Open vitormhenrique opened 4 years ago
I would love to have one, especially if there's a service that can ship an assembled one to Europe.
My only reservation is the fan. 30mm fans tend to be noisy. It might be better to use the space for additional electronics, and mount 40mm PWN controlled Noctua (or equivalent) on the side of the housing.
However, I would get the board anyway, I would just not mount the fan. If you can find that 25kHz PWM driver which can drive at least 2 outputs, then I'm all set :-)
Heh, look no further: https://datasheets.maximintegrated.com/en/ds/MAX31790.pdf
Count me in for one board.
Nice work!! Are you planning to share the design sources?
I started something similar some time ago, but i prefer your idea to use a PCA9635 PWM Controller over my solution to use power FETs to control fans and leds.
I'd like to share my thoughts about the shield I designed. Maybe you could use some of it for the 'official' hardware board.
How do you connect your 3d printer to the raspberry? Does the connection go thorugh the Hat? On my board, i added a JST connector to the Hat and built an adapter board to interface with my prusa i3 (https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:3953845).
I also added a JST connector to attach an I2C bus to the raspberry, which can interface with several MCP9808 temperature sensors digitally. I like the idea that i can place multiple sensors in the enclosure and just having a bus 3 wires to connect them. For the MC9808, i also built a small PC which has low thermal masses and two connectors to daisy-chain multiple sensors. Unfortunately, I did not have the time yet to see if it works with the octoprint-enclosure plugin.
I also placed a 12V to 5V DC/DC converter to my board in order to power the raspi from the 12V, which i planned to use for other actors like fans or LED's. Looking at your design, I think i might have overdone the job here :-), since fans and leds don't neccesarily require 12V.
I placed two LED, one to 12V, one to 5V just to see if the voltages are present - i love LEDs to see whats going in, but thats just personal taste :)
Please let me know if I can assist you in any way with the design of the hardware.
I'd be in for a board - i've been thinking to go enclosed on my Printer
I'd be in for two boards
I'd also be in for a board (or could you share some design files preliminary?). I was actually searching quite a while for shields which do exactly what you describe here. I stopped searching a week ago and just stumbled over this today. I wonder why I did not find this thread earlier
I could also offer design support in Altium or Eagle
Three things I had on my list for a potential design:
EDIT: oh, one more thing: Might be worth to place some vias inside the solder pads for the fan. It is much more robust than just a solder pad with wires soldered onto.
EDIT2: I also have oscilloscopes and logic analyzer (Analog Discovery 2) at home and highly professional solder equipment available at work.
I very much agree with external 40mm fan (and save space on the board). The processor on 4B doesn't get hotter than 60º with no fan anyway. This is the enclosure that I have designed for mine, and which I can adapt to fit the board and possibly other components: https://www.prusaprinters.org/prints/41225-octoprint-box-raspberry-pi-4b-waveshare-43-dsi
I still think that it shouldn't be a hat, because separate board allows for better cooling and positioning inside an enclosure, but it seems it is just me :-).
@vitormhenrique - I have bought an oscilloscope, so I can eventually help to debug things
Cool idea, if there is enough space, I'd use JST-XH through-hole connectors (like the BTT SKR 1.4 and many other boards), because they are way more common and pretty robust. Unfortunately I won't need one in the near future, I made a few adapter boards when required from components I already had, so some of the MOSFETs may be Overkill to switch some LEDs, but they all work fine so far. Here a list of what I built, maybe you can use some ideas:
I have a few other small boards, but they are not directly connected to the Pi, so I'll omit them here. If the printer has a fixed enclosure anyways, my modular approach works quite well and is easily expandable. For beginners, a plug and play shield would still be a great option though.
I d be in for one board also (in Europe/France). Today I am using pi3b+ without fan. I ve crimping tool and prefer your flexible solution with JST connectors. Impressive job ! :-)
I'd also be interested in the board (I'm based in Europe as well).
I would be interested in a board and am in the U.S. Could one of the existing PI HATs like the Automation HAT be used with this plugin?
Also interested in 1 board. Europe based (Croatia). Thank you for all the good work regarding enclosure control.
I would also be interested in a board, I'm in the EU!
hey @vitormhenrique,
i just build my enclosure with 4 fans (2 for the electric bay) and two for the printer. I used the adafruit EMC2101 boards but would really like to test your board to save space.
It is a slick design, but unfortunately I'm already set with modular circuitry including dallas sensors, fets, isolated relays, ssr, and constant current high power led drivers... even a pro micro with vfd in there just for the enclosure pid control (with all the details and bell/whistles, my printer will remain the rats nest it is with or without a pi hat lol). OTOH, if I was building another rig from scratch your board has some key features that would be compelling to for a design around. I really like the hardware PWM, and level shifted io... and again you did an A+ job on the layout. I'm with haplm regarding the fan though... seems a bit on the bloated side for what this is, but that's just my opinion. Being the type who would integrate this in a larger box containing many other wirey circuitry and centralized cooling, my opinion probably does not apply to what it "should" be used for. ;)
You have these available? I am interested.
Really nice, I did something similar for my Neopixel ring but only for them.
What is the status? Can we get this Octoshield manufactured from you?
count me in, another one for europe !!
Don't think this plugin is being maintained anymore. I doubt the board will ever come to light.
Hello Everyone,
I started to work on the new version of the plugin and for that I'm creating an raspberry pi hat with some features to make it easy to deploy and maintain this plugin.
This will allow me test new stuff a little bit more easily and will probably use those shields on my enclosure...
It's basically a raspberry pi shield with the following features:
All connectors will have JST-SH cables (other than servos and jumpers of course)
I'm interested to see if, and how many people would be interested on getting this board, so I can estimate a small batch and get it done....
Already had 5 ordered and manual soldered one to start testing and developing...