Windows Ballooning Question (version support)

madmax01 commented 2 months ago

this is more an question.

we spotted that any non-linux vm does a full allocation of ram an not freeing up......equal what libvirt.. 8.0/8.6/9.0 or 6.0/7.2 qemu.

now question is - which virtio driver package supports the Ballooning on windows? as something is not right seems

madmax01 commented 2 months ago

i looked and we have 0.1.240 in use

madmax01 commented 2 months ago

1.5/8GB but assigned is 8GB and boots up with 8GB........... not reclaming to kvm

madmax01 commented 2 months ago

virsh qemu-monitor-command --hmp Win10 'balloon 1500' with this ballooning works.......but not auto-balloon

is that auto-ballooning planned for virtio?

madmax01 commented 2 months ago

seems that command was just a lucky strike.... triied again and on others > not reclaiming.... the balloon info shows already at max size......is the balloon service not correct installed on windows ?

ybendito commented 2 months ago

@madmax01 This should work assuming you have balloon driver installed on the guest. With build 240 and later and earlier. Look in device manager under "system devices" -> "virtio balloon driver". The system will start with 8G and as soon as the driver is up it starts giving the memory to qemu.

madmax01 commented 1 month ago

i defo installed the whole exe package and didn't unchecked anything.. will check device manager... so far i know i have different versions of virtio on windows...but non of them reclaming to qemu...... 7.2 or 6.0 qemu.......

may you know which libvirt/qemu confirmed should work minimum? freebsd also have same issue......but linux seems don't have that issue > reclaims unused mem

madmax01 commented 1 month ago

dominfo: Max memory: 8388608 KiB Used memory: 8388608 KiB

domstat balloon.current=8388608 balloon.maximum=8388608 balloon.last-update=1714816720 balloon.rss=2525324

dommemstat

actual 8388608 last_update 1714816720 rss 2526092

i checked on other stack (above seems working....odd) something with libvirt/qemu which i didn't spotted before

7.2 qemu + 9.0 libvirt = windows not reclaming unused mem (ppa on ubuntu) 6.2 qemu + 8.0 libvirt = windows reclaming unused mem (default)

we upgraded libvirt > because of strange bugs of default ones

may from virtio point this is known case? you think its an libvirt or qemu case

madmax01 commented 1 month ago

may there are known ppa's for 9.6 libvirt and qemu 8.0? not finding it atm ;(

ybendito commented 1 month ago

Just did a smoke test with Fedora 36, libvirt-8.1.0-2.fc36, qemu qemu-6.2.0-17.fc36, 8GB/7GB, driver 228, works, hmp 'info balloon' returns 7G after boot

madmax01 commented 1 month ago

well when i check info balloon then it shows same amoutn which is assigned.. but when checking rss > its still assigned mem and not freed ha.....very strange.......but on linux its like no issue........just spotted windows + freebsd (well seems not an virtio issue) ;( something between ubuntu 22.04 libvirt/qemu....buest guess is 24.04 lts

madmax01 commented 1 month ago

bit fun - as seems linux acting not like that

when checking linux dom.. its matching up Maxmem to balloon info.......looking on windows its same... but rss is same assigned size not reclaiming........

in that case when i reduce balloning instead of full to say 2048.....then windows starts to reclaim.......very confusing

madmax01 commented 1 month ago

Max memory: 20971520 KiB Used memory: 20971520 KiB

on linux +windows

balloon info tells balloon: actual=20480

linux reclaims > windows not

when i do --hmp xxx "balloon 1" on windows vm then it starts working and Used memory goes down

i'am not very sure where this issue is....

madmax01 commented 1 month ago

virsh setmem --size 2560 --live xxx

that triggers the ballooning and hmp goes down....then i can see the real % usage but mem side mem usage goes up because of comitted ram.....

that behavior is strange.......on linux its auto working

i tested this now on new ubuntu 24.04 lts too > exact same behavior (windows vm with virtio)

virsh qemu-monitor-command --hmp test "info balloon" balloon: actual=8192

virsh dommemstat test actual 8388608 last_update 1715191125 rss 8448364

virsh dominfo maxtest01 Id: 10 Name: test UUID: cd23c4ef-b1da-4a1f-b2fc-d203709f8f1f OS Type: hvm State: running CPU(s): 4 CPU time: 38.0s Max memory: 8388608 KiB Used memory: 8388608 KiB Persistent: yes Autostart: disable Managed save: no Security model: none Security DOI: 0

now i need to do either virsh setmem --size 8192 --live test or virsh qemu-monitor-command --hmp test "balloon 1"

balloon service running virt-io installed (0.1.240)

then windows have more mem usage but host side seems reclaim (when triggering)

i don't understand this behavior.

i see an general problem with windows on kvm (which seems not appear on vmware)

with default ballooning and kvm > vm boots nice - low mem usage - but host tells 100% allocated and 100% in use.. where on guest side just 1GB in use
when doing the balloon trigger above > most mem goes to guest and the mem usage increase as most is committed gb then. usage on host side tells real guest usage

i'am blank on that one.. nobody have that issue?

virtio-win / kvm-guest-drivers-windows