search

v2fly / domain-list-community

Community managed domain list. Generate geosite.dat for V2Ray.
https://www.v2fly.org
MIT License
4.69k stars 848 forks source link

TODO: revert #863 #1657

Closed IceCodeNew closed 8 months ago

IceCodeNew commented 1 year ago

There was a discussion about it, and we are planning to revert the PR #863
This issue is for notification and tracking the progress.

For anyone who may concern about the discussion, please refer to the following:

rootmelo92118 commented 1 year ago

I have no objection to revert the PR, after all, there is no guarantee that there are any remaining problems. But at the same time, I don't think the original PR is completely worthless. I have saved domains that will be removed. I will check these domain names again, and the domain names after the check will be re-added to category-porn.

rootmelo92118 commented 1 year ago

Wait a minute. I used OpenDNS to resolve which domains are belonging to pornographic websites. (also remove the domain which is expired). I got 908 domains, and the total domains have 994. It means most of the domain will be re-added. Are you sure you want to revert it? outputdomain.txt

IceCodeNew commented 1 year ago

Wait a minute. I used OpenDNS to resolve which domains are belonging to pornographic websites. (also remove the domain which is expired). I got 908 domains, and the total domains have 994. It means most of the domain will be re-added. Are you sure you want to revert it? outputdomain.txt

Yes, I am going to revert that PR, no matter what. The nature of the problem is copying the contents of a third-party source, which brings us to the problem of copyleft, sync & quality. You may spot the miscategorized domains based on OpenDNS's labeling or something, but even if it is enough for salvaging the qualified parts, there are still problems that we can not solve. After all, salvaging pornographic sited from a list of domains that are blocked in Korea is not a good idea.

Loyalsoldier commented 10 months ago

Any progress?