30,§ 747.31,§ 747.32,§ 747.33,§ 747.34,§ 747.35,§ 747.36,§ 747.37,§ 747.38,§ 747.39,§ 747.40,§ 747.41,§ 747.100,§ 747.201,§ 747.202,§ 747.203,§ 747.204,§ 747.205,§ 747.206,§ 747.207,§ 747.208,§ 747.301,§ 747.302,§ 747.303,§ 747.304,§ 747.305,§ 747.306,§ 747.307,§ 747.308,§ 747.309,§ 747.310,§ 747.311,§ 747.401,§ 747.402,§ 747.403,§ 747.404,§ 747.405,§ 747.406,§ 747.601,§ 747.602,§ 747.603,§ 747.604,§ 747.605,§ 747.606,§ 747.607,§ 747.608,§ 747.609,§ 747.610,§ 747.611,§ 747.612,§ 747.613,§ 747.614,§ 747.615,§ 747.616,§ 747.701,§ 747.702,§ 747.703,§ 747.801,§ 747.802,§ 747.803,§ 747.804,§ 747.805,§ 747.806,§ 747.807,§ 747.1001,§ 747.2001,§ 747.2002,§ 747.2003,§ 747.2004,§ 747.2005,§ 747.3001,§ 747.3002,§ 747.3003,§ 747.3004,§ 747.3005,§ 747.3006,§ 748.0,§ 748.1,§ 748.2,§ 749.0,§ 749.1,§ 749.2,§ 749.3,§ 749.4,§ 749.5,§ 750.0,§ 750.1,§ 750.2,§ 750.3,§ 750.4,§ 750.5,§ 750.6,§ 750.7,§ 760.1,§ 760.2,§ 760.3,§ 760.4,§ 760.5,§ 760.6,§ 760.7,§ 760.8,§ 760.9,§ 760.10,§ 761.1
Checking file at path: ./CFR-2019/title-40/CFR-2019-title40-vol1.xml
§ 2.108
contains mismatched sections § 2.100,§ 2.101,§ 2.102,§ 2.103,§ 2.104,§ 2.105,§ 2.106,§ 2.107,§ 2.201,§ 2.202,§ 2.203,§ 2.204,§ 2.205,§ 2.206,§ 2.207,§ 2.208,§ 2.209,§ 2.210,§ 2.211,§ 2.212,§ 2.213,§ 2.214,§ 2.215,§§ 2.216-2.300,§ 2.301,§ 2.302,§ 2.303,§ 2.304,§ 2.305,§ 2.306,§ 2.307,§ 2.308,§ 2.309,§ 2.310,§ 2.311,§ 2.401,§ 2.402,§ 2.403,§ 2.404,§ 2.405,§ 2.406,§ 3.1,§ 3.2,§ 3.3,§ 3.4,§ 3.10,§ 3.20,§ 3.1000,§ 3.2000,§ 4.1,§ 5.100,§ 5.105,§ 5.110,§ 5.115,§ 5.120,§ 5.125,§ 5.130,§ 5.135,§ 5.140,§ 5.200,§ 5.205,§ 5.210,§ 5.215,§ 5.220,§ 5.225,§ 5.230,§ 5.235,§ 5.300,§ 5.305,§ 5.310,§ 5.400,§ 5.405,§ 5.410,§ 5.415,§ 5.420,§ 5.425,§ 5.430,§ 5.435,§ 5.440,§ 5.445,§ 5.450,§ 5.455,§ 5.500,§ 5.505,§ 5.510,§ 5.515,§ 5.520,§ 5.525,§ 5.530,§ 5.535,§ 5.540,§ 5.545,§ 5.550,§ 5.600,§ 5.605,§ 6.100,§ 6.101,§ 6.102,§ 6.103,§ 6.200,§ 6.201,§ 6.202,§ 6.203,§ 6.204,§ 6.205,§ 6.206,§ 6.207,§ 6.208,§ 6.209,§ 6.210,§ 6.300,§ 6.301,§ 6.302,§ 6.303,§ 6.400,§ 6.401,§ 6.402,§ 6.403,§ 6.404,§ 6.405,§ 6.406,§ 7.10,§ 7.15,§ 7.20,§ 7.25,§ 7.30,§ 7.35,§ 7.45,§ 7.50,§ 7.55,§ 7.60,§ 7.65,§ 7.70,§ 7.75,§ 7.80,§ 7.85,§ 7.90,§ 7.95,§ 7.100,§ 7.105,§ 7.110,§ 7.115,§ 7.120,§ 7.125,§ 7.130,§ 7.135,§ 7.140,§ 7.145,§ 7.150,§ 7.155,§ 7.160,§ 7.165,§ 7.170,§ 7.175,§ 7.180,§ 8.1,§ 8.2,§ 8.3,§ 8.4,§ 8.5,§ 8.6,§ 8.7,§ 8.8,§ 8.9,§ 8.10,§ 8.11,§ 8.12,§ 9.1,§ 10.1,§ 10.2,§ 10.3,§ 10.4,§ 10.5,§ 10.6,§ 10.7,§ 10.8,§ 10.9,§ 10.10,§ 10.11,§ 11.1,§ 11.2,§ 11.3,§ 11.4,§ 11.5,§ 11.6,§ 12.101,§ 12.102,§ 12.103,§§ 12.104-12.109,§ 12.110,§ 12.111,§§ 12.112-12.129,§ 12.130,§§ 12.131-12.139,§ 12.140,§§ 12.141-12.148,§ 12.149,§ 12.150,§ 12.151,§§ 12.152-12.159,§ 12.160,§§ 12.161-12.169,§ 12.170,§§ 12.171-12.999,§ 13.1,§ 13.2,§ 13.3,§ 13.4,§ 13.5,§ 13.6,§ 13.7,§ 13.8,§ 13.9,§ 13.10,§ 13.11,§ 13.12,§ 13.13,§ 13.14,§ 13.15,§ 13.16,§ 13.17,§ 13.18,§ 13.19,§ 13.20,§ 13.21,§ 13.22,§ 13.23,§ 13.24,§ 13.25,§ 13.26,§ 13.27,§ 13.28,§ 13.29,§ 13.30,§ 13.31,§ 13.32,§ 13.33,§ 13.34,§ 13.35,§ 13.36,§ 13.37,§ 13.38,§ 13.39,§ 13.40,§ 14.1,§ 14.2,§ 14.3,§ 14.4,§ 14.5,§ 14.6,§ 14.7,§ 14.8,§ 14.9,§ 14.10,§ 14.11,§ 14.12,§ 14.13,§ 14.14,§ 16.1,§ 16.2,§ 16.3,§ 16.4,§ 16.5,§ 16.6,§ 16.7,§ 16.8,§ 16.9,§ 16.10,§ 16.11,§ 16.12,§ 17.1,§ 17.2,§ 17.3,§ 17.4,§ 17.5,§ 17.6,§ 17.7,§ 17.8,§ 17.11,§ 17.12,§ 17.13,§ 17.14,§ 17.21,§ 17.22,§ 17.23,§ 17.24,§ 17.25,§ 17.26,§ 17.27,§ 17.28,§ 17.29,§ 18.1,§ 18.2,§ 18.3,§ 18.4,§ 18.5,§ 18.6,§ 18.7,§ 18.8,§ 18.9,§ 18.10,§ 18.11,§ 19.1,§ 19.2,§ 19.3,§ 19.4,§ 20.1,§ 20.2,§ 20.3,§ 20.4,§ 20.5,§ 20.6,§ 20.7,§ 20.8,§ 20.9,§ 20.10,§ 21.1,§ 21.2,§ 21.3,§ 21.4,§ 21.5,§ 21.6,§ 21.7,§ 21.8,§ 21.9,§ 21.10,§ 21.11,§ 21.12,§ 21.13,§ 22.1,§ 22.2,§ 22.3,§ 22.4,§ 22.5,§ 22.6,§ 22.7,§ 22.8,§ 22.9,§ 22.10,§ 22.11,§ 22.12,§ 22.13,§ 22.14,§ 22.15,§ 22.16,§ 22.17,§ 22.18,§ 22.19,§ 22.20,§ 22.21,§ 22.22,§ 22.23,§ 22.24,§ 22.25,§ 22.26,§ 22.27,§ 22.28,§ 22.29,§ 22.30,§ 22.31,§ 22.32,§ 22.33,§ 22.34,§ 22.35,§ 22.36,§ 22.37,§ 22.38,§ 22.39,§ 22.40,§ 22.41,§ 22.42,§ 22.43,§ 22.44,§ 22.45,§§ 22.46-22.49,§ 22.50,§ 22.51,§ 22.52,§ 23.1,§ 23.2,§ 23.3,§ 23.4,§ 23.5,§ 23.6,§ 23.7,§ 23.8,§ 23.9,§ 23.10,§ 23.11,§ 23.12,§ 24.01,§ 24.02,§ 24.03,§ 24.04,§ 24.05,§ 24.06,§ 24.07,§ 24.08,§ 24.09,§ 24.10,§ 24.11,§ 24.12,§ 24.13,§ 24.14,§ 24.15,§ 24.16,§ 24.17,§ 24.18,§ 24.19,§ 24.20,§ 25.1,§ 25.2,§ 25.3,§ 25.4,§ 25.5,§ 25.6,§ 25.7,§ 25.8,§ 25.9,§ 25.10,§ 25.11,§ 25.12,§ 25.13,§ 25.14,§ 26.101,§ 26.102,§ 26.103,§ 26.104,§§ 26.105-26.106,§ 26.107,§ 26.108,§ 26.109,§ 26.110,§ 26.111,§ 26.112,§ 26.113,§ 26.114,§ 26.115,§ 26.116,§ 26.117,§ 26.118,§ 26.119,§ 26.120,§ 26.121,§ 26.122,§ 26.123,§ 26.124,§ 26.201,§ 26.202,§ 26.203,§ 26.301,§ 26.302,§ 26.303,§ 26.304,§ 26.305,§ 26.401,§ 26.402,§ 26.403,§ 26.404,§ 26.405,§ 26.406,§ 26.1101,§ 26.1102,§§ 26.1103-26.1106,§ 26.1107,§ 26.1108,§ 26.1109,§ 26.1110,§ 26.1111,§ 26.1112,§ 26.1113,§ 26.1114,§ 26.1115,§ 26.1116,§ 26.1117,§§ 26.1118-26.1122,§ 26.1123,§ 26.1124,§ 26.1125,§ 26.1201,§ 26.1202,§ 26.1203,§ 26.1301,§ 26.1302,§ 26.1303,§ 26.1501,§ 26.1502,§ 26.1503,§ 26.1504,§ 26.1505,§ 26.1506,§ 26.1507,§ 26.1601,§ 26.1602,§ 26.1603,§ 26.1604,§ 26.1605,§ 26.1606,§ 26.1607,§ 26.1701,§ 26.1702,§ 26.1703,§ 26.1704,§ 26.1705,§ 26.1706,§ 27.1,§ 27.2,§ 27.3,§ 27.4,§ 27.5,§ 27.6,§ 27.7,§ 27.8,§ 27.9,§ 27.10,§ 27.11,§ 27.12,§ 27.13,§ 27.14,§ 27.15,§ 27.16,§ 27.17,§ 27.18,§ 27.19,§ 27.20,§ 27.21,§ 27.22,§ 27.23,§ 27.24,§ 27.25,§ 27.26,§ 27.27,§ 27.28,§ 27.29,§ 27.30,§ 27.31,§ 27.32,§ 27.33,§ 27.34,§ 27.35,§ 27.36,§ 27.37,§ 27.38,§ 27.39,§ 27.40,§ 27.41,§ 27.42,§ 27.43,§ 27.44,§ 27.45,§ 27.46,§ 27.47,§ 27.48,§ 29.1,§ 29.2,§ 29.3,§ 29.4,§ 29.5,§ 29.6,§ 29.7,§ 29.8,§ 29.9,§ 29.10,§ 29.11,§ 29.12,§ 29.13
Checking file at path: ./CFR-2019/title-20/CFR-2019-title20-vol1.xml
§ 30.300
contains mismatched sections § 30.301,§ 30.301,§ 30.302,§ 30.303,§ 30.305,§ 30.305,§ 30.306,§ 30.306,§ 30.307,§ 30.307,§ 30.310,§ 30.310,§ 30.311,§ 30.312,§ 30.313,§ 30.313,§ 30.314,§ 30.314,§ 30.315,§ 30.315,§ 30.316,§ 30.317,§ 30.318,§ 30.318,§ 30.319,§ 30.319,§ 30.320,§ 30.320,§ 30.400,§ 30.400,§ 30.401,§ 30.402,§ 30.403,§ 30.403,§ 30.404,§ 30.405,§ 30.405,§ 30.406,§ 30.410,§ 30.410,§ 30.411,§ 30.411,§ 30.412,§ 30.415,§ 30.416,§ 30.416,§ 30.417,§ 30.420,§ 30.421,§ 30.422,§ 30.500,§ 30.500,§ 30.501,§ 30.501,§ 30.502,§ 30.502,§ 30.505,§ 30.506,§ 30.507,§ 30.508,§ 30.509,§ 30.509,§ 30.510,§ 30.511,§ 30.512,§ 30.513,§ 30.514,§ 30.515,§ 30.516,§ 30.517,§ 30.518,§ 30.519,§ 30.520,§ 30.600,§ 30.600,§ 30.601,§ 30.601,§ 30.602,§ 30.603,§ 30.603,§ 30.605,§ 30.606,§ 30.607,§ 30.608,§ 30.609,§ 30.610,§ 30.611,§ 30.615,§ 30.616,§ 30.617,§ 30.617,§ 30.618,§ 30.618,§ 30.619,§ 30.620,§ 30.625,§ 30.626,§ 30.627,§ 30.700,§ 30.700,§ 30.701,§ 30.701,§ 30.702,§ 30.702,§ 30.703,§ 30.705,§ 30.705,§ 30.706,§ 30.706,§ 30.707,§ 30.707,§ 30.708,§ 30.709,§ 30.709,§ 30.710,§ 30.710,§ 30.711,§ 30.711,§ 30.712,§ 30.712,§ 30.713,§ 30.713,§ 30.715,§ 30.715,§ 30.716,§ 30.716,§ 30.717,§ 30.717,§ 30.718,§ 30.718,§ 30.719,§ 30.719,§ 30.720,§ 30.720,§ 30.721,§ 30.721,§ 30.722,§ 30.723,§ 30.723,§ 30.724,§ 30.724,§ 30.725,§ 30.725,§ 30.726,§ 30.726,§ 30.800,§ 30.800,§ 30.801,§ 30.801,§ 30.805,§ 30.805,§ 30.806,§ 30.806,§ 30.807,§ 30.810,§ 30.810,§ 30.811,§ 30.811,§ 30.812,§ 30.815,§ 30.900,§ 30.901,§ 30.901,§ 30.902,§ 30.902,§ 30.905,§ 30.906,§ 30.907,§ 30.908,§ 30.908,§ 30.910,§ 30.911,§ 30.912
Checking file at path: ./CFR-2019/title-21/CFR-2019-title21-vol4.xml
§ 202.1
contains mismatched sections § 203.1,§ 203.2,§ 203.3,§ 203.10,§ 203.11,§ 203.12,§ 203.20,§ 203.22,§ 203.23,§ 203.30,§ 203.31,§ 203.32,§ 203.33,§ 203.34,§ 203.35,§ 203.36,§ 203.37,§ 203.38,§ 203.39,§ 203.50,§ 203.60,§ 203.70,§ 205.1,§ 205.2,§ 205.3,§ 205.4,§ 205.5,§ 205.6,§ 205.7,§ 205.8,§ 205.50,§ 206.1,§ 206.3,§ 206.7,§ 206.10,§ 207.1,§ 207.3,§ 207.5,§ 207.9,§ 207.13,§ 207.17,§ 207.21,§ 207.25,§ 207.29,§ 207.33,§ 207.35,§ 207.37,§ 207.41,§ 207.45,§ 207.49,§ 207.53,§ 207.54,§ 207.55,§ 207.57,§ 207.61,§ 207.65,§ 207.69,§ 207.77,§ 207.81,§ 208.1,§ 208.3,§ 208.20,§ 208.24,§ 208.26,§ 209.1,§ 209.2,§ 209.10,§ 209.11,§ 210.1,§ 210.2,§ 210.3,§ 211.1,§ 211.3,§ 211.22,§ 211.25,§ 211.28,§ 211.34,§ 211.42,§ 211.44,§ 211.46,§ 211.48,§ 211.50,§ 211.52,§ 211.56,§ 211.58,§ 211.63,§ 211.65,§ 211.67,§ 211.68,§ 211.72,§ 211.80,§ 211.82,§ 211.84,§ 211.86,§ 211.87,§ 211.89,§ 211.94,§ 211.100,§ 211.101,§ 211.103,§ 211.105,§ 211.110,§ 211.111,§ 211.113,§ 211.115,§ 211.122,§ 211.125,§ 211.130,§ 211.132,§ 211.134,§ 211.137,§ 211.142,§ 211.150,§ 211.160,§ 211.165,§ 211.166,§ 211.167,§ 211.170,§ 211.173,§ 211.176,§ 211.180,§ 211.182,§ 211.184,§ 211.186,§ 211.188,§ 211.192,§ 211.194,§ 211.196,§ 211.198,§ 211.204,§ 211.208,§ 212.1,§ 212.2,§ 212.5,§ 212.10,§ 212.20,§ 212.30,§ 212.40,§ 212.50,§ 212.60,§ 212.61,§ 212.70,§ 212.71,§ 212.80,§ 212.90,§ 212.100,§ 212.110,§ 216.23,§ 216.24,§ 225.1,§ 225.10,§ 225.20,§ 225.30,§ 225.35,§ 225.42,§ 225.58,§ 225.65,§ 225.80,§ 225.102,§ 225.110,§ 225.115,§ 225.120,§ 225.130,§ 225.135,§ 225.142,§ 225.158,§ 225.165,§ 225.180,§ 225.202,§ 226.1,§ 226.10,§ 226.20,§ 226.30,§ 226.40,§ 226.42,§ 226.58,§ 226.80,§ 226.102,§ 226.110,§ 226.115,§ 250.11,§ 250.12,§ 250.100,§ 250.101,§ 250.102,§§ 250.103-250.104,§ 250.105,§§ 250.106-250.107,§ 250.108,§ 250.201,§ 250.250,§ 290.1,§ 290.2,§ 290.5,§ 290.6,§ 290.10,§ 299.3,§ 299.4,§ 299.5
Checking file at path: ./CFR-2019/title-10/CFR-2019-title10-vol4.xml
§ 1045.53
contains mismatched sections § 1045.5,§ 1045.10,§ 1045.15,§ 1045.20,§ 1045.25,§ 1045.30,§ 1045.35,§ 1045.40,§ 1045.45,§ 1045.50,§ 1045.55,§ 1045.60,§ 1045.65,§ 1045.70,§ 1045.75,§ 1045.80,§ 1045.85,§ 1045.90,§ 1045.95,§ 1045.100,§ 1045.105,§ 1045.110,§ 1045.115,§ 1045.120,§ 1045.125,§ 1045.130,§ 1045.135,§ 1045.140,§ 1045.145,§ 1045.150,§ 1045.155,§ 1045.160,§ 1045.165,§ 1045.170,§ 1045.175,§ 1045.180,§ 1045.185,§ 1045.190,§ 1045.195,§ 1045.200,§ 1045.205,§ 1045.210,§ 1045.215,§ 1045.220,§ 1045.225,§ 1046.1,§ 1046.2,§ 1046.3,§ 1046.4,§ 1046.5,§ 1046.11,§ 1046.12,§ 1046.13,§ 1046.14,§ 1046.15,§ 1046.16,§ 1046.17,§ 1046.18,§ 1046.19,§ 1046.20,§ 1047.1,§ 1047.2,§ 1047.3,§ 1047.4,§ 1047.5,§ 1047.6,§ 1047.7,§ 1048.1,§ 1048.2,§ 1048.3,§ 1048.4,§ 1048.5,§ 1048.6,§ 1048.7,§ 1049.1,§ 1049.2,§ 1049.3,§ 1049.4,§ 1049.5,§ 1049.6,§ 1049.7,§ 1049.8,§ 1049.9,§ 1049.10,§ 1050.101,§ 1050.102,§ 1050.103,§ 1050.104,§ 1050.201,§ 1050.202,§ 1050.203,§ 1050.204,§ 1050.301,§ 1050.302,§ 1050.303,§ 1050.401,§ 1060.101,§ 1060.201,§ 1060.301,§ 1060.401,§ 1060.501
Thanks! We'll take a look.
Hello! My name is Rachel Johns, I'm a product Manager at Fastcase. We have been looking through the CFR XML files and have noticed a few issues. I was hoping you could potentially help us with these?
For Title 47, 90.603-90.1338 all appear to be incorrectly nested under 60.601. Here is how it appears on Fastcase using the Bulk Data:
https://fc7.fastcase.com/outline/US/402?docUid=164798869
Also, 90.623-90.1338 are all incorrectly lumped under 90.621:
The source on the ECFR website lists all of these sections after 90.621 correctly:
https://gov.ecfr.io/cgi-bin/text-idx?SID=8bdc0140de420c937355f33e1a46d46d&mc=true&node=pt47.5.90&rgn=div5
In 90.621 in Fastcase:
Issue 2: All Images are missing
As far as we can tell, all of the images are missing on this source. Examples are below.
Title 49 Source:
Title 49 as it appears in Fastcase using Bulk Data
The Same problem occurs with math equations:
Source:
Code we used based on the Bulk Data:
<P>(g) Calculate the adhesion utilized at each axle as a function of braking ratio using the following equations:</P><MATH>
<MID>ER02FE95.014</MID>
</MATH>
Could you please let us know if these issues are possible to resolve?
Thank you!