cc @jshorland
Any other requirements for comments from BRCK?
jshorland 2015-10-27
Nice to have feature (feedback from quakemap who found comments very valuable): getting notifications when someone comments on a post you've also commented on. Similar to blog commenting notifications.
rjmackay 2016-04-05
@jshorland bumping this to the next sprint
snilsmitchell 2016-04-27
Is this now in Sprint #2 (May 2 - June 3)?
rjmackay 2016-04-29
@sebm90 its probably going to get bumped further out. Is there a solutions project waiting on that??
jshorland 2016-05-02
508 is related
jshorland 2017-08-29
Closing #508 in favor of this and adding comment here:
Copying V2 feature request 595: Switching "on" comments for logged in users
I don't see a way to limit commenting to logged in users only - only the on/off switch in the site settings. Would be great to add this for both spam protection and accountability. Best would be to assign it as a user role capability that can be selected for assorted user levels.
Nice as an option, but don't want to limit comments to logged-in users on every Ushahidi deployment. Ushahidi would be a rather limited crowd-sourcing tool if the crowd can't comment. BTW, Akismet has done a great job of eliminating spam for us.
I would also like to do user testing on this when it goes out. I suspect we should make this 'optional' via admin settings to avoid 'trolling' if that isn't already a specification.
rowasc 2019-07-10
Agree on making it optional.
I'll let you know when this lands in a test environment and you can run user tests there?
Erioldoesdesign 2019-07-10
That'd be awesome! Usertesting in the test environment is great cause we often gather other insights about other features 🙌
rowasc 2019-09-03
Ok. :( Sadly the PR still needs work (probably because it's also super stale 😬 ) . It's not running, and the migrations do not run, so we will
close the PR so it's not there just sitting in our queue without doing anything.
linear[bot]
commented
4 months ago
Looks like members of the public can't add updates/comments to published posts. I think this would be a valuable feature. (via Nekesa Were)
Aha! Link: https://ushahiditeam.aha.io/features/PROD-747
View original issue in GitHub
rjmackay 2015-09-02
cc @jshorland Any other requirements for comments from BRCK?
jshorland 2015-10-27
Nice to have feature (feedback from quakemap who found comments very valuable): getting notifications when someone comments on a post you've also commented on. Similar to blog commenting notifications.
rjmackay 2016-04-05
@jshorland bumping this to the next sprint
snilsmitchell 2016-04-27
Is this now in Sprint #2 (May 2 - June 3)?
rjmackay 2016-04-29
@sebm90 its probably going to get bumped further out. Is there a solutions project waiting on that??
jshorland 2016-05-02
508 is related
jshorland 2017-08-29
Closing #508 in favor of this and adding comment here:
Copying V2 feature request 595: Switching "on" comments for logged in users
I don't see a way to limit commenting to logged in users only - only the on/off switch in the site settings. Would be great to add this for both spam protection and accountability. Best would be to assign it as a user role capability that can be selected for assorted user levels.
Nice as an option, but don't want to limit comments to logged-in users on every Ushahidi deployment. Ushahidi would be a rather limited crowd-sourcing tool if the crowd can't comment. BTW, Akismet has done a great job of eliminating spam for us.
jshorland 2017-08-29
This might align nicely with future of "tasks"
rowasc 2019-06-07
https://github.com/ushahidi/platform-client/pull/1229 https://github.com/ushahidi/platform/pull/3207 Noting this 2 PRs from Will that seem to be addressing some of the "comments" functionality, will need to review and test/demo to see where we are exactly on this
Erioldoesdesign 2019-07-10
I would also like to do user testing on this when it goes out. I suspect we should make this 'optional' via admin settings to avoid 'trolling' if that isn't already a specification.
rowasc 2019-07-10
Agree on making it optional. I'll let you know when this lands in a test environment and you can run user tests there?
Erioldoesdesign 2019-07-10
That'd be awesome! Usertesting in the test environment is great cause we often gather other insights about other features 🙌
rowasc 2019-09-03
Ok. :( Sadly the PR still needs work (probably because it's also super stale 😬 ) . It's not running, and the migrations do not run, so we will