search

varvet / pundit

Minimal authorization through OO design and pure Ruby classes
MIT License
8.24k stars 627 forks source link

New release? #656

Closed iMacTia closed 3 years ago

iMacTia commented 4 years ago

Latest release was August 2019, and since then there have been lots of commits in master. Would the team consider releasing a new version with all the new fixes/features?

rlue commented 4 years ago

Wait up! There are some commits in master that extend the API in a way that I and at least one other person don't think are ideal—if a new release is coming, is there any chance we could get some feedback on #654 / #655 first? :pray:

iMacTia commented 4 years ago

I understand the pending issues but the last release is almost 1 year old now and there hasn't been any movement on those issues since May/June 😕...

rlue commented 4 years ago

If it helps, you can just specify the commit you need in your Gemfile:

gem 'pundit', git: 'https://github.com/varvet/pundit.git', ref: '504b86a'
iMacTia commented 4 years ago

Of course! I did it back in May, but I hope you'll agree that's not a long-term solution 😅 I was hoping to see a proper release in a few weeks, definitely not expecting months!

vpereira commented 3 years ago

I'm looking forward for a new release, specially because of https://github.com/varvet/pundit/blob/master/lib/pundit.rb#L24-L41. Any plans for 2020?

mabras commented 3 years ago

If anyone search for alternative simillar to Pundit: https://actionpolicy.evilmartians.io/

gat-bryszard commented 3 years ago

Any news in here? It doesn't look good with the last meaningful commit 17 months ago.

joshbuker commented 3 years ago

@kindell @olleolleolle @dgmstuart

What are the long term plans for Pundit? I was planning on using Pundit as the primary example of Authorization combined with Sorcery as the Authentication, but it is a bit concerning if the release cadence is looking unhealthy.

Burgestrand commented 3 years ago

Hi! I can't speak for the other maintainers, but I can give you some information from Varvet. This is all preliminary as we're still figuring things out at Varvet, and I can't run this post by @kindell or @dgmstuart since they're both (me too, really) on ~4-week swedish vacation and are off-grid right now. Please keep some spare oversight in hand while reading this.

That said, I just noticed this issue and I figured a vague reply is better than none.

The short answer is that we at Varvet have no intention of abandoning Pundit. It's likely that we'll continue spending resources on Pundit, and if that turns out to not be an alternative we are probably looking at finding a new maintainer.

The long answer is that recently (~mars 2020) Varvet as a company underwent a significant restart. We're a much smaller shop now, so @dgmstuart and I started doing inventory of our OSS projects and trying to figure out what to do with all of them. Most of the time until now has been spent on building up and getting to know the new company we just rebooted, and our public communications suffered. I'm sorry.

I can't do much right at this moment, but I can promise I'll take a closer look together with @dgmstuart late august when we're both back from vacation and are on-grid again.

Burgestrand commented 3 years ago

Wait up! There are some commits in master that extend the API in a way that I and at least one other person don't think are ideal—if a new release is coming, is there any chance we could get some feedback on #654 / #655 first? 🙏

Agreed. That said, it shouldn't keep us from making a new release. We'll revert the change in master in order to make a new release soon (tm).

As for error reasons/messages that discussion can move to https://github.com/varvet/pundit/issues/654 for now.

Burgestrand commented 3 years ago

Hi again!

The new release is out and available on Rubygems.