search

valueflows / agent

agent has moved to https://lab.allmende.io/valueflows/agent
10 stars 4 forks source link

Remove member relationship for now #69

Closed fosterlynn closed 8 years ago

fosterlynn commented 8 years ago

The member relationship as modeled here has no relationship to the vf:relationship / vf:Relationship. Got to figure out how to model this correctly, but I'm pretty sure this isn't right.

@elf-pavlik I'd like to discuss with you when you are back.

elf-pavlik commented 8 years ago

How about just referencing foaf:member and/or org:memberOf + org:hasMember. IMO we can't expect everyone to use qualified/n-ary relationship approach for simple group membership and need to make sure that we also support direct (binary) version which does NOT make use of vf:Relationship and vf:relationship.

Relevant discussion in AS2.0 tracker https://github.com/w3c/activitystreams/issues/289

fosterlynn commented 8 years ago

IMO we can't expect everyone to use qualified/n-ary relationship approach for simple group membership and need to make sure that we also support direct (binary) version which does NOT make use of vf:Relationship and vf:relationship.

OK. Maybe we should make 2 separate models, and say, here's the two ways this can work. (Not a priority though I think?)