vexim / vexim2

Virtual Exim 2
Other
70 stars 47 forks source link

Acl policyd weight #153

Open runout-at opened 8 years ago

runout-at commented 8 years ago

example config for policyd-weight instead of using DNSBL

Udera commented 8 years ago

You can add some smtp syntax checking in the acl-part (and SPF, ...). Spamassassin is as well included which also can add checks against block-lists. What is the actual benefit of policyd_weight which can't be handled in exim directly?

runout-at commented 8 years ago

I like policyd_weight because i had some troubles with DNSBLs and false positives in the past and polycd_weight does something more complex than just use a singl DNSBL result for blocking a sender. Its very easy to use with exim additionally to spamassassin.

I'd include the config in vexim as an example. People can decide if they like to enable ist.

Vexim has a different purpose, but there are already some other example configs which do not really relay to virtual users and in that way it makes sense to put some more examples to the repository. I added this as an alternative to using DNSBLs directly because of the discussion #127

Udera commented 8 years ago

policyd was written for postfix which has a more modular design than exim. Many rules (syntax checking during smtp) can directly be implemented in exim. I'm currently using only very conservative DNSBLs and I integrate others into spamassassin. There is perhaps a way, to combine several DNSBLs in exim that mail are only rejected if the host is listed in more than one DNSBL.

runout-at commented 8 years ago

It's just an example how to use it if somebody wants it. It would be very nice if someone takes the time and makes a real exim implementation of the policyd_weight ruleset

Udera commented 8 years ago

Let's focus on the v2.3-release and then try to establish some policyd-like behavior.