[RFC]: Merge input processor and input mapper for multi-modal models

Motivation

Background

To provide more control over the model inputs, we currently define two methods for multi-modal models in vLLM:

The input processor is called inside LLMEngine to extend the prompt with placeholder tokens which are reserved for vLLM features such as KV cache and chunked prefill.
The input mapper is called inside ModelRunner to transform multi-modal inputs (e.g. PIL images) into tensor inputs, usually via the modality-specific processor (e.g. AutoImageProcessor) from HuggingFace.

Issues with the current design

The input processor accepts the output of HF AutoTokenizer, a list of token IDs, instead of the text prompt. Since HF AutoProcessor doesn’t accept token IDs, we have to write custom code to edit the list of token IDs based on the multi-modal inputs. For some models (such as Phi-3-vision), this means re-implementing code from their HF AutoProcessor, complicating the process of porting the model to vLLM.
The input mapper, being inside ModelRunner, lies on the critical path of vLLM’s model execution. Even when the input mapper is fast, the tail TTFT and TPOT suffers because of this. As the input mapper takes up more time, our overall throughput decreases proportionally which can be avoided if we move it outside of the critical path. Nevertheless, we can do little if the AutoProcessor inside input mapper is very slow, like in #9238. Hope that huggingface/transformers#33810 can help with that!
This abstraction results in redundant processing for models (such as Qwen2-VL and Molmo) with HF AutoProcessor that already performs most of the work for calculating the number of placeholder tokens.

Proposed Change

Unified multi-modal processor

We plan to merge our input processor and input mapper into a unified multi-modal processor and call it inside the LLMEngine (and thus benefit from #8779), taking the role of the existing tokenizer. After this change, each input type will be processed as follows:

Text-only prompt: Pass to vLLM tokenizer (wraps HF AutoTokenizer) [Unchanged]
List of token IDs: Skip vLLM tokenizer [Unchanged]
Text prompt with multi-modal input: Pass to vLLM multi-modal processor (wraps HF AutoProcessor) [NEW]
~List of token IDs with multi-modal input:~ [DEPRECATED, see below]

This multi-modal processor will first call HF AutoProcessor, and then modify the processed token IDs by inserting placeholder tokens. (These processed token IDs are not to be confused with the deprecated “list of token IDs with multi-modal input", in which “list of token IDs" represents the tokenized text before processing with multi-modal input.) The number of placeholder tokens to assign can be determined by the existing feature size calculations for each model.

Deprecate token IDs with multi-modal input

To be compatible with OpenAI’s (legacy) Completions API, we currently support passing token IDs directly to both LLM class and OpenAI-compatible server. However, Completions API doesn’t support multi-modal inputs, so we will deprecate passing token IDs alongside multi-modal inputs to simplify model implementation (see Issue 1 above). Please tell us if you have a use case for this and don’t want to see it removed!

Feedback Period

Feel free to comment as the effort progresses!

Timeline

[x] #10040
[ ] #10044
[ ] [2/N] Convert LLaVA-1.5, Phi-3-Vision, Qwen2-VL and Ultravox to multi-modal processor as POC and add tests
[ ] [3/N] Deprecate the old code for input processor/mapper so external developers have time to convert
[ ] [4/N] Convert the rest of the built-in vLLM models to multi-modal processor
[ ] [5/N] Remove the old code for input processor/mapper

The majority of our code will be called inside the existing InputPreprocessor which is separated from the vLLM engine, making it easy to integrate with #8779.

CC List

@ywang96 @Isotr0py @WoosukKwon @robertgshaw2-neuralmagic

Any Other Things

Multi-modal plugins remain supported

You can define additional modalities in MultiModalProcessingMetadata to handle your custom multi-modal plugins. If the names of those modalities are not valid keyword arguments to HF AutoProcessor, you can override the default multi-modal processor (similar to how you currently need to define _default_input_mapper for multi-modal plugins).

Some users currently use multi-modal plugins to directly pass custom model inputs (#6260). We can implement an alternative process_multimodal to help them migrate to the new processing framework.

No batched preprocessing for now

Currently, preprocessing is performed per prompt in vLLM. While we can call HF tokenizer and modality-specific processor on batched inputs separately, calling the wrapping HF AutoProcessor with both list of texts and list of multi-modal data results in the processed multi-modal data (e.g. image) being assigned to every text in the list, rather than the more intuitive zip-like behavior (e.g. the ith image only assigned to the ith text). To support batched preprocessing, we would have to write custom code for each model to combine the outputs of HF tokenizer and modality-specific processors. Given that this can significantly complicate model implementation (see Issue 1 above), we will not consider batched preprocessing at this stage, even with this change.

vllm-project / vllm