search

ustulation / p2p

NAT Traversal techniques for p2p communication
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
132 stars 28 forks source link

Incompatible license #72

Open TheWaWaR opened 5 years ago

TheWaWaR commented 5 years ago

p2p is a nice library.

But maybe we can not use p2p as MIT/BSD-3 license?

$ cargo lichking check
warning: IANAL: This is not legal advice and is not guaranteed to be correct.
error: p2p cannot include package sha1, license BSD-3-Clause is incompatible with Any(MIT, BSD-3-Clause)
error: p2p cannot include package future-utils, license GPL-2.0-only is incompatible with Any(MIT, BSD-3-Clause)
error: p2p cannot include package tokio-shared-udp-socket, license GPL-3.0-only is incompatible with Any(MIT, BSD-3-Clause)
error: p2p cannot include package config_file_handler, license GPL-3.0-only is incompatible with Any(MIT, BSD-3-Clause)
error: p2p cannot include package fuchsia-zircon-sys, license BSD-3-Clause is incompatible with Any(MIT, BSD-3-Clause)
error: p2p cannot include package unwrap, license GPL-3.0-only is incompatible with Any(MIT, BSD-3-Clause)
error: p2p cannot include package netsim, license GPL-2.0-only is incompatible with Any(MIT, BSD-3-Clause)
error: p2p cannot include package fuchsia-zircon, license BSD-3-Clause is incompatible with Any(MIT, BSD-3-Clause)
error: p2p cannot include package net-literals-impl, license GPL-3.0-only is incompatible with Any(MIT, BSD-3-Clause)
error: p2p cannot include package future-utils, license GPL-2.0-only is incompatible with Any(MIT, BSD-3-Clause)
error: p2p cannot include package net-literals, license GPL-3.0-only is incompatible with Any(MIT, BSD-3-Clause)
error: p2p cannot include package future-utils, license GPL-2.0-only is incompatible with Any(MIT, BSD-3-Clause)
error: p2p cannot include package get_if_addrs, license GPL-3.0-only is incompatible with Any(MIT, BSD-3-Clause)
error: p2p cannot include package capabilities, license MPL-2.0 is incompatible with Any(MIT, BSD-3-Clause)
error: p2p cannot include package maidsafe_utilities, license GPL-3.0-only is incompatible with Any(MIT, BSD-3-Clause)
error: Incompatible license
povilasb commented 5 years ago

error: p2p cannot include package sha1, license BSD-3-Clause is incompatible with Any(MIT, BSD-3-Clause) - hmmm, makes me question if this report is right :/

povilasb commented 5 years ago

Also, except capabilities, license MPL-2.0 we, MaidSafe, own the other libraries, so probably could change their licensing (maybe already did). But I'm still not sure about MPL 2.0.

TheWaWaR commented 5 years ago

error: p2p cannot include package sha1, license BSD-3-Clause is incompatible with Any(MIT, BSD-3-Clause)

To my understanding, MIT is incompatible with BSD-3-Clause so you can not use a BSD-3-Clause only library in a Any(MIT, BSD-3-Clause) library.

Maybe this better be a warning, not an error.

TheWaWaR commented 5 years ago

How about this capabilities replacement with MIT/Apache-2.0 license?

folex commented 4 years ago

Hi! Is that still an issue?