uuid6 / uuid6-ietf-draft

Next Generation UUID Formats
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-peabody-dispatch-new-uuid-format/
187 stars 11 forks source link

Remove "time-based" constraint from version 8 UUID #124

Closed broofa closed 1 year ago

broofa commented 1 year ago

Change Proposal Template

I should have caught this earlier, but is there a reason version 8 UUIDs are described as being for "time-based" UUIDs specifically? I see version 8 as being the catch-all format for any type of experimental UUID, and I'm fairly certain it's going to be used as such, regardless of whether it's described as "time-based" or not.

Source (Select one.)

Change Reason (Select all that apply.)

Draft Number, Full Section, Name

draft-ietf-uuidrev-rfc4122bis-00, Section 5.8. UUID Version 8

Current Text:

The only explicitly defined bits are the Version and Variant leaving 122 bits for implementation specific time-based UUIDs. 

Proposed Text:

The only explicitly defined bits are the Version and Variant leaving 122 bits for implementation-specific UUIDs. 

Other Supporting information below:

Insert data here

kyzer-davis commented 1 year ago

Good catch, Ill slate it for Draft 01 of rfc4122biz.