uvutna / COMP5120_Project-2

0 stars 0 forks source link

Peer Review Proposal - Group E #4

Open TraMiu opened 6 months ago

TraMiu commented 6 months ago

Suggestion 1: The project is well-organized and carefully planned. However, aiming to create both a Shiny app and a 3D-printed sculpture within a short timeframe is ambitious. It's wise to focus on finishing the app first, especially the 3D visualization part. If time allows, then the artistic work on the sculpture can be completed as a bonus. Your project is dealing with very technical things, so I think it might be a great option if you can add a well-defined description in your app/dashboard. This will help everyone understand the project better.

Suggestion 2: Another potential problem is that the topic of modulation schemes and wireless communication systems may not be familiar to the average audience because they are too academic. Therefore, your team should concisely explain any jargon for the audience to avoid confusion. By understanding the terms, the audience would appreciate the significance of the visualizations more.

Suggestion 3: However, we think that if your team can manage the workload of this project, having 3D printed sculptures for visualization would be an astounding idea as you can utilize the 3D printing machines at the university.

nguyenminhtuong commented 6 months ago

Suggestion 1: Thanks Suggestion 2: Another potential problem is that the topic of modulation schemes and wireless communication systems may not be familiar to the average audience because they are too academic. Therefore, your team should concisely explain any jargon for the audience to avoid confusion. -> Ok we will do it Suggestion 3: However, we think that if your team can manage the workload of this project, having 3D printed sculptures for visualization would be an astounding idea as you can utilize the 3D printing machines at the university. Ok thanks

tienvu95 commented 6 months ago

Thank @TraMiu for the comment and a Tường for the response. This feedback is somewhat aligned with what I proposed, for this technical piece to reach wider audience, we should clearly explain all the concepts used. I think the team is already aware of that issue and I believe that having this feature will help the demo in our presentation + the final product to be more user-friendly.

Note that you don't have to reply to this comment, this is just my thought on what you can do to improve your project.