GeometryUnion behaves more like an Exclude than a Union

vane / degrafa

Automatically exported from code.google.com/p/degrafa

0 stars 0 forks source link

What steps will reproduce the problem?
1. Create a Geometry Union using two overlapping shapes:

<geometry:GeometryUnion>
                    <geometry:fill>
                        <degrafa:SolidFill color="#000000" />
                    </geometry:fill>
                    <geometry:geometry>
                        <degrafa:Circle radius="100">
                            <degrafa:fill>
                                <degrafa:SolidFill color="#00ff00" />
                            </degrafa:fill>
                        </degrafa:Circle>
                        <degrafa:Circle centerX="70" radius="150">
                            <degrafa:fill>
                                <degrafa:SolidFill color="#0000ff" />
                            </degrafa:fill>
                        </degrafa:Circle>
                    </geometry:geometry>
                </geometry:GeometryUnion>

What is the expected output? What do you see instead?
The expected output is two black overlapping circles. I've attached an
image of the result, as well as the expected result (sorry for my lousy
illustrator drawing skills). It seems that instead of the expected behavior
that both the circle shapes are drawn with the same fill, the overlapping
area no longer is drawn, much like a exclude in illustrator.

What version of the product are you using? On what operating system?
Beta 3.2, on both Mac OSX and Windows Vista

Please provide any additional information below.

Original issue reported on code.google.com by sarah.pl...@gmail.com on 17 May 2010 at 10:43

Attachments:

Unfortunately we haven't implemented 'real' geometric operations yet in degrafa. GeometryUnion is a little misleading as a class name in that sense. It is simply a class that draws its children without resetting paint styles between - basically it issues the drawing commands for all the children as a single sequence with the fill and stroke styles that it defines on the GeometryUnion parent. The fill exclusion zone you see from the overlapping circles is as a result of the flash drawing api's default fill-rule (called 'even-odd') which basically fills parts of a shape based on alternating areas of enclosed spaces defined by enclosed sub-paths or self-intersections. We do have plans to add geometric operations in the future, this has been our intention all along...however if I were to suggest a timeframe I would say Q3-4 earliest.

vane / degrafa

GeometryUnion behaves more like an Exclude than a Union #89