vlachoudis / bCNC

GRBL CNC command sender, autoleveler and g-code editor
GNU General Public License v2.0
1.54k stars 528 forks source link

Involute gear, internal gear #1832

Open MARIOBASZ opened 1 year ago

MARIOBASZ commented 1 year ago

Great job. But you have to correct the shape in the internal gear: what points to the center must point to the outside, what points to the outside must point to the center (it looks like a very nice balloon for children anyway).

MARIOBASZ commented 1 year ago

44FB2892-4AF0-4C24-A962-16BCEF4B749F

MARIOBASZ commented 1 year ago

It should be more like this. Adding gear rack will be very useful. For my personal use, I had modified gear for internal gear and for rack. Mediocre result, very enthusiastic about your version. Hugs.

MARIOBASZ commented 1 year ago

A4668085-FACE-41D0-A126-215E8FCE5675

MARIOBASZ commented 1 year ago

D0F9F233-186B-41A9-946A-C571A332A01C

LittlePierre commented 1 year ago

"It should be more like this. Adding gear rack will be very useful. For my personal use, I had modified gear for internal gear and for rack. Mediocre result, very enthusiastic about your version. Hugs."

Sorry @MARIOBASZ but I think that the profile you describe is wrong.

The profile generated by the plugin is good. You just have to add a circle around the internal gear to get the rack, depending your application.

Pierre

image image

LittlePierre commented 1 year ago

you have to correct the shape in the internal gear: what points to the center must point to the outside, what points to the outside must point to the center

Noooooo ! :-)

here is how it works :

image

LittlePierre commented 1 year ago

In red is the profile generated by involutegear plugin. You can see that it matches the theoretical gear. Within the plugin you can

image

MARIOBASZ commented 1 year ago

It may be that I am wrong. My concern is the following: the tooth has a trapezoidal shape, and a rounding / recess in the head of both teeth to allow the rotation of the gears. It would seem that the recess is being fulfilled at the base, instead of at the head. It may be me who is wrong. However, it would seem that they have done it that way in this image. This allows them to roll at the point of contact image

LittlePierre commented 1 year ago

There are only two profiles for gear teeth :

Believe a man who has spent 30 years of his carrier in french capital of watchmaking industry, near Switzerland.

LittlePierre commented 1 year ago

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Involute_gear

LittlePierre commented 1 year ago

You can play with addendum, dedendum, shift coeffs to change the shape of the tooth, but be sure you understand what you're doing. Otherwise use default parameters which are the normalized ones.

MARIOBASZ commented 1 year ago

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Involute_gear

Yes. Involuta gear with standard parámeters. Yes, I am referring to involute gears. In the wikipedia animation it shows what I am referring to meshing, pointing the head of the tooth towards the center of the opposite gear. It is very common for me to be wrong. Visually, though, I don't know if your inner gear design allows your partner to roll. Thank you for the complement, your explanations and your answers! Hug.

LittlePierre commented 1 year ago

I don't know if your inner gear design allows your partner to roll.

Yes it does. Sorry to say so Mario, and I say it with respect, but you are trying to reinvent square wheel.

Pierre

MARIOBASZ commented 1 year ago

good Pierre. I have seen images with both ways: the silhouette of the tooth pointing towards the center, like the image I showed, (the way of meshing is comparable to that of two external gears) and the silhouette of the tooth pointing outwards. You must be right. Hug.